6 ms·
What it would take to actually institute Universal Basic Income
- brandonmenc 11y ago> A basic income can be funded by taxing bad things, things we need less of, such as pollution, financial transactions, and extreme wealth. Why do we need fewer financial transactions?
- com2kid 11y agoThis also neglects that after taxing those things, less of those things will exist, thus decreasing tax revenue.
- WalterBright 11y agoI.e. if pollution is taxed, there'd be less of it? I'd vote for that!
- com2kid 11y agoWell yes, that is a good thing. But it doesn't work if the government does their math assuming revenue from that tax is constant!
- madeofpalk 11y agoHence the 'Carbon tax'
- jessriedel 11y agoHe's gesturing at the "finance is evil, we need to tax each transaction" body of thought. http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/22/opinion/the-case-for-a-tax-on-financial-transactions.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/22/opinion/the-case-for-a-tax...
- pbreit 11y agoMight be referring to High Frequency Trading which is relatively useless. But a tax would unlikely raise much revenue because it would go away.
- patio11 11y ago125 million households in US: @ $1 / year each : Cost less than one of several individual machines in various portions of the federal inventory (mostly things which kill people efficiently). @ $1,000 / year each : Exceeds combination of all federal spending on healthcare and education. @ $10,000 / year each: over 1/3rd of total federal tax receipts @ $30,000 / year each: consumes entire federal budget
- JacobAldridge 11y agoI note only 2 of those interviewed actually discussed the financial logistics at all. Matt Breuning throws out there that "10% GDP would be do-able", without really explaining where that $1.677 Trillion is coming from. Is it only existing programs? And even that figure only works out at approximately $5,000 per US Citizen per year. While worth investigating, I feel that's a far cry from what most people want when they talk about 'basic income'. [1] Numbers based on what Google spits out when you search for US GDP.
- TTPrograms 11y agoFor comparison, current Federal welfare spending divided across all households is equivalent to ~$3000/year: http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/us_welfare_spending_40.html http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/us_welfare_spending_40.h... I think the expectation is that income taxes would increase so that above a certain income level it becomes a net negative or break even at least - in that case it's pretty easy to get $1000 or $2000 / month equivalent for the bottom quarter of households or so. It's interesting that you describe $1000/year as "Exceeds combination of all federal spending on healthcare and education." given that it would be a savings over current welfare programs - doesn't seem like a very balanced comparison.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- matt_wulfeck 11y ago> 1) Salaries can decrease because employees are getting some income from the government. If you're making $100k now, you'd no longer need $100k from your employer, post-UBI, to have the same total income and quality of life. Who would actually be incentivized by this? "I can wakeup and do whatever I want today... OR I can roll into my crappy job with my crappy boss and be part of the economic machine and make a tiny bit more money each year..." If you're making $30k a year for nothing, why work at all for an extra $10 or $20k?
- massemphasis 11y agoOn the other hand, instituting UBI will decrease the people's willingness to accept immigration. The Nordic countries are notoriously homogenous in respect to diversity. A country like the US is extraordinarily far more diverse than something like a Nordic country. Countries like Norway, etc... that institute these welfare programs for their population are also among the least welcoming of immigrants. If Donald Trump were smart he'd likely pursue the UBI dependent on how much money the US makes versus the number of citizens. This would definitely trigger the same kind of mentality resident in welfare states like the nordic countries to resist immigration. How would this be addressed in the US? Would it signify a change in the immigration trend in the US?
- mc32 11y agoOne could mitigate that by setting it up where new citizens have a waiting period before they can qualify --kind of like retirement [where you wait till you qualify]. Same for anyone under 18, they [or legal guardians] receive progressively more as the children grow and need more. Or alternatively, your qualification follows you as a natural-born citizen of a given country --so you as a Canadian or American, Japanese, etc., receive UBI from your [original] country no matter where you live or move to so you would never qualify for UBI from a new host country blunting the threat of people thinking new immigrants get a free ride from the new host country.
- prostoalex 11y agoUnder current rules babies are eligible for more entitlements than older kids up to teenagers just because at that time in life they need more care. If UBI is replacing existing entitlements, that means taking away food stamps, WIC, free child annual physical / dental / vision exams (under AAC/Obamacare), tax deduction for dependents on 1040, and a host of other programs like free baby formula or car seats.
