3 ms·
"The effect of gravitational frequency shift on the GPS due to general relativity is that a clock closer to a massive object will be slower than a clock farther
by LeoPanthera 11y ago
"The effect of gravitational frequency shift on the GPS due to general relativity is that a clock closer to a massive object will be slower than a clock farther away. Applied to the GPS, the receivers are much closer to Earth than the satellites, causing the GPS clocks to be faster by a factor of 5×10^(−10), or about 45.9 μs/day. This gravitational frequency shift is noticeable.
When combining the time dilation and gravitational frequency shift, the discrepancy is about 38 microseconds per day, a difference of 4.465 parts in 10^10. Without correction, errors in the initial pseudorange of roughly 10 km/day would accumulate.
To compensate for the discrepancy, the frequency standard on board each satellite is given a rate offset prior to launch, making it run slightly slower than the desired frequency on Earth; specifically, at 10.22999999543 MHz instead of 10.23 MHz. Since the atomic clocks on board the GPS satellites are precisely tuned, it makes the system a practical engineering application of the scientific theory of relativity in a real-world environment. Placing atomic clocks on artificial satellites to test Einstein's general theory was proposed by Friedwardt Winterberg in 1955."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_analysis_for_the_Global_Positioning_System#Special_and_General_Relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_analysis_for_the_Global_...
- jessriedel 11y agoDoesn't shiva2012 specifically address this in his point? You are describing a slow drift that would accumulate over many days and eventually lead to an error, but that is avoided by regularly re-syncing the clock on the satellite and the ground ("clock drifts dealt with via regular ground synch"). In a hypothetical world where Einstein didn't figure out GR, nor the thousands of physicists who followed him in the intervening decades, the implication for GPS would be an unexplained drift that would be easily correctable though still mysterious.
- LeoPanthera 11y agoTo my knowledge there is no "ground sync" - as described in the previous quote, the clocks are intentionally set to run slightly slow in advance to offset the effects of relativity.
- Shiva2012 11y agoGround re-synchronization happens daily. "The clock and ephemeris corrections are uploaded generally about once per day (but some times more often if needed to maintain precision). The rubidium clock’s natural drift is large and might be of the order of 10^-13 per day" (quote from an engineer that works on the system)
- Shiva2012 11y agoThose are the theory numbers, not the results of experimentation. The 10 km/day number (with a bad reference) comes from removing the calculation of relativistic doppler and the sagnac effect. Without Einstein, classical doppler would be used and the difference would be tiny. Part of the considerations sometimes labeled "relativistic" are also those which compensate for the sagnac effect, this effect however, behaves no differently than classical expectation and was originally an experiment created by Sagnac to falsify special relativity. From an ECI frame, some changes to clock rates would be considered under a classical regime just like under the relativistic one. The sagnac effect is perfectly classical. (though without Sagnac trying to show Einstein wrong would we have the Sagnac effect understood well?) It's a personal interest of mine so I've directly contacted numerous engineers at the FAA who manage the GPS satellite system and even gotten a little info from Raymond DiEsposti. What it boils down to is that there is a negligible difference between relativity and classical in this context when you understand the system and all that would need to be considered under a classical treatment. Here's an entertaining quote (not perfectly explicative, but indicative of the larger issue): http://www.gps.gov/technical/icwg/IS-GPS-200H.pdf http://www.gps.gov/technical/icwg/IS-GPS-200H.pdf 20.3.3.5.2.3 page 123 Since the periodic relativistic effect is less than 25 meters, it need not be included in the time scale used for almanac evaluation. Over the span of applicability, it is expected that the almanac time parameters will provide a statistical URE component of less than 135 meters, one sigma. This is partially due to the fact that the error caused by the truncation of af0 and af1 may be as large as 150 meters plus 50 meters/day relative to the toa reference time. During extended operations (short-term and long-term) the almanac time parameter may not provide the specified time accuracy or URE component. Additionally, occasional CS actions to manage clock offsets may also inhibit the ability to provide specified almanac time parameter accuracies