3 ms·
Ever since David Hume[1], a couple of hundred years ago (and arguably long before him), causality has been recognized to stand on very shaky philosophical groun
by pmoriarty 11y ago
Ever since David Hume[1], a couple of hundred years ago (and arguably long before him), causality has been recognized to stand on very shaky philosophical grounds. It will be interesting to learn what statisticians can make of it. Even if there is in fact a firm mathematical foundation on which causality can rest, that in itself is problematic because mathematicians themselves have mostly given up trying to find foundations for mathematics.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Hume https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Hume
- stdbrouw 11y agoThey're different questions to some extent. In the statistical literature on causality, the counterfactual definition is almost universally accepted: if you do X then Y happens, but if you wouldn't have done X, Y wouldn't have happened. So the main challenge that statisticians are tackling is not the ontological question of whether causality can really be said to exist in the world, but rather the practical question of how to make measurements performed at different times, in different places, on different people, using different machinery, as comparable as possible.