- mc32 11y agoUBI would be less successful, or, I can see it run into problems, if it were to replace medical care, for example. There would be those who would forgo the checkups in order that they might have more money for something less critical. I would lean heavily toward separating those to avoid that hazard. My take would be Medical, basic education [k-12], would be provided by the state and the rest, immediate things people can't skimp on [housing, food, clothing, etc.] could be covered by UBI
- brandon272 11y agoUBI seems to be presented under the context that every single adult in the country receives a UBI payment every month. Assuming that the UBI is funded through existing taxes/entitlement inlays, why not limit it to only those who need it or would ordinarily qualify for some kind of social assistance? (i.e. Unemployed/low income + retirees)
- streptomycin 11y agoIt could have a phase out, and many proposals indeed do: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax
- Absentinsomniac 11y agoBut this can have the effect of reducing incentive to work, according to the criticisms section of that page and some other stuff I've read.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThere's nothing wrong with reducing the incentive to work. That simply means jobs that must be done will have their wages rise. Jobs that don't need to be done will disappear.
- 542458 11y agoDefine "Jobs that don't need to be done". As Capitalism is ruthlessly profit-seeking, every job currently in place in free markets provides value to somebody. There are some in non-free markets, but that isn't affected by UBI existing.
- Absentinsomniac 11y agoWhat if the value to someone is keeping people busy and thus not challenging the status quo? Or what if the job is useless to society but still makes some money?
- Meekro 11y ago> A basic income can be funded by taxing bad things... The author is assuming that you can increase revenue by imposing new taxes, but that is rarely true. Tax revenue as a percentage of GDP has been nearly constant for the last 70 years, even as tax policy has fluctuated all over the place[1]. [1] http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/displayafact.cfm?Docid=205 http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/displayafact.cfm?Doc...
- jessriedel 11y agoBut don't several other countries collect a much higher percentage of GDP? I like your data, but it seems more likely to me that fractional GDP collected is limited by voters than economic limitations of taxation.
- nickff 11y agoMost of the countries which collect a higher percentage of GDP do so only at the federal level. If you look at US tax income and include the states, you will see that the collection percentage is more closely comparable to other western countries, and that the total receipts still stay relatively flat despite tax policy changes.
- spangry 11y agoI'm sorry but that's simply false. From the OECD's latest 'Revenue Statistics Publication' (http://www.oecd.org/ctp/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-methodology-guide-and-classification-system.htm http://www.oecd.org/ctp/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-method...): This annual Report presents detailed internationally comparable data on tax revenues of OECD countries for all levels of government... It's like the first sentence in their methodology section. Their 2014 estimates show total tax to GDP ratios of 34 countries that range from 19.5% to 50.9%. They are in no way 'relatively flat'. EDIT: Here's a direct link to the spreadsheet -> http://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/table-a-total-tax-revenue--gdp.htm http://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/table-a-total-tax-revenue...
- sparky_z 11y ago
- dilemma 11y agoI'm partial to it as an idea and a sentiment, but what it would take to institute it is the impossible: deciding on the level of it. Should it be $5,000 per month so that the full costs of an apartment in NYC/SF so that a family could on with their lives undisturbed by unemployment? Or, should it be $500 to cover just the most fundamental needs of shelter and nourishment in the Midwest? There are many levels in-between -- it's just as impossible to decide between $1,000 and $1,500 -- and if you went ahead to implement UBI, the conflict this would cause would halt implementation.
- isomorphic 11y agoMost states have some form of income tax. The federal government could work with an average UBI amount, which each state could increase (or not) from its own budget. (Not that the above isn't contentious and probably stands no chance of being put into place; I'm just suggesting a model to address your point.)
- dilemma 11y agoNo. The problem of deciding on the level of UBI remains, and remains impossible regardless of who is making the decision.
- mirimir 11y agoWhere to take the money from is not so doable either. But hey, let's wait until most of the truck drivers have lost their jobs, and are camped out in DC. That will help greatly to focus the debate.
- adrianN 11y agoYou start with very little, say $100 a month, that can be paid from current tax revenue, and increase it as the productivity per worker increases.
- dilemma 11y agoCompletely unfeasible. 1. $100 is roughly the same as $0 in the US; you cannot live on it at all. It does simply not pass as UBI. 2. The impossible decision to be made on the final level remains. You just put it off until tomorrow and obfuscate that this is what you're doing.
