4 ms·
The anarchist position is totally self defeating. We live in a complex society so some systems are needed. You can't do without a functioning justice system, fu
by maxxxxx 11y ago
The anarchist position is totally self defeating. We live in a complex society so some systems are needed. You can't do without a functioning justice system, functioning infrastructure, a financial system you can trust not to steal your money and other things. The market can't provide these things without some rules.
I really wish people would start asking for government accountability instead of wanting to abolish things that don't work and thinking that there is some magic fairy that will jump in and make it work. Getting systems to work well is hard, never-ending work and there are no simple solutions. Most of us here build technology systems so we should know this first hand.
- qntty 11y agoNot that I'm advocating anarchism, but you misunderstand what anarchism is if you think that it doesn't involve complex systems. The dream of anarchism is to have a stateless society, where there's no top-down control, not one without complex social institutions. In fact, an anarchist society would require more complex systems in order to function.
- maxxxxx 11y agoThat's the same fantasy like extreme libertarianism. How do you build a power grid? How do you build national defense? How do conflicts get resolved? I have never heard a real answer to those questions.
- dawnbreez 11y agoAs a not-so-extreme libertarian: >Power companies are responsible for their own infrastructure. >National defense is a tricky one. Maybe PMCs. >Conflicts are basically impossible to resolve without some variety of authority; this is why more moderate libertarianism works better
- bronson 11y ago>Power companies are responsible for their own infrastructure. You think they'll be able to negotiate easements and rights of way to each house? (without starting to look like a public entity?) >National defense is a tricky one. Maybe PMCs. So, Somalia? Blackwater? >Conflicts are basically impossible to resolve without some variety of authority; this is why more moderate libertarianism works better Extremely moderate libertarianism? There are more conventional names for that.
- dllthomas 11y ago> Extremely moderate libertarianism? There are more conventional names for that. Per my understanding, mainstream Libertarianism retains the court system as mediator of contractual disputes as well as criminal law.
- kevin_thibedeau 11y agoBecause the people peddling this philosophy are all lawyers and they want to be at the top of the heap after knocking everyone else down.
- dawnbreez 11y agoI...don't know where you get the idea that libertarianism is about knocking everyone else down. Perhaps if you focus entirely on removing welfare, it looks like that. And then, I (and other libertarians) believe that a Basic Income Guarantee would be extrenely useful, and a BIG would cover more people than current welfare systems. Or perhaps you think that deregulating business will lead to massive monopolies, ignoring that the regulations you defend make it harder for new companies to enter a market (thus making it easier to hold a monopoly).
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Or perhaps you think that deregulating business will lead to massive monopolies A reasonable belief, given what happened before regulatory controls were imposed to prevent massive monopolies.
- thoth 11y ago>Power companies are responsible for their own infrastructure. How exactly do you build infrastructure without government powers such as eminent domain, or without inserting easements for utility access? A libertarian landowner could simply refuse to allow utility lines to cross their property and thus cutoff others from access, or require expensive routing around their property. Roads, power/sewer/water/gas lines, phone/cable/data - all would be at the whim of landowners large and small as to whether it would even exist. There is no realistic way for a private company to negotiate access between them and every single landowner they'd need to in order to build infrastructure that serves a sizeable population. Hence government "coercion" is required.
- mercurial 11y agoIn Spanish regions controlled by anarchists during the Spanish Civil War (a country which at the time had a lot of dirt poor farmers and a lot less large landowners), landowners were given the choice between working their lands collectively, or keeping only the land they could work themselves. That's not the same thing as Ayn Rand-style libertarianism.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]