10 ms·
Love Resembles Addiction
- blubb-fish 11y agohttp://www.pnas.org/content/113/5/1417 http://www.pnas.org/content/113/5/1417 Cocain destroys your mind - love heals it.
- jayess 11y agoLosing love has been the most unexpectedly devastating thing I've experienced.
- rdtsc 11y ago> I think romantic love is an addiction ... Or perhaps addiction is like romantic love. (Also noticed the first comment for that article also mentions this). Evolution probably had good reason to select an addiction center in the brain because, well ... those that didn't have and didn't fight for their loved ones, didn't start wars because of it, didn't care as much, somehow haven't made it this far. So that machinery seems to serve a purpose.
- danieltillett 11y agoEvolution never has a reason - it just is what tends to happen :) Having said this it is a really interesting question what could be the evolutionary force driving romantic love. My pet hypothesis is that it holds couples together long enough for their children to be too old to abandon.
- Houshalter 11y agoSince love came first, wouldn't it be more accurate to say cocaine is like love? But somehow that sounds worse.
- jMyles 11y ago> Since love came first Is this a certainty? Depending on how we define the dawn of "love," it seems at least vaguely plausible that it occurred after the first human consumption of coca. Of course if we're specifically talking about isolated cocaine then you're correct for sure.
- rosser 11y agoCoca is a "new world" plant, growing only in the Andes mountains. As best we can tell, there've only been homo sapiens sapiens on that continent for a few tens of thousands of years, at the outside. The hormonal basis for the phenomenon we call "love" is without doubt older than that.
- jMyles 11y agoWe don't really know though, right? Coca may have been Pangaeal. There's a lot about the prehistory of plant medicine that's difficult to really know.
- mirimir 11y agoYes, my thought precisely. There's also cross-tolerance ;) But cocaine can be far more intense. Once you burn out those dopamine channels, they don't come back. You lose, more or less permanently, the ability to love, or even care very deeply.
- jaytaylor 11y agoYour comment prompted me to do a quick search; interesting concept. Thanks! http://mobile.nytimes.com/2010/08/31/health/views/31mind.html http://mobile.nytimes.com/2010/08/31/health/views/31mind.htm...
- ktRolster 11y agoThat's brutal. I'm never doing drugs.
- mirimir 11y agoThat's one option. But for sure, one should be careful with drugs that down-regulate receptors, especially those that do so long-term or permanently. As cocaine does. Receptor down-regulation is the mechanism for biological addiction. Cocaine is less addictive than nicotine, ethanol or opiates. You need considerable high-dose exposure to do serious damage. But once it's done, you're screwed.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- scotty79 11y agoThanks for this article. Made me block random facebook posts from the girl I spent 7 years being addicted to. I don't want to get any unexpected cues that could trigger pathways forged by this addiction.
- scotty79 11y agoCan you burn dopamine channels with love or is that something specific to cocaine that naturally produced substances don't do at achievable levels?
- abalashov 11y agoI think it varies by cultural extraction and emotional background. My life experience suggests that people from "warm" and "romantic" cultures are more likely to experience the highs of falling in love than people from more measured, rationalistic and phlegmatic cultures. Being from a "warm and romantic" background myself, I can confirm that falling in love is very much intoxicating. It alters one's frame of mind and leads to decisions one simply would not make for any other reason. Some of them are quite momentous and have lasting impact indeed.
- trentmb 11y agoI grew up in the care of parents that decided to stay together for the children. I can't really complain--they both love me--I grew up in a safe middle class environment, one of them always read with me at night when I was young, I never worried about being hungry, got toys on x-mas, etc. They certainly never abused me. But to this day I struggle with relationships. I have a hard time connecting with people, even in a non-romantic context. Man, I realize I don't know anyone who's going to read this, but it feels real good to confess it to someone. EDIT: To be honest, I feel like such an asshole. There are people that have had it way worse than me, and here I am feeling sorry for myself.