- mc32 11y agoUBI is attractive in its simplicity but there are many open questions. -How much is dispensed/person/family? -Who qualifies [every child, man and woman; when do new citizens qualify?] -What happens when people make bad decisions about their UBI? Do we still offer assistance to people who misspend/misallocate it? -In order to get more purchasing power out of UBI, do we move people en-masse to less costly and more dispersed places? -Is it progressive depending on income, or is it unconditional? -People who were once employed by the apparatus, and who may not have alternative jobs in social services, are they relegated to just getting by with UBI? -How do we pay for all this [depending on allotment]?
- matt_wulfeck 11y agoI'm sorry but I can never support something that gives this much power to the federal government. I'm thinking of the massive tax collection and enforcement machinery needed to gather this much money. im thinking of all of the new laws and exceptions that will be created.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 11y ago> taxing bad things, things we need less of, such as [...], and extreme wealth Yes, the money should be taken away before those people fritter it away on eradicating polio, making electric cars, and building a space program.
- darpa_escapee 11y agoBecause this is an accurate description of how the wealthy have used their wealth. The public good shouldn't be left in the hands of those who are only willing to contribute if doing so can increase their wealth.
- landryraccoon 11y ago> The public good shouldn't be left in the hands of those who are only willing to contribute if doing so can increase their wealth. Would you be willing to consistently apply this across everyone in the population, not only the wealthy?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- yanilkr 11y agoIt would truly cost liberty. Do you think an entity that gives you free money is going to let you be free? It is going to tell you what you can/cannot spend on, where you can and cannot go. The system would enslave you to the state. It would be so bad it would even be impossible to opt-out.
- EthanHeilman 11y agoWhy not have it not be state controlled at all? For instance setup it up as a series of trusts paid out to each person. Or limit state control by creating it under a constitutional amendment which establishes a fourth branch of government outside of congressional and executive control. These are not unsolvable problems. The US has a large standing professional military which is civilian controlled. Many thinkers in the past would have asked, "Do you think the people that control the military will just allow the president to fire them?" Yet that has happened. Legitimacy and tradition goes pretty far.
- yanilkr 11y agoI am a math minded person I don't see how this adds up. Let me explain myself in a different way. Money, wealth, currency and value are all related but they are not the same. They are tied to each other via currency. Just imagine a class room full of students and we have a way of grading student's work. A better grade means the student is smart. Currency is just that a system of accounting to make students work for better grades. Try distributing grades from performing students to non-performing students and see if it makes the entire class any more smarter than before? Similarly try to just boost grades ie guarantee someone a minimum grade. Now the overall grades look better but students are working the same and they are not any smarter than before.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- throwawaymsft 11y agoExcept make it so a student starves if they don't pass the class. Ask if they are in favor minimum grades then. The goal is to make the consequences of failure less severe.
- ohthehugemanate 11y agoThe title is wrong. It should be "we talked to 4 pro-UBI Facebook group admins, and 1 expert" TL;DR Associate professors of philosophy who manage Facebook groups promoting UBI like the concept and think it's feasible in a number of ways. The only economist (and only full professor) interviewed says: "UBI gets all this attention and popularity, but I haven’t seen one model that’s even on the planet of financial feasibility."
- tristanburnside 11y agoExcept that his reasoning seems flawed. He says that expanding the Finland trial would require "taxing citizens double what you’re taxing them now". Finland has about 5.5 million in population (this counts children) So 800 * 12 * 5.5mil = 52.8 Billion euro Finland GDP is about 290 Billion euro and their tax take as a % GDP is 20-25%. That's at least 58 Billion euro. So while it would take a lot of work to find the money, it seems that this statement is not really true either.
- mc32 11y agoSo what's the budget left for infrastructure, defense, R&D, education, disasters, emergencies?
- ntumlin 11y ago20% * 300 billion = 60 billion is where they're at now, add on 58 billion to pay for basic income and you've doubled taxes.
- spangry 11y agoI'm guessing the number would be a fair bit lower when you subtract the savings from abolishing the existing unemployment welfare system (and the cost of administering it). And, in theory, those previously on 'tapering welfare' now face less of a disincentive to work, so there'd be a bump in pretty much any tax revenue base correlated with GDP (i.e. almost all of them). EDIT: Just to give you a sense of what I mean about EMTRs, here's a chart from Australia's most recent tax system review -> http://i.imgur.com/jhRYXiB.png?1 http://i.imgur.com/jhRYXiB.png?1 . The interaction of the tax and welfare system means low income earners face an effective marginal tax rate of almost 80% at certain points of the income range (mostly due to payment tapering).
- bernardlunn 11y agoI found it a good intro to the subject. I am surprised by how negative the comments here on HN are.
