5 ms·
Games from people like World of Goo are exciting. I wasn't sure how I'd even imagine a game that could teach skills with good mapping to programming. They're do
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Games from people like World of Goo are exciting. I wasn't sure how I'd even imagine a game that could teach skills with good mapping to programming. They're doing a good job. Prior to that, the best results we were getting were projects like the brilliant MIT Scratch that turned it into collaborative, creative, lego building (below). Should still invest in stuff like that, too, which is more direct but fun.
https://scratch.mit.edu/ https://scratch.mit.edu/
On other hand, that programming is a fundamental skill is an assertion that's being repeated by many without evidence. It's a useful skill that will become more useful as we go along. Yet, something like 80-90% of America, including top 1%, know nothing about programming despite their job success or quality of life. There's no direct tie in. Meanwhile, they use reading/writing and mathematics on a regular basis. So, I think people should stop making this claim as most people will mentally tune out upon seeing something like that.
This brings to a bigger point where software isn't engineered despite prior work showing how to do it. That started with Margaret Hamilton and Dijkstra in the 1960's where both of them used modularity, layering, and interface checks to build flawless systems. By the 1980's, Hansen had safe concurrency (Concurrent Pascal), Mill's Cleanroom let teams hit almost no defects first try, LISP machines let you live-edit, incrementally-develop running systems w/ no compile phase, Schell had a NSA-resistant kernel (GEMSOS) that ran other things as processes/containers on virtual CPU's (sound familiar?), and Wirth's simplicity + safe language approaches let ETH run on their students' OS's. Each of these approaches led, with small teams, to systems that reached high levels of security, reliability, extensibility, and (for Lisp machines) productivity.
Yet, the techniques that built them are largely not used by mainstream. The negative results are predictable. So, we have two problems: (a) getting nonprogrammers into programming so they can solve problems with some approach and toolset; (b) getting programmers into engineering so they can build robust, maintainable systems using lessons learned from the past. Like other engineering fields do. So far, we're doing better at (a). Some good news at least.
- contingencies 11y agoAt the risk of stating the obvious, (b) doesn't progress because it's more expensive and often unnecessary. In the cases where it would be useful, when TCO incorporating whole lifecycle costs such as maintenance and/or rebuilds are considered, (b) is still often a failure because it requires higher lead time and up front investment. That's not to say there's no space for very carefully built systems, just that they're a niche and likely always will be, particularly as hardware is now basically free and improved tooling (eg. popularization of CI) helps to reduce the difference between one-off hacks and "robust, maintainable" systems built with knowledge of prior work and theory.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoRegarding expensive, empirical tests found the medium assurance methods to cost either the same or cheaper due to huge reductions in debugging or maintenance issues. This was the case for Fagan Inspections, Cleanroom especially, TSP, and iterative methods with safer languages. Far as high assurance, the level of assurance is usually applied to a high level design or some small, critical component. The cost reported for LOCK was about 30% extra on top of a solid lifecycle. Same percentage for security costs of one Special Access Program. A small team did an EAL7 IPsec VPN in relatively short time. I'd love to know cost overhead of Praxis Correct by Construction. seL4 cost a few million for highest extreme. So, applied correctly, even high assurance methods result in a reasonable premium for certain industries. Niche as you said. Time to market is another story with high assurance killing that. Yet, medium assurance is nearly as fast and around same price as solid lifecycle while paying dividends later. So, the cost and lead time objections are a misconception if we're aiming for medium level which is merely high quality. It benefits long-term better than alternatives. Only exception is bottom-dollar deals and one offs where it barely working is acceptable.
- contingencies 11y agoThe study likely assumed that people already familiar with working in these methodologies were equally available, equally happy to do so, and equally priced as regular developers, which is unlikely to be case. A certain minimum team size is probably required to make many of these processes viable; many real world systems are written by solo coders. Also, in reality it is relatively trivial to scavenge work like seL4, Linux kernel security toolkits, software HA clustering and/or proxy implementations, hardware watchdogs, ssss and/or distribute infrastructure across disparate locations to provide what probably amounts to magnitude higher redundancy and resilience against real world attacks or component failures without paying those costs. Indeed, the implementation of such is becoming near free many cases due to convergence on SoA/microservices. To put this more plainly, "I can get another if I break it, so a clay cup trumps a grail." - Mirza Asadullah Khan Ghalib, classical Urdu and Persian poet from the Mughal Empire ... quote #1 in my fortune db @ https://github.com/globalcitizen/taoup https://github.com/globalcitizen/taoup