12 ms·
Much of the customization stem from fixing android's perceived shortcomings by the product-management at respective OEMs. Besides, you must realise that Google
by ignoramous 11y ago
Much of the customization stem from fixing android's perceived shortcomings by the product-management at respective OEMs. Besides, you must realise that Google doesn't engage OEMs as much as it should when it decides what goes and what doesn't AFAIK, Google does it own prod-mgmt. Android isn't a standard. Which is a good thing, 'cause it can move fast and break things (which it often does).
For instance, Amazon saw that the WebView was tightly tied with Android and that was security concern (up until it was freed in Android L), and so Amazon made it OTA'able in its third iteration of Fire OS (Android K).
Also, in a crowded market, you need a differentiator. If every phone is going to look and do the same thing, why would anyone buy one device over another? Samsung needs to market things with its offering, it can't just do so with Hardware. It needs the stylus to justify the exorbitant price tag on its Galaxy Note line of products. It needs floating activities on its mega-screen and wants people to get hooked on to that feature, to an extent that they can no longer do without it, which makes sure they'd buy and recommend Samsung over other OEMs.
Secondly, hardware is just one part of the equation. Sometimes you require vast changes in Software to make sure the hardware is properly utilized... Or you just have a better Software solution up your sleeve than what Google gave you.
Thirdly, some of the Google Apps aren't stellar-- Photos is miserable, Camera is a-okay, Music Player is a-okay, Video Player is miserable, Launcher isn't smart, Lockscreen isn't smart. You need premium apps for your devices. Besides, why would you want Google to walk away with the cake (usage information generated using all those apps) from a customer you acquired with all those hours you spent marketing the phone, establishing your brand, figuring out the quirks of doing businesses globally, toiling endlessly to sort out the logistics, whilst also fighting patent battles, as if the existing technology arms-race weren't enough... among a host of other commitments?
You and I (and I take that most of the HN community) are purists... not everyone else is.
- avn2109 11y ago>> "Or you just have a better Software solution up your sleeve than what Google gave you." Honest question, have you ever seen any OEM modification to Android that was a net improvement over stock? Maybe someone has improved power management or some low level feature that I've never noticed.
- harshalizee 11y agoHTC line of Android phones with HTC Sense was probably the best and most distinct UI customization I've seen. They had it way before Material design even came into picture.
- ignoramous 11y agoI help mod Android for a living. From my experience, there is a tonne of things OEM want that improve either performance, stability, security, and usability (atleast until Google cleaned up their act with JB).
- xbmcuser 11y agoI like Samsung close all apps button not available on pure Android as according to Google you are not supposed to. Google people are great engineers but sometimes they don't get not needing something doesn't people don't want it.
- xbmcuser 11y agoI like Samsung close all apps button not available on pure Android as according to Google you are not supposed to. Google people are great engineers but sometimes they don't get not needing something doesn't people don't want it.