6 ms·
I'd love to see if these MRI studies hold up if you select participants who are happily married or in long-term relationships of > 3 years length. The author's
by nostrademons 11y ago
I'd love to see if these MRI studies hold up if you select participants who are happily married or in long-term relationships of > 3 years length. The author's study selected participants with a maximum relationship length of 7.4 months. I dug up the Bartel's study referenced by it, and it had selected participants by putting out posters & Internet posts looking for people "truly, madly, and deeply in love", and got people with a relationship length of 2.4 +- 1.7 years:
http://www.vislab.ucl.ac.uk/pdf/NeuralBasisOfLove.pdf http://www.vislab.ucl.ac.uk/pdf/NeuralBasisOfLove.pdf
FWIW, I can recall crushing hard on girls up through college, with exactly the same drug-like intoxication that the article describes. But as I got more secure of myself and comfortable in my own skin, the crushes moderated. When I met my wife, there were no massive can't-stop-thinking-about-you highs, no obsessive yearning, few intrusive thoughts. It just felt natural - we enjoyed being together.
This was really disconcerting at first, like maybe it wasn't love after all, but I checked with a number of friends who were happily married for long (sometimes >10 years) periods. Very often, they mentioned the same feeling of not having the trumpets and whistles blow, and instead they grew together and found that love developed later on. Indeed, the people who were always "truly, madly, deeply in love" were usually broken up 2 months later.
I've heard a theory circulated round that when we feel that huge deep rush of intoxication, we're actually reading our "completion" into personal characteristics that the other person possesses. We're not so much in love with them as in love with the idea of being with them. And that limerence persists as long as the idea does, but eventually we all have to face the reality that we are not our partners, and we are not going to somehow become more or better than ourselves just by being with them. That huge mind-blinding rush of dopamine when you meet a new person might be an antipattern, because it blinds us from seeing the real them.
- shubhamjain 11y agoThis is very enlightening. I am not sure if people are aware but arranged marriages are still prevalent in India (which these days means being asked to meet someone and decide in few months if you would want to get married). Although, it seems a bit awkward and more of being forced into it but there is statistical evidence that it can work out really well. If people enjoy being together, love develops eventually.
- winter_blue 11y agoI've met some people from India who spent a grand total of 2-3 hours doing what people in the U.S. would call dating (spending time together; talking to each other) before deciding to marry them. I think that is really messed up. Marrying someone is one of the most important decisions you can make in your life, especially if you're planning to stick with them until you die. I think you need to spend at least a hundred hours (preferably, even more) together with a potential mate, before deciding whether you want to spend the rest of your life with them. A hundred hours together could be a 60 or 70 dinner dates, and weekends spent together, which you could do in less than 6 months. Everyone puts on a show in the first couple of dates, and it takes a little while to get to know who a person better / for who they really are.
- shubhamjain 11y ago> I've met some people from India who spent a grand total of 2-3 hours doing what people in the West would call "dating" (spending time together; talking to each other) before deciding to marry them. I am sure this happens widely and in many cases, the woman's consent isn't even taken, post-wedding is when the first conversation takes place. I agree this is unacceptable but in most metros, with less-conservative households, expectation is that they take their time before having a final say.
- indians_pro 11y agoHow can they have a wedding before a woman gives her consent?
- winter_blue 11y agoThat was a really good comment, thank you. > there were no massive can't-stop-thinking-about-you highs, no obsessive yearning, few intrusive thoughts. It just felt natural - we enjoyed being together This pretty much describes how I've felt while dating girls I've liked. I've never really had or experienced the "drug-like intoxication" obsession-love, and I'm glad I'm left out of it. I'm intrigued by your theory of why that it might due to a desire for "completion". I don't know if you're right, but it definitely is an interesting theory.
- philwelch 11y agoIn the polyamorous community, we refer to the initial drug-like rush you get in the first 3-12 months of a relationship as "NRE", for "new relationship energy". It is definitely much different from the kind of love you experience when a relationship gets up there in years.
- LesZedCB 11y agoWoah, hey, me too! Yeah, it's awesome to be able to meet other people and be excited by the prospect of new love. My partner and I have been dating for three years and transitioned to poly 2 years ago. It's been great for us both, having the excitement of new relationships while also having the strength of a longer relationship as well.
- mirimir 11y agoAnother way of looking at that experience is that you developed tolerance to crushes. I suspect that simple olfactory and visual cues drive crushing. But whatever the mechanisms, my experience has been very similar.
- danieltillett 11y agoYes it is much like alcohol - the first time you try it can be a bit of a disaster, but unless you are an alcoholic you learn how to imbibe without wrecking your life. The more you drink in moderation the better you handle the effects.
- scotty79 11y ago> The more you drink in moderation the better you handle the effects. Also, the more chance you have to become alcoholic.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoAnd above all love is self inflicted, and has very little to do with the other person. It's selfish in many ways, but I do not have the ability to expand on this.
- q-base 11y agoReally insightful and interesting comment. Thank you!
- cableshaft 11y agoGoing through that right now. The girl I've been with for the past seven months I've never really felt intense feelings for. But I really enjoy her company, and it's been much easier to keep the relationship going than previous ones, which always felt like I had to make serious effort to keep it going beyond a month or two. It used to really bother me that I didn't feel intense feelings of love and worried that maybe sometime I'd have to end things, but things keep going really well, and as we've shared more experiences together and mutually support each other, I've been having those thoughts less and less.
- scrupulusalbion 11y agoInfatuation is the word that I think should be used in place of love in this context. Most people want love, but seeking to get it immediately (instant gratification), dooms one to stay in the infatuation phase for lack of sober relating with the other person. If this is correct, then a high divorce rate would be the product of a high rate of instant gratification seeking.