- forrestthewoods 11y agowtf. The article doesn't actually answer the question! The last answer comes closest. But the others aren't even close. Lame.
- visarga 11y agoIt would be necessary to augment UBI with free healthcare and education, and, maybe, a part of the UBI should be in food or tickets that can be exchanged for food in stores so as to make sure it is being used for survival.
- strathmeyer 11y agoNo it is supposed to replace those things.
- SCAQTony 11y agoThe United states pulls in $3-trillion in taxes. We have 225-million adults over 18-years old and if they (we) were handed out $2,000 a month each that would equal EDIT: [225 million * 2000 * 12 = 5.4 trillion per year.] If we're talking about the solutions mentioned in the article I suspect administrating the various types of handouts may add an additional 50% cost to that [$5.4 trillion per year.] A basic income may work for Switzerland due to it's amazingly tiny population. (Less than half the size of L.A. County) In the United States, I would think inflation, laziness and complaints that $2,000 was not enough basic income would rule the day.
- agorabinary 11y ago225 million * 2000 * 12 = 5.4 trillion per year. Basic income arguments usually revolve around numbers. But what of self-respect? There is something very concerning about faith in a benevolent State-parent that will feed and clothe us instead of enabling us to do so ourselves, by removing policies that keep Americans poor.
- Frondo 11y agoThe state already provides roads, ensures the safety of our food, and gives us all access to a justice system. What of self-respect? If we want it, we should be able to derive it from being political beings, from being active and engaged members of civic society. While you need a purpose for being to have self-respect, that doesn't have to come from punching a clock.
- SCAQTony 11y agoYou come from a kind place and I acknowledge that but IMHO, you may be overestimating the IQ of at last 50% of the citizenry. I border a poor neighbor in Los Angeles; their goals and aspirations are quite different then the readers on this site. Problems with keeping their kids in school, gangs and teen pregnancy come to mind as the most important issues. It would not be hyperbole to say that a high percentage of this class can't name the three branches of government, the mayor of the city, let alone the governor, or their Congress member. A basic income may provide shelter and food but they all ready have that via section 8 housing and EBT cards. What they really want is a "job ticket" to the middle class.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoOne of the most interesting questions that people consider, when thinking about basic income, is whether or not people would still "want" to work if they were being given enough money to get by. That is a question which has a lot of opinions but not a lot of data behind. One way to study this might be to take a population which is on welfare, and for some of them replace their welfare with 'one string attached' basic income. The string is that if they take the BI they cannot also take welfare. However any money they earn by working doesn't affect how much BI they receive, it's a constant. Then compare them against other people in the study who were left on welfare. The goal would be to see how many BI recipents returned to work versus welfare recipients over 1, 2, and 5 year time spans. Trying to get a sample set in the 100 - 200 people range could be very expensive but it would help establish some data with which to analyze the question of whether or not people will work or not while getting basic income.
- pkaye 11y agoOne thing I imagined with basic income is if my wife and I paid off our mortgage and saved enough money, we could retire early, tighten our belts and live off our savings and whatever the basic income provides (multiplied my number of people in my household.) A big part of our living expenses are taxes and a mortage!
- duncan_bayne 11y agoThis entirely dodges the moral issue of whether it is acceptable to force people to subsidise others. UBI is particularly problematic in this area, as given its scale, it is impossible to implement without coercion.
- intopieces 11y agoFocusing on UBI as a national program is a mistake. Something like this would only gain traction if it were proven at the state level. Remember, ObamaCare was RomneyCare first.