- abalashov 11y agoDon't feel like an asshole. Life is complicated and turbulent - everyone's. It's easy to forget that when watching TV or browsing Facebook, which beam only idealised portraits and high notes into our minds--the conscious and unconscious parts. It's easy to think everyone has their shit together and you're the only fuckup, but you couldn't be more wrong. In reality, a lot more parents stayed together for the kids than you realise. Decades of marriage aren't easy to sustain for anyone, no matter what their personalities or notional compatibility. Many more people struggled and struggle with depression, alcoholism or substance abuse than meets the eye. There's a veneer of comme il faut civilisation over it all, but it's very thin. Actually-existing reality is messy. The world is messy. Don't forget that you only see the curated--in some cases scrupulously curated--presentation layer of almost everyone else's life. It's almost like going to a Quixtar-Amway IBO motivational conference/Sieg Heil cult rally, or any trade show consisting primarily of account reps, crazed MBA apes and sales bullshitters; it'll seem like everyone's a successful millionaire except you, because that's the whole point of the venture. Nobody would pay expensive registration fees to attend a grim, morose and sober appraisal of the ups and downs of the casino that is their life. In reality, 89% of them are broke.
- sdegutis 11y agoReal love is actually pretty good for you altogether, body and mind, emotionally and psychologically. But that's not what most people think of as "love".
- liamconnell 11y ago> Few academics and laymen regard romantic love as an addiction I think dozens on pop songs say otherwise. Jazz: "Like someone in love" "you go to my head" Pop: Kelly Clarkson's "Addicted", Kanye's "Addiction", Kesha "You're love is my drug" (and those are just the "K" artists!)...
- agumonkey 11y agoGretchen Parlato cover of SWV's weak made me aware of this: 'when the cause and cure is you.' that illustrate the situation pretty well.
- michaelwww 11y agoI was in a crazy addicted love relationship once in my life in 2007 and it scared us both because of it's irrational power and what the article terms "intrusive thinking." We met on StumbleUpon and were attracted by our shared sensibilities at first, later much more than that after we met. About that time, when it was getting crazy, we both read the story of game designer Theresa Duncan[1] and artist Jeremy Blake[2], two lovers who committed suicide within a week of one another. She and I broke it off after that. It seemed like the smart thing to do. I would have scoffed at this article if I had not had a very real experience of what the article is describing. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theresa_Duncan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theresa_Duncan [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremy_Blake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremy_Blake
- mahmud 11y agoWe didn't. I met a girl overseas and within 24 hours we moved in together. Obsessive, all encompassing, "can't take my eyes off you" love. I moved continents to be with her; 8 years together, married for 4. Then suddenly, early last year, it all fell apart as quickly as it started. Finalizing divorce next month. It was crazy, but I feel blessed to have experienced it. We're still good friends, but the thrill is gone, well and truly. I was actually relieved when she said she was having an affair. Good, I thought, better you than me; now let's end this.
- michaelwww 11y agoI think we anticipated that it could turn cold equally fast and intensely, but good for you for making it work 8 years. Sorry about your divorce.
- delazeur 11y agoStories like yours make me wonder if "marriage for life" is even a worthwhile goal.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoIt certainly is not for everyone. We should accept that everything has its lifetime and end it when it is over instead of prolonging it.
- tyingq 11y agoI'm reminded of these lyrics... "Love is like oxygen...You get too much you get too high... Not enough and you're gonna die"
- qohen 11y agoLong (album) version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRVwcPTnug8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRVwcPTnug8 Short (single) version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTlM6OBRc8w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTlM6OBRc8w By Sweet: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sweet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sweet (You may know them better for The Ballroom Blitz: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_jdiU47bFA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_jdiU47bFA ).
- noobermin 11y agoIf not love, then what else? Couldn't someone say you're addicted to work? To entrepreneurship? Solving problems? Or for many here, hacking?
- wanda 11y agoSolving problems ⊃ hacking (Not being pedantic, I just like set theory symbols and never get to use them)
- noobermin 11y agoProbably the better superset is intellectual stimulation. Hacking, strategy games, crossword puzzles...all fall under that moniker, and are they so addicting too! It's just of great luck that unlike cocaine or love, hacking can lead to returns in other utilities like in money and a career.
