5 ms·
Does the market still function as a market if everybody uses index funds or robo advisers? The market should reflect the opinions of participants about individu
by maxxxxx 11y ago
Does the market still function as a market if everybody uses index funds or robo advisers? The market should reflect the opinions of participants about individual companies but with automated tools the market seems to get disconnected from economic reality.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 11y agoIt seems pretty unlikely that all the professional traders quit rather than taking advantage of any market disparities that arise.
- tamana 11y agoTraders aren't investors. They don't create valuations, they mediate between others who offer valuations. Traders make their money interacting with investors (and dumb traders).
- morgante 11y ago> Does the market still function as a market if everybody uses index funds or robo advisers? The more people forego seeking alpha the more of it that is available. So even if 50% of the market is passive, the pricing signals will all come from the 50% that's being actively managed.
- tomasien 11y agoThat would be a pretty weird "market" if money didn't shift to the opportunities created in such an environment.
- maxxxxx 11y agoI am just wondering if those opportunities would be more about exploiting weaknesses in other algorithms and less about identifying good companies.
- ForHackernews 11y agoYou mean exactly the way it is today?
- irq-1 11y agoThe market isn't losing valuable insights from people who are investing in index funds. Even if they were confident enough in an individual stock to buy shares, that doesn't mean they have any real insight about the company. For example, thinking RHT is a good buy at 63 doesn't demonstrate any insight about Red Hats business, management or market. I suspect the opposite is true: the market would be better if people invested in index funds rather than individual stocks when they didn't have any insight about the company. I don't have definitions to separate company "insight" from the more speculative information, but the distinction seems real enough.
- harryh 11y agoI tend to agree with you here, but James Surowiecki's "Wisdom of Crowds" thinking does make me wonder some....
- jlebar 11y ago> The market isn't losing valuable insights from people who are investing in index funds. Even if they were confident enough in an individual stock to buy shares, that doesn't mean they have any real insight about the company. Well, but index funds and individual stocks aren't the only things that retail investors can buy. A lot of money is moving out of actively-managed funds too.
- berberous 11y agoIt's an interesting question that has been covered a lot in the media lately. I've posted here before about an interesting letter that Nevsky Capital, a successful hedge fund, sent to its investors describing the reasons it was shutting down and returning investor money [0]. Among other reasons for shutting down, here is what the letter had to say on your question: - The unintended consequences of those new regulations introduced as a result of the GFC, which have largely removed the market making role of investment banks from global equity markets, has coincided with the recent massive increase in market share of both ‘dumb’ index funds and ‘black box’ algorithmic funds to create a situation where equity market volumes have fallen sharply and individual stock volatility has risen dramatically. An initially badly executed order can now inadvertently create a price trend (because there is no longer the cushion to price moves which was in the past provided by market maker inventories) that, as algorithmic funds feast on it, can create a market event even if the initial order was a simple innocent error. Truly – to mix metaphors – butterflies flapping their wings now regularly create hurricanes that stop out fundamentally driven investors who cannot remain solvent longer than the market can remain irrational. - In such a world dominated by index and algorithmic funds historically logical correlations between different asset classes can remain in place long after they have ceased to be logical. More butterflies. - Index and algorithmic fund manoeuvrings also make it very hard to ascertain what the markets ‘clean’ positioning is at any given time. All of which pushes up the cost of capital. [0] http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-01-05/why-15-billion-nevsky-capital-shutting-down-full-letter http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-01-05/why-15-billion-nevs...
- vehementi 11y agoDo all the other hedge funds agree?
- prostoalex 11y agoHow do index funds typically vote on hiring/firing ineffective management, executive compensation and other controversial issues? Doesn't management basically get a free run to milk the place dry with no active shareholders in charge?