6 ms·
Apple Bans the Word 'Android' From App Store
- mattfitzgerald 17y agoCurrently deciding whether to buy an iPhone or an android phone. This has made the decision easy - android all the way.
- zitterbewegung 17y agoApp stores are generally broken because you can have the ability to ban things. We should have an open appstore.
- Mark_B 17y ago"He who controls the Spice controls the universe"
- litewulf 17y agoOR allow people to install things by means other than the appstore.
- cookiecaper 17y agoYou can install Android apps from anywhere. EDIT: See http://en.androidwiki.com/wiki/Applications http://en.androidwiki.com/wiki/Applications
- nuclear_eclipse 17y agoExcept with Android, you're free to distribute or install applications through alternate apparently stores, or directly through the internet with .apk files. If Apple allowed that on the iPhone, nobody would care if they banned something from their "blessed" channel...
- elai 17y agoSame with palm pre, except it's ipk files. You can also use a free application hosting version of their "app store", where palm hosts a link to your app, no approval processes/money necessary. It doesn't appear in the catalog this way although.
- Zak 17y agoThe mechanism of banning apps is useful so that users can have a trusted place to get apps known to be free of malware. The way to make sure that mechanism doesn't result in evil policy is to allow an alternate means of installing software. Google does this. Apple does not.
- buster 17y agoand mentioning android in the app description is in which way malware? i see the point in verifying apps that need security (banking mostly). but that doesnt account for 99.99% of apps. Plus, mostly what you hear about which apps where banned, it's not about security. It's about bookreaders that can show the kamasutra (which the browser can, too). It's about software that "replicates" apples functionality. You will never have alternative browsers or mail programs and be tied to apples mercy. I have the choice. Let's face it, the appstore is apples way to have control over its customers.
- dtby 17y agoi see the point in verifying apps that need security (banking mostly). I don't understand how you're using "security" in this sentence.
- AlisdairO 17y agoAlthough this approach creates an opportunity for much easier piracy of applications, too.
- joeyo 17y agoThere are a couple of alternative app stores for Android (I'm not sure what would make them "open", they're certainly more open than the Apple one, but that goes for the official Google Market, too. Here are the ones that I know of for android: * http://slideme.org/ http://slideme.org/ * http://mikandi.com/ http://mikandi.com/ [adult] * http://www.handango.com/ http://www.handango.com/ * http://onlyandroid.mobihand.com/ http://onlyandroid.mobihand.com/
- sjs 17y agoAs someone who currently has an iPhone, you made the right decision. I love my iPhone, but sometimes it feels too much like Apple's iPhone rather than my iPhone. Android for me next.
- blub 17y agoYou're ok with the AppStore and the Apple policies in general, but when they forbid one guy from using the Android tm in an app suddenly Apple becomes the bad guy? I don't like Apple at all, but your decision process seems incorrect.
- chappi42 17y agoMost/lots of people probably _aren't_ ok with Apple policies but accept it pragmatically because the device and the apps are that good. Now with alternatives at hand (Android/Palm Pre) and policies getting worse it's very understandable that there is a point people say: enough!
- bad_user 17y agoI saw a Nexus One the other day on one of my colleagues ... it's pretty awesome. Has aprox. the same size as an iPhone, and the apps are really OK. The only thing missing is multi-touch because of Apple's patent, but I didn't saw much of a difference ... and apparently you can activate multi-touch support. It's a pretty cool phone ... if iPhone wasn't the first to come out, the Nexus One would be an instant hit. Unfortunately being as good as the iPhone is not enough, but its real strength will be its openness ... for example you can install Flash on it :)
- surfmike 17y agoMultitouch support was added with this week's update.
- simanyay 17y agoCan't wait for Apple banning apps because their developers use GMail.
- ryanwaggoner 17y agoApple does have something of a weird relationship with Google at the moment...Gmail is one of the email providers on the iPhone with "express" setup, and they have pre-installed apps for Google Maps and Youtube. On the other hand, Android. Seems like a perfect opportunity for MSFT.
- snprbob86 17y agoTo be fair, Gmail's express setup is somewhat unsanctioned. Gmail's documentation explicitly advises against the use of that express setup button: What if I tap 'Gmail' instead? Archiving and deleting messages will work differently. Our instructions ensure Gmail works as designed. http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=77702 http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answe...
- pbz 17y agoI guess MSFT doesn't have a mobile operating system...
- tszming 17y agoevil
- electromagnetic 17y agovs good!
- chanux 17y agoMy gut feeling Google vs Apple: Whoever wins, we lose. But about android phones, it's more freer than iPhone anyway.
- ryanwaggoner 17y agoIt's hard to understand how an organization as savvy as Apple could do something like this. What do they really think they're going to get out of it, other than bad press? I'm not even saying that the tradeoffs aren't worth it, but that there's no upside at all. What possible benefit could this have?
