6 ms·
Why is it widely condemned when North Korea launches a satellite? Why does the article quote North Korea's "right" to explore space in a peaceful manner? Just
by Tepix 11y ago
Why is it widely condemned when North Korea launches a satellite?
Why does the article quote North Korea's "right" to explore space in a peaceful manner?
Just wondering.
It's not like plenty of other states are putting military satellites in orbit without asking anyone for permission.
- madaxe_again 11y agoIndeed. I'm actually impressed by the technical achievement - putting something into a (nearly) circular polar orbit is no mean feat. As for the "it's an ICBM test!" crowd - bollocks. That's like saying the Boeing 747 was a test to see if manned flight is possible - total overengineering. Also, for context, what exactly do folks think soyuz goes into space on? A magical peace rocket? No. It goes up on an R-7, which is an ICBM - the very first developed, in fact. That nasty ICBM technology has kept the ISS running. The Mercury programme redstone rockets that put Americans in space - also ballistic missiles that had had warheads replaced with crew capsules. Should America and Russia have been condemned by the world? By the standards being applied here, yes. So, shake your fist all you like, but regardless of their politics this is a technical coup, and I congratulate them on a successful launch.
- mikeash 11y agoYou say the ICBM connection is bollocks, then discuss the extensive links between the two. That seems slightly contradictory.
- gozur88 11y ago>As for the "it's an ICBM test!" crowd - bollocks. That's like saying the Boeing 747 was a test to see if manned flight is possible - total overengineering. Not true. The North Koreans aren't at the point yet where they can miniaturize nuclear bombs, so if they're going to make a system that can deliver nuclear warheads, it's going to need to be something like this.
- vpribish 11y agoyou are deeply wrong, friend. Our, and the soviet, rocket development was very clearly ICBM development - thats no secret. North Korea is quite obviously following the same path. Yes, it is a technical accomplishment - no they are not to be congratulated : do you live in a cave? They are universally condemned not because they can do engineering, but because they are an affront to civilization.
- ForHackernews 11y agoBecause it's widely assumed that this satellite launch is a test-bed for a nuclear-warhead ICBM.
- viraptor 11y ago> Why does the article quote North Korea's "right" to explore space in a peaceful manner? Because if you run through the street, it's normal. If you run through the street shouting that you're exercising your right to run through the street in a peaceful manner, it's being super suspicious. (like naming state-controlled newspaper "The Truth") Also because everyone is aware they're experimenting with serious weapons and act as if they are disconnected from consequences, so it's worth paying attention.
- Outdoorsman 11y agoThe launch has already been condemned by the UN Security Council... http://www.cnn.com/2016/02/07/asia/north-korea-rocket-launch-window/ http://www.cnn.com/2016/02/07/asia/north-korea-rocket-launch...
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y ago> act as if they are disconnected from consequences One suspects that pretty much everybody in the NK leadership is aware of the last few decades of international sanctions.
- viraptor 11y agoWere there any real changes though? They may be aware and happy to just live with the sanctions / embargoes.
- CamperBob2 11y agoSanctions are only a problem for the little people. The governing elites aren't missing any steak, iPhones, and caviar.
- brg1007 11y ago> Why is it widely condemned when North Korea launches a satellite? Because 18 million reasons.[1] When so many people are always on the brink of famine, you can stop "playing war" and you can help your people in need. [1]http://reliefweb.int/report/democratic-peoples-republic-korea/un-emergency-fund-releases-us-8-million-assist-most http://reliefweb.int/report/democratic-peoples-republic-kore...
- gozur88 11y ago>Why is it widely condemned when North Korea launches a satellite? Because most countries view it as a cover for an ICBM program. Anything that can launch a satellite into orbit can carry a nuke to the other side of the world. >Why does the article quote North Korea's "right" to explore space in a peaceful manner? Doesn't it have that right? Who is to say North Korea can't launch satellites? This is a tricky thing for other countries to navigate. We really don't have the right to tell them they can't have satellites or nuclear power. Other countries collectively launch satellites every week or so, and there are 438 operating nuclear reactors. On the other hand... nobody trusts the Norks, and with good reason. I guess it's like interpersonal communications - reputation matters.
- mikeash 11y agoReputation and precedent. It's long past time to complain about the US's ICBMs. And for everyone sarcastically wondering why the US gets a pass, I'm pretty sure there was a lot of criticism at the time over the US's (and Soviets') nuclear buildup.
- Outdoorsman 11y agoI backpacked Australia in 1986... I was asked, very straightforwardly, by a woman I met,"Why does Ronald Reagan want to destroy the world with nuclear weapons?"...I replied that I doubted very much that he did... The U.S. has certainly received scrutiny abroad...
- gozur88 11y agoStill, can't you see it from their side? I'm pretty sure if I were running North Korea or Iran I'd be doing whatever I needed to do to acquire a credible nuclear deterrent. Particularly after Libya. When the US invaded Iraq the Libyans decided the best way to avoid the same fate was to accede to demands from the West. They gave up their nuclear program, paid compensation for Lockerbie, and generally stopped messing with other countries. And when it was convenient, we (mostly the UK and France, but the US too) provided the air power to overthrow the Libyan government. Kadaffi himself was tortured to death. If you're Kim Jong Un, what lesson do you draw from that sequence of events?
- jackgavigan 11y agoThe UN Security Council has banned North Korea from developing ballistic missile technology. There's not much difference between a rocket that's capable of putting a satellite into orbit and an intercontinental ballistic missile. In fact, Sputnik was launched using an ICBM.