- ScottBurson 11y agoI've found a short piece [0] on the Negative Income Tax, an idea closely related to the UBI, that I think does a better job than this article of discussing the problems with any such scheme. Some quotes: The first and most basic problem is that it is currently fiscally—and perhaps administratively—impossible to construct an NIT that simultaneously 1. provides an income guarantee as generous as the cash and in-kind benefits already available to many welfare recipients in the United States, 2. provides an ostensible incentive to work (a far greater concern when benefits are to be extended beyond the traditional welfare population dominated by female-headed families), and 3. restricts coverage to any manageable proportion of the population—the so-called "break-even" problem. These constraints are, in fact, irreconcilable as long as the median income remains within striking distance of the poverty line—a situation that has barely improved over the last two decades of slow average economic growth. The second problem with an NIT is that the welfare system already provides a package of cash and in-kind benefits that, in many states, is worth considerably more than any likely NIT (though at the cost of excluding large groups of the poor—such as two-parent families—from eligibility). Political and humanitarian considerations prevent reducing these benefits, thus vitiating one of the NIT's attractions—the possibility of abolishing the welfare system. [0] http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc1/NegativeIncomeTax.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc1/NegativeIncomeTax.html
- spangry 11y agoGood find. It's worth noting though that the author is discussing the 'Jersey Experiment', which implemented an 'impure' form of the NIT: Thus, a treatment might offer a guarantee equal to half the poverty line, which was then about $8,000 for a family of four, with benefits being reduced by 50 percent of the family's income. When income was zero, the family would receive the full $4,000 (50 percent of $8,000). When income reached $8,000, the benefit would be reduced to zero and the family would "break even" (i.e., neither receive negative taxes nor pay positive taxes). This is basically the opposite of a 'pure' NIT: where earnings do not affect the annual cash amount handed out by the government. In other words, under an NIT, the government would be sending the same amount of money to Bill Gates as they would send to its poorest citizen. The NIT discussed above meant that recipients faced at least a 50% effective marginal tax rate on their first $8000 of earnings, which is a pretty significant disincentive to work. The whole point of an NIT is to avoid this 'welfare trap' effect.
- cprayingmantis 11y agoLook I really like this idea of a UBI but I don't think it would work. We tend to think everyone is like us and we're hackers and creators to us its a compulsion to add or create value. The trouble of this idea to me is for a lot of low income families we pretty much subsidize their lives and it honestly isn't working. I grew up in an area of the country where we had tons of people living on welfare. Did they create? Did they add value to the community? Nope not at all. They were a drain the community. Take for instance a friend of mine we'll call her Mary. She has three kids and she gets free child care and after school care. She also gets food stamps, low income housing, and is eligible for 2 free college classes a semester from the local university because she's a single mom with low income. She's also got her CNA licence. She holds no job despite offers from places in the community. Now according to this UBI theory she would be a prime candidate. We give her money and magically she begins to add value to the community because she doesn't have to worry about money anymore. However we already do this and she's a drain on the community. She takes and never gives back. Now let's take another friend of mine we'll call him James. He doesn't have a job and didn't qualify for college but he can code. His github account is filled with commits to all kinds of crazy projects. He just loves to build things. He adds to the community. My question to you is do we give every one UBI because I'm not really ok with that. If James said man I'm short on rent this month I'd give him $100 but if Mary said she need $100 for diapers and cloths I'd refuse because she has places to get that and if she's short on money its most likely her own mismanagement of cheques. I'm open to new ideas though. So help me understand why UBI is a great idea.
- cprayingmantis 11y agoLook I really like this idea of a UBI but I don't think it would work. We tend to think everyone is like us and we're hackers and creators to us its a compulsion to add or create value. The trouble of this idea to me is for a lot of low income families we pretty much subsidize their lives and it honestly isn't working. I grew up in an area of the country where we had tons of people living on welfare. Did they create? Did they add value to the community? Nope not at all. They were a drain the community. Take for instance a friend of mine we'll call her Mary. She has three kids and she gets free child care and after school care. She also gets food stamps, low income housing, and is eligible for 2 free college classes a semester from the local university because she's a single mom with low income. She's also got her CNA licence. She holds no job despite offers from places in the community. Now according to this UBI theory she would be a prime candidate. We give her money and magically she begins to add value to the community because she doesn't have to worry about money anymore. However we already do this and she's a drain on the community. She takes and never gives back. Now let's take another friend of mine we'll call him James. He doesn't have a job and didn't qualify for college but he can code. His github account is filled with commits to all kinds of crazy projects. He just loves to build things. He adds to the community. My question to you is do we give every UBI because I'm not really ok with that. If James said man I'm short on rent this month I'd give him $100 but if Mary said she need $100 for diapers and cloths I'd refuse because she has places to get that and if she's short on money its most likely her own mismanagement of cheques. I'm open to new ideas though. So help me understand why UBI is a great idea.
- ap3 11y agoStill don't understand why do we need this, and what would it solve in the US
- MrsPeaches 11y agoHas anyone made an explorable explanation for UBI? It seems like the perfect candidate.
- duncan_bayne 11y agoWorth reading on this topic: https://thesnarkwhohuntsback.wordpress.com/favorite-passages-from-atlas-shrugged/the-story-of-the-twentieth-century-motor-company-atlas-shrugged-part-ii/ https://thesnarkwhohuntsback.wordpress.com/favorite-passages...