- techiferous 17y ago"What possible benefit could this have?" I was wondering this, too. Perhaps Apple has a policy of avoiding mentioning other platforms because it could confuse the end user. Remember that many people don't even know the difference between a browser and a search engine.
- pyre 17y agoHe was only mentioning a competing platform in a manor of speaking. Someone that doesn't know what Android is would just know that his app was a finalist in a competition, no?
- techiferous 17y agoAgreed completely. But I was just trying to wonder why they had the policy in the first place. In large bureaucracies, policies inevitably have weird edge cases.
- 9oliYQjP 17y agoActually it's really simple to understand. Last time I checked, Google had a trademark on the word Android. An integral part of trying to assert a trademark is enforcing certain usages. Otherwise people start calling all similar products by your product's name (e.g., paper tissues become Kleenex) and you lose that trademark. From Google themselves (http://www.google.com/permissions/guidelines.html http://www.google.com/permissions/guidelines.html): "One of the conditions for all uses is that you can't mess around with our marks. Only we get to do that. Don’t remove, distort or alter any element of a Google Brand Feature. That includes modifying a Google trademark, for example, through hyphenation, combination or abbreviation, such as: Googliscious, Googlyoogly, GaGooglemania. Do not shorten, abbreviate, or create acronyms out of Google trademarks" ... "Don’t incorporate Google Brand Features into your own product name, service names, trademarks, logos, or company names." My money is on either Apple's lawyers or Google's lawyers coming up with this policy. I know it's en vogue to jump on Google as the knight in shining armour and Apple as the villain, but let's not jump to conclusions here.
- st3fan 17y agoHey, it is their store ... whatever they want.
- pyre 17y agoDoes that mean that we have to approve of what they do? I don't think that anyone is claiming that they don't have the 'right' to do it.
- Que 17y agoWell can you blame Apple?.. they didn't want to have their infallible image tarnished by having an top ADC app advertising that it was designed for a competing platform. [/sarcasm] Boo
- marshallp 17y agoi think steve jobs does these kinds of these things just to get press - it doesn't matter if they're percieved evil or good - poeple will love him and buy his products anyway
- qjz 17y agoThe title of the article is misleading. It's not like they rejected a game named "Android Apocalypse." Why should they host any content that promotes another platform?
- lt 17y agoThe application in question has not even been rejected, much less mass banning of apps that contain the word happened. They just suggested not to mention the competitor's platform: While your application has not been rejected, it would be appropriate to remove 'Finalist in Google's Android Developer's Challenge!' from the Application Description I can understand why that would be appropriate. Most users would have no idea what Google's Android Developer's Challenge is: "How do I download the other finalist apps?" "I bought this application that says it's Android - how do I run it in my wife's Nexus One?". Not to mention the courtesy of not promoting competitors products in one vendor's own turf. This is a huge overreaction by the PCWorld editor to linkbait you all. Even the application author thought it was reasonable. I'm surprised no one had picked up on this yet.
- patio11 17y agoNot to mention the courtesy of not promoting competitors products in one vendor's own turf. I remember a time when it was widely believed that a large technology company being able to dictate what firms had access to its market was something akin to it being the bastard child of Ma Bell and Hitler.
- donaq 17y agoWhile I agree that the article title was linkbait, I think the author had a valid point in noting that mentioning that the app was a finalist in a big competition does help in vouching for the app's usefulness. This isn't something that Apple should be discouraging, and the fact that they do does make them seem, well, petty.
- 9oliYQjP 17y agoThe app wasn't a finalist. You can't enter an iPhone app in an Android competition. Logic like this is what makes people think Microsoft Office for Mac is as full featured as Microsoft Office on Windows. They're too very different products with different codebases and functionality that attempt to mimic some behaviour between each other. Have you seen the frustration of an Office:Mac user when they realize, for instance, that they can't do something simple like get Entourage to work with an Exchange server or get Office to connect to Sharepoint?
- maxmason 17y agoApple is being stupid, it makes them look bad and does Google's job for them.
- Dbug 17y agoThe article makes use of straw-man argument by bring up VOIP apps. But the avoiding of mentioning a competing app seems reasonable. If there was a Zune store I don't think any would think it appropriate for apps to mention the iPod. The developer can always encourage people to visit their website, and provide more company/product history there.
- thaumaturgy 17y agoFlagged due to headline and sensationalist content.
- blhack 17y agoThis really contributes a lot to the discussion, thanks.
- lsc 17y ago"I guess I'm just old-fashioned: I like to receive my content unfiltered and make my own decisions." then, why are you using an apple product? Part of the iphone value proposition is that they do that filtering.