5 ms·
> With plenty of competitors, including Atlassian, GitLab, and even Google, one thing is certain: If GitHub does stumble, there are plenty of companies that wan
by mschuster91 11y ago
> With plenty of competitors, including Atlassian, GitLab, and even Google, one thing is certain: If GitHub does stumble, there are plenty of companies that want to pick up its slack.
Atlassian? Oh god. Their software might be ideal for corporate beancounters and expensive consultants, but for everyone else it's a nightmare.
GitLab? A pile of memory leaks and other weirdness.
Google? Not so much, I highly doubt they'll ever re-open Google Code.
edit: and another thing, Github enjoys a massive, massive network effect, next to impossible to recreate by anyone else. Except Sourceforge, but they burned so many bridges that no one sane in his mind will ever trust them again.
- seibelj 11y agoAtlassian bitbucket is fine for me, and it gives free private repos. If you just want something for side projects without all of the bells and whistles, bitbucket is fine
- tomschlick 11y agoThe frequent bitbucket downtime is what got me to switch my company's stuff to github.
- techdragon 11y agoShame they lack any way to discover active forks that is as useful as the GitHub network graph widget.
- icefox 11y agoUsing the API you can get it, they just don't bother showing it to the user.
- kannonboy 11y agoDev attached to the Bitbucket team here. While we love and support open source where we can, the vast majority of repositories on Bitbucket are private or public but maintained by a single organization. Our core focus is professional teams, which typically means branching (rather than forking) workflows. This has lead us to prioritize features like branch level permissions over network graphs and other features focused on forking workflows, because they are of higher value to our users. We're not ideologically opposed to them (indeed, forks are useful for some professional workflows too - such as working with contractors or external contributors), but they just haven't bubbled up to the top of our roadmap just yet.
- the_ancient 11y agoI love both BitBucket and GitLab, have no issues with either.
- mschuster91 11y agoI'm administrating a small-ish Gitlab server and we have to reboot it every week or else it will fail in random and weird ways due to OOM - the machine has 8GB of RAM and 20 active users, so WTF? Isn't the entire point of git to have one pretty dumb server acting as a file server and letting the client do the work?!
- radicalbyte 11y agoI believe that that is more of a Ruby runtime issue than a Gitlab issue.
- mschuster91 11y agoWell why implement it in Ruby then if it's known that the environment is sensitive to OOM?
- giaour 11y agoA memory leak would be an application issue, not a language issue.
- the_ancient 11y agoGitLab, GitHub, BitBucket etc are not simply a GitServer, if that is all you want then there are better projects out there for that. hell basic ssh or http server can be used a gitserver with no front end at all or gitweb http://git-scm.com/docs/gitweb.html http://git-scm.com/docs/gitweb.html GitLab, GitHub, BitBucket etc are project Management platforms that enable Bug Tracking, Documentation, Social networking all on top of and around basic git functions
- mschuster91 11y agoNo matter what extra functions, 20 users and 8 GB RAM is way out of proportions. Especially these days where everything is done on the client and the server only has to run a simple API!
- ilostmykeys 11y agoYou got downvoted by people promoting the companies they work for. Altasian stuff is hideous and Gitlab I heard is a horror show. This will be downvoted too but honestly who cares. Despite all of Github's problems no one comes anywhere close in terms of adoption and developer mindshare and there is a reason for that.
- audessuscest 11y agoActually Gitlab could be a replacement, I use it with 10 dev team + customers and we have absolutely no problem.
- ex3ndr 11y agoWe tried to switch. After few days devs make a note on the table "X days without GitLab being down". X always was < 2.
- audessuscest 11y agoDo you use gitlab.com or you own instance ? We use our own instance since 2 years (60+ users, 200+ repo) and the only down time is for update
- ex3ndr 11y agoI am sure that own instances will run much better, but i prefer cloud services for storing such important data.
- ake1 11y agobeen using gitlab for the past two years at work and the only time it's inaccessible is when upgrading it. it does have a lot of other issues like response time and a difficult to navigate ui but crashing is not one of them.
- sytse 11y agoWhat version are you on? Since GitLab 8.0 great improvements have been made to the UI and if there is something still wrong on the latest version we would love to know.
- ake1 11y agoit is generally hard to navigate, every time i'm adding a user and giving him access to groups/projects i have to spend a minute to figure out where. the new CI gui is worse than the old one (pre-8).
- smhg 11y agoGoogle's Cloud Source Repositories [1] aren't related to Google Code if I get it right. [1] https://cloud.google.com/source-repositories/ https://cloud.google.com/source-repositories/
- mbrock 11y agoI dunno if it's impossible to recreate. You could just scrape GitHub's user data, mirror all public repositories, provide GitHub login, and do everything you can to ensure that your new competing thing lets people move away from GitHub with no friction.
- zo1 11y agoI believe Github provides a free data-dump of their publically-available data. That makes things even easier, it's just no one's done it yet.
- dorianm 11y agoThey mention Google Cloud Source Repositories as a recent concurrent of GitHub: https://cloud.google.com/source-repositories/ https://cloud.google.com/source-repositories/
- DannyBee 11y ago"Google? Not so much, I highly doubt they'll ever re-open Google Code. " One thing to remember is that the main reason Google did code.google.com was to create competition for sourceforge (I was the third or fourth person to join the code.google.com team) Now, it's pretty much 100% that Google won't do this again anytime soon, but that doesn't mean some other large company won't have the same thought.
- stock_toaster 11y agoMaybe Google Ventures will end up investing in Gitlab, or some similar startup down the line. It seems like it would be a decent hedge, and possibly cheaper than developing and/or running it themselves.
- eikenberry 11y agoThey aren't talking Google Code. If you read the linked article, they are talking a new thing Google "Cloud Source Repositories". https://cloud.google.com/source-repositories/ https://cloud.google.com/source-repositories/ Haven't had a change to review it yet but seems to be they retired Google Code in preparation for this, not because they were acquiescing the market to Github.
- quicklyfrozen 11y agoThey describe it as "fully-featured private Git repositories" so not a replacement for Google code. Also it's pretty inconceivable they'd retire Google Code early, forcing repos to move to a competitor, then introduce a new public service.
- reactor 11y agohttps://notabug.org https://notabug.org
- sytse 11y agoI agree that we at Gitlab should do something about the memory leaks and I created https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues/13241 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues/13241 What do you mean with other weirdness?
- greenrd 11y agoI've heard a lot of people complaining about JIRA and so on, but I've never really understood why they hate it. Sure, it's closed source, but so is GitHub, and people seem to like that (this discussion notwithstanding).