3 ms·
Wrong. Tesla buys its cells from Panasonic. Panasonic owns half the gigafactory (the Lithium Ion half). Tesla only buys Li-Ion cells from Panasonic and then as
by dragontamer 11y ago
Wrong.
Tesla buys its cells from Panasonic. Panasonic owns half the gigafactory (the Lithium Ion half). Tesla only buys Li-Ion cells from Panasonic and then assembles them into batteries. I can agree that there is some efficiency in this arrangement (cells and batteries made inside the same facility), but don't get ahead of yourself. Tesla is only assembling batteries.
Panasonic makes the 18650 cells.
GM and Ford build their own batteries too for their own fleet of vehicles, supplied from LG Chem. The benefits of scale seem to benefit the joint effort between GM + Ford + LG Chem, and the topology of Detroit (which has tons of railroads and shipyards that GM / Ford / LG Chem can leverage).
- toomuchtodo 11y agoRight, a joint partnership. I'll be worried as soon as I see legacy automakers building their own battery factories. Until then, good luck!
- dragontamer 11y agohttp://www.autoblog.com/2015/10/21/gm-without-lg-chem-we-couldnt-build-bolt-ev/ http://www.autoblog.com/2015/10/21/gm-without-lg-chem-we-cou... I bet you Bolt EV hits consumer market before TSLA Model 3. But yeah, GM owns its own battery factory. Is it the same size as Tesla's?? No. But I think its a smarter move to build the factories after demand has proven itself. Tesla expects the Model 3 to sell out. Anything less than "amazing" will make the Gigafactory not worth its billions-upon-billions of dollars of investment.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI don't disagree the Bolt gets here first. The Leaf got here first too. I don't see the Leaf selling out. I don't see the Bolt selling out either. > Tesla expects the Model 3 to sell out. Anything less than "amazing" will make the Gigafactory not worth its billions-upon-billions of dollars of investment. Even if the Model 3 doesn't sell out, there are utility customers clamoring for stationary storage, first to replace peaking plant capacity, and then down the value chain as more utility scale wind and solar come online.
- dragontamer 11y agoWhy the hell should we use Lithium Ion batteries for energy storage when Pumped Hydro is cheaper? Do you even know what the energy storage market looks like in the US? You ain't gonna build a 30 GIGAWATT-hour plant on $3 Billion (1.6 Billion initially, another 1.5 billion in upgrades a few decades later) like the Bath County pumped storage station. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bath_County_Pumped_Storage_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bath_County_Pumped_Storage_Sta... Lithium Ion will cost you significantly more.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoBecause you can't drop pumped hydro onto a substation anywhere in the world in cargo containers. Batteries, you can (Hawaii is already doing so in tandem with utility scale solar). Pumped hydro is restricted by geography. That's like arguing, "Why not build dams everywhere! Hydro power is so clean!". You need someplace to actually pump water around.
- dragontamer 11y agoOkay, so TSLA can go ahead and capture the Hawaii and Alaska energy storage market. Virtually everywhere else has dams they can take advantage of. The places that don't have abandoned mines for Compressed-Air energy storage. Continental US has a ton of natural resources at its disposal that can be built up to significantly cheaper solutions than Lithium Ion.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Okay, so TSLA can go ahead and capture the Hawaii and Alaska energy storage market. And Australia. And Europe. And anywhere that is placing a premium on renewable energy. Tesla's market for batteries increases each time they're able to lower their price as volume increases. > Virtually everywhere else has dams they can take advantage of. The places that don't have abandoned mines for Compressed-Air energy storage. Continental US has a ton of natural resources at its disposal that can be built up to significantly cheaper solutions than Lithium Ion. There is no point in us arguing further when you don't base your argument on reality. You can't put dams anywhere. You can't build salt caverns anywhere. You can put batteries anywhere.
- Const-me 11y agoTesla’s not the only company producing electric vehicles. Globally, demand for Li-Ion cells and batteries is going to increase, even if Tesla will stop making cars.
- dragontamer 11y agoYes, but that only puts Panasonic in a good position. Tesla Batteries can only be used inside of Tesla cars and Powerwalls right now. All the other companies build their own batteries (out of LG Chem cells or Samsung cells). Tesla only assembles Panasonic cells into batteries. They are not poised to actually benefit from increased global demand of Lithium Ion.
- Const-me 11y agoCurrently yes, only assembling Panasonic cells. They’re building the factory to change that, by making their own cells. Panasonic only owns about 35% of the factory, the rest is TSLA.
- dragontamer 11y agoPanasonic owns the cell development side of the factory. Tesla has no plans to make their own cells. This is a simple fact.
- Const-me 11y agoPanasonic invested $1.6B while the total project cost is about $5B. E.g. here: http://mashable.com/2016/01/16/panasonic-tesla-gigafactory-investment http://mashable.com/2016/01/16/panasonic-tesla-gigafactory-i... While 32% if significant share, it’s less then half. I don’t see how the cells manufactured by a Tesla-branded factory, where TSLA owns more than 50% of the factory, aren’t Tesla’s own.
- dragontamer 11y agoYou've never been in an office building with more than two different companies inside? I mean, serious question. In the office building I work in, my company only owns two floors. The next floor is another company, and the floor above that is yet another company. My company owns more than half the building (the bottom floors has more space for various reasons), but the stuff made upstairs isn't made by my company.
- Riod 11y agoThanks for inserting some logic here. This is all public information