4 ms·
Paving roads with solar panels is a classic example of a 'simple, easy, wrong' solution. It seems that some people have gross misconceptions about the barrier t
by CyberDildonics 11y ago
Paving roads with solar panels is a classic example of a 'simple, easy, wrong' solution. It seems that some people have gross misconceptions about the barrier to solar panels. People living in crowded cities think there is some sort of shortage of space. In a broad sense this is of course very far from the truth. The barrier to solar is cost per kw/hr. As that goes down, solar installations go up.
- chillingeffect 11y ago> People living in crowded cities think there is some sort of shortage of space. Too true. When I spent some time in an urban technology research lab, the researchers and students gravitated strongly toward projects described as "a little tiny $X that you can carry with you." Their focuses narrowed from stage performances to screen-based art. In the Indra's web of city life, the wide, open space of rural areas was not only forgotten, but incomprehensible and unavailable as a resource for deployment.
- paulddraper 11y agoFirst thought: "You can carry any X dollars around, the form of a credit card." Second thought: "Oh, the $ is a indicator of some kind." Third thought: https://xkcd.com/1306/ https://xkcd.com/1306/
- stickfigure 11y agoPlus, the first light rain will turn this into a shiny death trap for motorcycles.
- donquichotte 11y ago"cost per kw/hr" kWh is a unit of energy, kW/h rarely makes sense (mostly if you're interested in dPower/dt)
- imaginenore 11y agoIt's actually kW*hr, not kW/h
- wang_li 11y ago> Paving roads with solar panels is a classic example of a 'simple, easy, wrong' solution. You are likely not seeing the same "problem" that the powers that be in France are seeing. When looked at through the lens of graft, corruption and cronyism, it's 'simple, easy, and profitable'. Whether it ever delivers worthwhile amounts of power at efficient costs is entirely secondary.
- hguant 11y agoAlways nice to know that certain elements of the human condition are universally true - was just talking the other day about graft, etc in Boston as compared to DC. Now we can include France in the discussion.
- nraynaud 11y agoIt would be really interesting that the big companies that helped the minister not get elected president would be in bed later with her for corruption
- fisherjeff 11y agoLooked at from the other direction, as solar installations go up, the cost per kWh goes down. So a public entity doing one very large installation seems like a good way to help push costs lower, especially for that particular installation. And if they're looking for a lot of urban public space to build on, why not roads?
- tdb7893 11y agobecause the panels then need to support and run the wear of cars (which my guess is expensive). roads are repaired quite often because they have to deal with temperature contraction and expansion and also huge shifting weights rolling across them all the time.
- fisherjeff 11y agoRight, but that's all structure and doesn't (er, shouldn't) fundamentally affect the cost of the PV cells themselves. Regardless, I agree that it's not necessarily the most cost-effective choice, I just don't think that it's a response to some perceived lack of space either.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- breatheoften 11y agoRoads require maintainance and solar panels require maintenance -- couldn't innovation (conceivably) produce a maintenance schedule that can maintain both these things under one process at less cost than maintaining each separately?
- mike_hock 11y agoYeah, just drives up the repair costs when there's an accident. Also causes huge wear on the panels. Why not place the solar panels next to the road?