9 ms·
Young people ignore social media age limits
- jwcacces 11y agoNews at 11
- JabavuAdams 11y agoAlso, minors drink alcohol.
- elthran 11y agoand people don't read ToS
- JabavuAdams 11y agoWell, it's all about plausible deniability. The people who run these sites know that minors are using them, and it would be cost-prohibitive to make it really hard for minors to use them. So, instead, embed some text in your ToS and pretend to act shocked whenever confronted with direct evidence that people aren't complying with the ToS. It's the same for porn. An "are you 18?" page isn't going to stop anyone, but it shifts the blame from the publisher to the consumer.
- draugadrotten 11y ago> An "are you 18?" page isn't going to stop anyone, but it shifts the blame from the publisher to the consumer. That makes no sense, considering that someone under 18 is not able to enter into any contract (with the publisher) in most jurisdictions. compare: It would not be enough to ask "are you of legal age?" before serving alcohol to someone. Proof is required.
- arethuza 11y agoEnglish law is actually subtler than that: "As a general rule, a minor is not bound by contracts he makes, though the adult party whom he contracts with is"
- Falling3 11y agoIt's actually very common in Oregon to be asked if you're over 21 before having alcohol served to you (without being proofed).
- ChristianBundy 11y agoYeah, but that's not what's supposed to happen. They'd be more diligent if you looked younger.
- Swizec 11y agoPeople consider those popups to be legal contracts? That's funny.
- lordCarbonFiber 11y agoYour mistake here is missing the idea of "due diligence". Many laws (in the US especially) revolve around this concept. The basic gist is, has the concerned party taken "reasonable" (vague on purpose to adapt to evolving circumstance) action to comply with the law. In the instance of serving alcohol, everyone carries an id and carding is judged to be the level of "reasonable" action; in contrast, on the internet where access to identifying info is much sparser, user verification makes the cut. It's not a contract being form, it's the company in question performing the minimum viable verification to protect themselves from liability.
- JabavuAdams 11y ago> That makes no sense Correct. And yet, somehow, it's industry practice. That's my point.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rco8786 11y agoShocking
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoI assure you, those are not the only digital media/online age limits being ignored.
- yk 11y agoBasically a repost of http://www.theonion.com/article/i-am-under-18-button-clicked-for-first-time-in-his-6396 http://www.theonion.com/article/i-am-under-18-button-clicked...
- shockzzz 11y agothe youth are a menace
- delish 11y agoThe headline invites ridicule. A more descriptive headline would be, "That young people ignore social media age limits exposes them to bullying." When I was a 6th grader, I played Diablo II online. A player named "I-Dupe" told me he'd duplicate my items and give them to me. I thought he had a program to do this. I gave him my items, and he left the game. My items were not duped; I was. I bawled, and ran downstairs and yelled to my parents. They offered consolation and advice ("be careful online"). But you can tell my parents couldn't ameliorate my hurt feelings. If I could wave a magic wand, I'd turn this situation--wherein parents have to cope with the relationship between their kids and the web--to one where parents can do something about it. The ridicule I've seen in HN's comments just now demonstrates that age requirements don't work and appear disingenuous. I'm also skeptical of what someone from UK Safer Internet Centre said, "It's so important that we show children what other things they can do using digital technology that are engaging, creative and age-appropriate. It's about showing them what else it could be and inspiring them with that." When we make things for people "less" than us (young, less-tech-literate, etc), we often make something crappy[0]. [0] http://paulgraham.com/javacover.html http://paulgraham.com/javacover.html relevant excerpt: Like the creators of sitcoms or junk food or package tours, Java's designers were consciously designing a product for people not as smart as them. This "smart people creating for people less than them" problem is exacerbated with students. You can convince almost any unemployed adult to learn Java by telling them it's profitable, even if they can detect condescension. But students are just as good at detecting condescension, and these "engaging, creative, and age-appropriate" tools are probably made to occupy students' time, not make them money.
- josu 11y agoI thought the same thing, the fact that "Young people ignore X's age limits" is not new.
- cscharenberg 11y agoWhen they discover teenagers smoke and drink - which also exposes them to ridicule, whether they do it or not - it's going to shock them. If federal law, physical ID verification, active law enforcement, massive fines to parents doesn't eliminate drinking and smoking, why would people expect simple age limits stop signing up online? And yes, online activities open up an avenue for bullying. So does pretty much everything. We should work on that aspect, of preparing children for it and also cracking down on it. Perhaps a good step for AI chat bots would be monitoring online chat services and learning to detect bullying and taking actions: block all communication, warn a guardian, etc. Detecting harassment could be achievable long before real intelligence is achieved. And detection lets the child, the parent, or the service take many actions in response.
