4 ms·
> World War II, which is usually discussed in terms of atomic bombs and V-2 rockets; these contributions are summed up in the phrase “the physicists’ war.” I h
by dalke 11y ago
> World War II, which is usually discussed in terms of atomic bombs and V-2 rockets; these contributions are summed up in the phrase “the physicists’ war.”
I have two complaints about this complaint.
It overlooks the importance of radar and radar detection in WWII, and many of the people in radar development were physicists.
Second, WWI was "The Chemists' War." There's even a book by that name on the topic. That war is known for the use of chemical weapon attacks, and guess who made those weapons. I'll quote from summary on Amazon for Freemantle's book:
> Within months of the start of the First World War, Germany began to run out of the raw materials it needed to make explosives. As Germany faced imminent defeat, chemists such as Fritz Haber and Carl Bosch came to the rescue with Nobel Prize winning discoveries that overcame the shortages and enabled the country to continue in the war. Similarly, Britain could not have sustained its war effort for four years had it not been for chemists like Chaim Weizmann who was later to become the first president of the State of Israel. Michael Freemantle tells the stories of these and many other chemists and explains how their work underpinned and shaped what became known as The Chemists' War.
Thus, while coal hydrogenation helped Nazi Germany stay in the war, the Haber-Bosch process made the ammonia needed to produce the explosives that helped Kaiser Germany stay in the war.
Certainly chemists were important in WWII (as were mechanical engineers, aviation engineers, metal working, and many other specialties). But the appellation "the physicists’ war" also highlights the relative decrease in the role of chemistry on the actual fighting, compared to WWI.
- tcate 11y agoThis is a very strange view of the war. The Haber-Bosch process was invented before 35 years before WWII even started, and had been a staple of food and weapons production by the time the previous World War had finished. Far from helping the Nazis Fritz Haber died well before they even took power in Germany. Also Carl Bosch didn't Germany overcome imminent defeat, he was an anti-nazi who died in obscurity very early in the war. Personally I don't think you can sum up World War 2 as anyone's war. It spanned 6 years, 4 continents and engaged every area of science, politics and economics.
- Houshalter 11y agoHe was talking about world war one, not two.
- tcate 11y agoMy mistake, I missed the subject change to World War I.