10 ms·
Why the hell should we use Lithium Ion batteries for energy storage when Pumped Hydro is cheaper? Do you even know what the energy storage market looks like in
by dragontamer 11y ago
Why the hell should we use Lithium Ion batteries for energy storage when Pumped Hydro is cheaper?
Do you even know what the energy storage market looks like in the US? You ain't gonna build a 30 GIGAWATT-hour plant on $3 Billion (1.6 Billion initially, another 1.5 billion in upgrades a few decades later) like the Bath County pumped storage station.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bath_County_Pumped_Storage_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bath_County_Pumped_Storage_Sta...
Lithium Ion will cost you significantly more.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoBecause you can't drop pumped hydro onto a substation anywhere in the world in cargo containers. Batteries, you can (Hawaii is already doing so in tandem with utility scale solar). Pumped hydro is restricted by geography. That's like arguing, "Why not build dams everywhere! Hydro power is so clean!". You need someplace to actually pump water around.
- dragontamer 11y agoOkay, so TSLA can go ahead and capture the Hawaii and Alaska energy storage market. Virtually everywhere else has dams they can take advantage of. The places that don't have abandoned mines for Compressed-Air energy storage. Continental US has a ton of natural resources at its disposal that can be built up to significantly cheaper solutions than Lithium Ion.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Okay, so TSLA can go ahead and capture the Hawaii and Alaska energy storage market. And Australia. And Europe. And anywhere that is placing a premium on renewable energy. Tesla's market for batteries increases each time they're able to lower their price as volume increases. > Virtually everywhere else has dams they can take advantage of. The places that don't have abandoned mines for Compressed-Air energy storage. Continental US has a ton of natural resources at its disposal that can be built up to significantly cheaper solutions than Lithium Ion. There is no point in us arguing further when you don't base your argument on reality. You can't put dams anywhere. You can't build salt caverns anywhere. You can put batteries anywhere.
- dragontamer 11y agoRight. Because Lithium Ion is the only battery technology out there. http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/11/new-type-flow-battery-can-store-10-times-energy-next-best-device http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/11/new-type-flow-battery... Good luck competing against Redox Flow. Its a miracle that Elon Musk has been able to get so much done with Laptop-batteries (18650 Cells). But the new chemistries actually designed for grid-storage are coming, and they crush laptop-batteries in cost and capacity. The Gigafactory is designed to make Electric car batteries, and the 26650 (successor to the 18650 laptop cells) aren't even being produced yet. How long before TSLA / Panasonic can tweak the gigafactory to make a cell optimized for grid energy-storage?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoTesla PowerWalls and PowerPacks are already being installed. When are redox flow batteries going to be built? Put into production?
- dragontamer 11y agoIn about a month. http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/articles/2015/08/hecate-vizn-to-deploy-north-america-s-largest-redox-flow-battery-system.html http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/articles/2015/08/hecate-... Your turn. Show me a 1MegaWatt-hr or larger TSLA installation. kw-installations (Power Wall) are small money, I don't care about that. I care about hundreds-of-million $$ installations. The only things I see for TSLA are planned projects and/or demos. Redox Flow is a bit newer technology than Lithium Ion, but small-scale installations already exist all over the world. http://www.energy-storage-online.com/cipp/md_energy/custom/pub/content,oid,1600/lang,2/ticket,g_u_e_s_t/~/Vanadis_Power_delivers_one_of_the_biggest_battery_storage_systems_in_Germany.html http://www.energy-storage-online.com/cipp/md_energy/custom/p...
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> In about a month. "Slated for commissioning in 2016, ViZn's ZnFe redox flow battery system will be the largest of its type in North America and Europe." "The first of these projects is expected to be brought online by the end of Q316."
- bsder 11y agoBecause everything you mentioned requires a capital investment and the Tesla batteries don't. There are many things which are more cost-effective long-term, which lose to something which costs less short term.
- dragontamer 11y agoThe Bath County Hydro Station was built in 1970. I'm comparing TSLA technology to literally 40 year old technology here. The 40-year old technology is cheaper, more well known, widely deployed, 100% green, non-toxic and extremely reliable. Its both a short-term and long-term solution. TSLA batteries don't even beat the status-quo in the energy field, let alone the new technologies that are coming (Supercapacitors, Redox Flow, Compressed Air...)
- bsder 11y agoHydro is cheaper, but requires permits, construction, multi-year timeframes, contractors, etc. Battery packs require NONE of these. Look, this is just like the PC revolution vs mainframes. Mainframes were cheaper and better on ANY axis relative to PC's in the 1980's. However, a PC didn't require a multi-year allocation in the capital budget. A PC didn't require buy-in from multiple players. A PC was locally controlled. So, PCs won. And the money expended on PCs eventually made them better than the mainframes they were displacing.
- dragontamer 11y agohttp://www.uetechnologies.com/product.htm http://www.uetechnologies.com/product.htm Okay. So why are PowerWalls going to beat the current state-of-the-art in battery technology? Look, for areas with resources, Pumped Hydro / Compressed Air is straight up superior. For areas without resources, getting a shipping container for a Redox Flow battery is more efficient.
- reality_czech 11y agoHydroelectric dams are bad for the environment, and a huge risk in areas prone to earthquakes. They're also a big terrorism risk (ever watched "The Dambusters" about the WWII dam-busting operations?) Plus, you are ignoring the biggest advantages of the PowerWall concept-- the decentralization and small-scale aspect. I don't think homeowners in my town are going to be building hydroelectric dams in their back yard, even if it weren't an earthquake zone (and it is...) With regard to new battery chemistries... sure, there are probably things out there much better or stabler than lithium-ion. But posting some marketing copy about a not-yet-shipped new battery product proves nothing. I'm surprised you didn't latch on to the "ultracapacitor" hype since that is also a year away from taking the world by storm (and has been for the last 5 years, at least). As a layman, none of us have any idea whether these physics breakthroughs are 5 months away or 5 years, and none of the people who do know are going to talk about it. If new battery chemistries do take the world by storm. I don't see why Tesla wouldn't just license them, much like they are licensing lithium-ion now. Tesla has the high-current charging network that a better battery would need anyway. Traditional car manufacturers have a spotty and low-wattage charging network that might not even benefit from a better battery chemistry. You seem to be grasping at any possible reason to be negative about Tesla. I agree they're overvalued right now, but the idea of building a big factory for batteries, and focusing on a high-end electric car is smart, and the next few years will show that. There are strong network effects in building a charging network, and major economies of scale in building the gigafactory.