4 ms·
So, this article not only retranslates Vietcong propanagda, but the only commentary it seems to offer is by Vietcong themselves, with phrases like "resistance t
by golergka 11y ago
So, this article not only retranslates Vietcong propanagda, but the only commentary it seems to offer is by Vietcong themselves, with phrases like "resistance to foreign invasion". How isn't this article isn't considered a propaganda piece by itself? It's one thing to present interesting historic material; it's another thing entirely to glorify a marxist dictatorship.
- fsloth 11y agoBut Vietnam war was essentially an effort to resist foreign invasion. It effectively started when "On 23 September 1945, with the knowledge of the British Commander in Saigon, French forces overthrew the local DRV government, and declared French authority restored..."[1] It was one of the awful proxy conflicts of 20th century. I have no idea which is better - to be a colony in a market economy (the dominating effect is that profits from capital leak into the owning country) or a marxist dictatorship. Most dictatorships are kinda shitty - Marxist or not - but I have no calculus to compute is being a colony any better [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Indochina_War https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Indochina_War
- classicsnoot 11y agoWhat is more, they did it with the weapons taken by the British from the Japanese who surrendered to the Vietminh.[1] [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sz8H_oi1ck0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sz8H_oi1ck0
- pearjuice 11y agoAs always there are two sides of a story. That what the oppressors want their citizens to believe to gather moral support and that what the suppressed want their citizens to know so they resist. By putting those two sides together, only then we can approximate truth.
- golergka 11y ago> By putting those two sides together, only then we can approximate truth. Absolutely agree. And this is exactly where this article fails, which is precisely the point of my comment.
- cariaso 11y agoThe article does not fail. It does it's part beautifully. You're abdicating your responsibility.
- golergka 11y agoWhat responsibility are you talking about?
- detaro 11y agoProbably the responsibility to do the comparison yourself. The article doesn't claim to present a balanced view or "the truth" (which propaganda would), it is clear about showing one perspective. There is more than enough documentation for the other perspective available, as is material contrasting the two. It would be bad if this article stood alone as the only source of information available, but it doesn't.
- pearjuice 11y agoHow so does it fail? Are there any useen images of the American side of the war they are hiding?
- golergka 11y agoWhy unseen? They're presenting this images without challenging them, without providing any historical context at all.
- alan_cx 11y agoReading your initial comment, its very hard to believe that. It reads like someone who only believes one side of the narrative.
- nness 11y ago"Resistance to foreign invasion" is essentially accurate, is it not? I find the quotes interesting. They help to illustrate the rhetoric which likely motivated much of North — that there were foreign countries intervening in what many locals considered a country's own struggle and not just another battlefield for a proxy war. I think pieces like this are important. Whilst you can disagree with it, it still makes you consider the views held by millions on the other side.
- golergka 11y agoWell, this is exactly my point: this piece is presenting only one point of view, without even an attempt to put it into context of a conflicting worldview.
- mmustapic 11y agoWell, the point of the article is how NV photographers saw the war. You don't need any extra context since it's explicitly stated that this is from one particular point of view. If you want a different point of view, there are thousands of articles, books and photographs.
- DanBC 11y agoI've had decades of the US point of view.
- arethuza 11y agoThe only reference to "foreign invasion" that I can see in the article is in a direct quote from one of the photographers who had witnessed US bombing of his country - not sure what other reaction you would expect him to have.
- fensipens 11y agobut the only commentary it seems to offer is by Vietcong themselves Yeah, nobody cares about the point of view of a 60kg Vietcong soldier. They are not supposed to have a face and keep quiet beneath that 2+ million bodycount. The brave war stories are reserved for the american GIs.. and hollywood.
- golergka 11y agoYou seem to argue against an imaginary strawman instead of a point I was trying to make.
- stingraycharles 11y agoI think OP was implying that this argument also holds for American soldiers talking from the American perspective, but wouldn't be labelled propaganda.
- Wintamute 11y agoYour comments are being down voted to oblivion. The prevailing narrative of our time is pretty anti-western. Anything the west does is auto-bad, whereas the activities of other cultures, current and historical, are (re)presented as heroic struggles against evil imperial forces. I agree with you, the truth lies somewhere in the middle. It seems like it should be an uncontroversial stance doesn't it? Welcome to the modern era where shades of gray don't exist, and the best way to accrue Twitter followers it to kick your own culture apart.
- SolaceQuantum 11y agoI don't think the downvoting of a comment claiming it's nothing but propaganda means anything about shades of grey not existing. I mean, that comment was pretty black and white itself.