- bobby_9x 11y agoyeah, I've known this for a long time. On Reddit, for instance, I saw a discussion in /politics (by many, many users at the time) about why a 13 year old can still be just as mature and smart as someone over 18. I'm in my mid 30s and the only reason anyone would say this is if they are close to that age or they want to have sex with someone that age (and justify it).
- corin_ 11y agoI disagree (and for the record, not because I want to have sex with someone that age.) A 13 year old can be just as mature and smart as someone 18+, the reason the law exists is because it isn't the case nearly all of the time, and there's no simple way of judging on a case by case situation, so it's better to protect the 99(.9?)% of 13 year olds who need protecting. This doesn't justify any adult having sex with a 13 year old, regardless.
- bobby_9x 11y agoHow old are you? I only ask because a 13 year old cannot possibly have the experience, knowedge, or wisdom to be as smart as an average 18 year old. Unless of course, the 18 year old is really stupid or has some sort of disability.
- cbhl 11y agoIt's worth noting that a lot of these age limits are a result of COPPA, which is legislation that prohibits companies from tracking people under the age of 14 without parental permission. When this law was first introduced, a site that I used heavily as a minor required me to get a permission form signed and faxed by my parents before they'd unlock my account -- while I actually got them to do this, it would have been faster and easier to create a new account with a fake age. I think these laws need to be revamped, although because they only affect kids they're not really on anyone's radar (in the US, the deteriorating and underfunded school system is a more pressing problem). Companies end up tracking kids anyway through their parents, whether it's the "35-year-old female using Angry Birds" (actually their mother handing their phone to their kid on a train) or having your parents upload your baby photos to Facebook hours after your birth.
- tedks 11y agoThis is a bad title edit, if it was edited. The original title, "Safer Internet Day: Young ignore 'social media age limit'", at least focuses partially on the actual topic of the article, an event meant to raise awareness of online bullying. A better title edit would be "10-12 year olds report seeing, experiencing online bullying in spite of social media age limits". But, you know what else puts youth at risk for bullying? Going outside. Going to school. Being different. Liking things other kids don't like. Being gay. Being black. Being asian. Etc.. Random trolls on the internet can do orders of magnitude less psychological damage to a kid than their actual peers can by excluding them from activities in the real world and making the state-mandated 9-5 they go to an experience they dread. This sort of dominance behavior is likely a human evolutionary constant, but so are a lot of behaviors we've as a society decided are no longer acceptable. What will actually stop bullying is enforcing, across society and consistently in front of children, that it isn't acceptable to hurt other people to benefit yourself. I'm sure virtually every educator knows this, because they're usually trained in child psychology. So if you see an "educator" saying that the thing we really need is an "internet safe zone" "for the children" you should know where their loyalties really lie.
- DanBC 11y ago> at least focuses partially on the actual topic of the article Yes, sorry. I thought people would read the article before commenting, and it seems a few people didn't bother doing that.
- fweespeech 11y agoDoes anyone think something based on something like SMOG readability to check grade level + something like uClassify [or some other machine learning API for age:text correlation] would go a decent way towards fixing this? For sites that actually care about this sort of thing and aren't doing the legal minimum? [i.e. Take a 500 word sample from the user over their initial posts, test it against SMOG to see if it meets a minimum grade level. Test it against a machine learning tool to see if it estimates reasonable age. If it doesn't pass, disable the account and ask for ID and/or parental consent form]
- CM30 11y agoAnd young people ignore age limits for everything else. Just ask how many people under 18 watch ultra violent movies and what not. Or how many Call of Duty fans are under 17 years old (read, probably most of them). Or heck, how completely non effective COPPA is on internet forums. Seriously, the amount of people who care about it is maybe... 0.1% of the population? And practically speaking, you will never avoid this. Any form of tick box or date of birth verification is faked in seconds, any credit card details will just be taken from a parent or friend's account. Just like real life really. If a kid can't buy something on their own, their parents will probably just buy it for them. As for the claims of bullying and stuff... well sure. At least social media has a way of dealing with the issue (by banning accounts, blocking people from contacting each other, etc). That's ten times more effective than anything a school would ever do, especially given how the latter often just make the situation even worse by uneven enforcement and victim blaming. And hey, it's at least easier to ignore bullies online than in the real world.