- nostrademons 11y agoI'd love to see if these MRI studies hold up if you select participants who are happily married or in long-term relationships of > 3 years length. The author's study selected participants with a maximum relationship length of 7.4 months. I dug up the Bartel's study referenced by it, and it had selected participants by putting out posters & Internet posts looking for people "truly, madly, and deeply in love", and got people with a relationship length of 2.4 +- 1.7 years: http://www.vislab.ucl.ac.uk/pdf/NeuralBasisOfLove.pdf http://www.vislab.ucl.ac.uk/pdf/NeuralBasisOfLove.pdf FWIW, I can recall crushing hard on girls up through college, with exactly the same drug-like intoxication that the article describes. But as I got more secure of myself and comfortable in my own skin, the crushes moderated. When I met my wife, there were no massive can't-stop-thinking-about-you highs, no obsessive yearning, few intrusive thoughts. It just felt natural - we enjoyed being together. This was really disconcerting at first, like maybe it wasn't love after all, but I checked with a number of friends who were happily married for long (sometimes >10 years) periods. Very often, they mentioned the same feeling of not having the trumpets and whistles blow, and instead they grew together and found that love developed later on. Indeed, the people who were always "truly, madly, deeply in love" were usually broken up 2 months later. I've heard a theory circulated round that when we feel that huge deep rush of intoxication, we're actually reading our "completion" into personal characteristics that the other person possesses. We're not so much in love with them as in love with the idea of being with them. And that limerence persists as long as the idea does, but eventually we all have to face the reality that we are not our partners, and we are not going to somehow become more or better than ourselves just by being with them. That huge mind-blinding rush of dopamine when you meet a new person might be an antipattern, because it blinds us from seeing the real them.
- shubhamjain 11y agoThis is very enlightening. I am not sure if people are aware but arranged marriages are still prevalent in India (which these days means being asked to meet someone and decide in few months if you would want to get married). Although, it seems a bit awkward and more of being forced into it but there is statistical evidence that it can work out really well. If people enjoy being together, love develops eventually.
- miteinander 11y agoThis particular trope of equating romantic love and substance addiction is annoying and fundamentally confused. It doesn't take neurology to understand that any activity from which we derive pleasure could, given the right circumstances or wrong attitudes, lead to a self-destructive spiral. And if one is aware that dopamine and other neurotransmitters are how pleasure is "implemented" in the brain, research which correlates a pleasurable experience with adaptive dopamine responses is pretty yawn-inducing. Even if one doesn't agree that the factual content of this research is boring, rather than salacious, I think the conclusions drawn here are vastly premature given our current understanding of the brain. Imagine that somebody with a tool to "see" electrical currents (an oscilloscope? CAT scan? I don't know) was looking at my computer, first as I unleash a massive DDOS attack on some unsuspecting evildoers, and then as I put my latest philosophical writings on my ftp server for all my rabid fans. In both cases they'd see my NIC go crazy, working itself to death to blast out packets to either badly configured DNS servers or badly confused human beings (as it happens, these human being strongly resemble cocaine addicts when it comes to reading highly digressive rants composed by yours truly). So, is hosting an essay on an FTP server "the same" as initiating a DDOS? Yes, I suppose either one could fry my network adapter, but that's pretty contingent. So, how exactly are they different, and what does this have to do with cocaine? Restricting ourselves to what's happening inside the computer, the differences reside atop a massive tower of abstraction. And what's more, these differences put down shallow roots. Even with an understanding of the von neumann architechure generally or my intel chip in particular, most physical ("neurological") measurements one could make would look pretty damn similar. One would have to understand the dynamic relationship between the cpu state register, my RAM chips, and my Hard Drive to even begin to grok what's "really" going on. I think neuroscience is in a state analogous to that of a man measuring currents in a modern computer. Even if it turns out that in certain neurological ways love and cocaine are completely identical, it may turn out that the similarities are completely overshadowed by subtler states in a different subsystem. We don't understand brain architecture, so who knows. And really, the crux of the difference between the DDOS and rabid fans downloading my latest essay in beautiful LaTeX formatting has to do with the way the activity is situated in the relationship between me and the social world in which I exist. And the same is true of the difference between love and cocaine addiction. Courtship is a foundational human activity, one that profoundly shapes our cultural practices and understanding of ourselves. Of course it changes us! What the hell is meant by "Normal Altered State?" What is an "unaltered" human state? Being a human is inherently a state of profound embeddedness in a culture which originates in others. And another human being, who is also a rich and complex cultural creature, has immeasurably more to offer than the cruel, contentless, solipsistic chokehold of a drug addiction. Take it from somebody who has both.
- coolandsmartrr 11y agoI wonder what chemical reactions occur inside our brains and bodies when we "fall in love." Reminds me of Rick and Morty, which refers to love as purely a symptom of secreting oxytocin.
- dschiptsov 11y agoOh, really?
- solidsnack9000 11y ago> Modern data suggest that romantic love should be treated as an addiction, regardless of its lack of official diagnostic classification as an addiction. What would this mean in practice? Court-ordered rehab?
- scotty79 11y agoFor stalkers, perhaps. Might be beneficial.
