5 ms·
> When they are widespread and commonplace the accident rate will go past that of wide/marked roads. Widespread or not, the lack of rules still forces drivers
by ricardobeat 11y ago
> When they are widespread and commonplace the accident rate will go past that of wide/marked roads.
Widespread or not, the lack of rules still forces drivers to be more aware of their surroundings. Drivers are not going to start speeding through junctions because they are used to it, the risks remain the same. As an anecdote, the Netherlands has unmarked crossings everywhere and one of the lowest rates of road accidents.
> For a fair comparison, if you compared a country with wide/marked streets to a country where narrow/unmarked streets are commonplace (Mexico for example) you'd find marked/wide is much safer.
That assumption doesn't hold any water. It is nearly impossible to make that kind of comparison due to the amount of factors involved - fleet composition and age, skill and education, driver attitude and behaviour, pavement quality, speeds, etc, etc.
- DanBC 11y agoThe Netherlands also has priority for pedestrians and bicycles everywhere. That's different from the UK, where many car drivers feel the road is entirely theirs and anyone else shouldn't be on the road.
- dazc 11y ago> That's different from the UK, where many car drivers feel the road is entirely theirs and anyone else shouldn't be on the road. I'm not sure what happens elsewhere but in the UK we pay a vehicle tax (or excise duty), colloquially known as 'road tax'. It's a common (misguided) belief that the roads are funded exclusively via this tax, hence the sense of entitlement. Ref: Is there any such thing as 'road tax'? http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23694438 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23694438
- ktRolster 11y agoWhen I was in the Netherlands, my coworker literally would hurry into the crosswalk to force cars to stop. When we questioned him about it, he said, "They have to stop. It's the law!" My Polish coworker and I were not so anxious to enforce the law with our bodies.
- jschwartzi 11y agoThe lack of markings also makes it really dangerous to be anywhere near the road without a steel cage of some sort. I can't count the number of times I've nearly been run over in a crosswalk by people turning into it at a red light. I can't imagine how much more dangerous they would be if we took all the markings off and relied solely on their flawed judgement. This is in the US, by the way.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoA big part of that is the corner-building tendencies that US civil engineers have. Often they'll build the corner in a broad sweep that makes it easier to turn at high speed. If it was built aggressively to force traffic to slow, it'd also be a shorter distance for pedestrians to cross.
- Retric 11y agoPedestrians also really need to pay attention. I have never had a close call because I treat traffic as the highly dangerous place it is. Yet, I see plenty of people practically throw themselves into oncoming traffic the instant the crosswalk changes.
- Mithaldu 11y agoIt would behoove pedestrians to pay attention simply so they don't die. Claiming they are obligated to, however is entirely wrong. (And in fact, in my country a car hitting a lesser traffic member is at fault be default, with only some percentages removed if the other member actively caused an accident.) Cars are obligated to ensure they don't kill anyone even when that other one is behaving irresponsibly.
- DanBC 11y ago> the crosswalk changes. Alternatively, car drivers need to recognise the fact that they're in control of a lethal bit of machinery and drive appropriately - and this means stopping at the lights.
- goodcanadian 11y ago