- codeshaman 11y agoTrue, mad love is a beautiful experience, maybe the most powerful and satisfying thing that can happen to you. I have been lucky to have experienced it once and now, 8 years later we still have it in us. Of course it doesn't manifest in endless nights of looking into each other's eyes, but we still cherish that period as a gift from God himself. Yes it does resemble an addiction, although maybe it's worth reversing the terms - addiction is actually like "true" love. Everything in our lives just clicked - we'd just moved to the beautiful city of Barcelona, it was spring time and flowers were in bloom, we had money, more than we could spend and we traveled around and experienced each other through Europe - Paris, Amsterdam, Lisbon, Brussels, Stockholm, Athens, Vienna, ... Every week in a different city, weather was always great, the food and wine were fantastic - but all that beauty around us was pale in comparison to the look in her eyes. That look - when this beautiful girl looks at you like you are everything for her and you feel like she's everything for you - like you are the perfect drugs for each other - that is a powerful and fulfilling experience. That's what it feels like to be blessed. Our daughter is the result of that love and we often joke that our love was actually the effect of her coming into this world. Drugs don't really come close to the powerful emotions that we can generate naturally when we are in love - I can only compare it to an MDMA trip that lasts for months... That love has carried us through the difficult moments of having a child and careers in our modern, artificial society and we would have been separated many times had it not been for those memories.
- greggman 11y agoI love your story. I hate that can't tell if I should wait for that or "settle" for the feeling others describe of "just well comfortable". I keep waiting for, searching for, your style of relationship but all I find, generally, is the "this is comfortable" style which while pleasant is also mostly "take it or leave it" kind of feeling for me. For lack of a better way it's nice while together but it's mostly "out sight out of mind".
- satyajeet23 11y agoLOVE IS LIKE COCAINE!
- InclinedPlane 11y agoWhich one has been around longer? Think the comparison might be backward.
- ajuc 11y agoI'm quite sure plants were there before humans.
- pingou 11y agoThere's a documentary about this with the scientist who wrote the article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sleepless_in_New_York https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sleepless_in_New_York
- tiatia 11y agoLove and Addiction http://www.amazon.com/Love-Addiction-Stanton-Peele-ebook/dp/B00IVAQQOK http://www.amazon.com/Love-Addiction-Stanton-Peele-ebook/dp/...
- ahussain 11y agoThis is one of the reasons to read Infinite Jest - it explores the concept of addiction with incredible depth and interest. I love the idea that many things in life can be modeled as addictions. Abstractly, an addiction takes the pattern of long periods of misery (plateau) interrupted by brief moments of ecstasy - what's special about an addiction is that it feels like the moments of ecstasy are worth it. This pattern is similar to that involved in learning a new skill, or going through a personality change.
- liveoneggs 11y agohappy valentines day! the onslaught of "love"-based articles is great.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoThis is a good example of why love is so misunderstood. What is being described in the article is closer to desire than love. The two are not the same, though desire can be the gateway towards love. Loving relationships aren't defined by codependency, though desire and love can exist together. I'm not a Christian, but the best description of love (that I know of) is found in the Bible... https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1+Corinthians+13:4-8 https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1+Corinthians+1...
- vinceguidry 11y agoI wouldn't be so quick to label and put experiences into boxes. Your experience and your culture and your understanding of love can be so different than another person's that labels mostly just get in the way. To look at it in information-theoretic terms, you need a higher-bandwidth channel to communicate about "core" experiences like love. Labels condense information by encoding culture and definition into them. So it's tempting to reach for them. But if the person you're communicating with doesn't share the same culture and definition, then you wind up mis-communicating until you can work out the source of the disconnect. Labels are great for talking about computer software systems. Not so much for love. For me, and to use your terms, I can't feel romantic love for someone without also having desire for them. I can care deeply for them, want the best for them whether it's with or without me, but in order for me to have a loving relationship with someone, desire has to be a constant undercurrent. I cannot spend copious amounts of time with a person otherwise, I start to retreat back into myself. Desire is that thing that draws me out and allows others in, it's absolutely essential. So, while your love / desire divide may work well enough for your purposes, it won't necessarily for other people. You can try to adapt the framework to accommodate them, but do this too many times and you're left with a mess. It's best to just share your own experiences with as plain of language as you can and let other people come up with their own abstractions.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "Desire is that thing that draws me out and allows others in, it's absolutely essential." That's what I meant by saying that desire can be the gateway to love. Desire helps you commit, love can grow from that point on.
- pcvarmint 11y agoStanton Peele made this observation 40 years ago.