5 ms·
Bringing him back the US would be extradition, not rendition. Rendition means sending him someplace away from American courts to be [interrogated harshly].
by tootie 11y ago
Bringing him back the US would be extradition, not rendition. Rendition means sending him someplace away from American courts to be [interrogated harshly].
- mschuster91 11y ago> Rendition means sending him someplace away from American courts to be [interrogated harshly]. I'd fully expect from the US government to lock Snowden up in Guantanamo and throw away the keys.
- tootie 11y agoYou would expect Obama to add prisoners to Guantanamo while he's desperately trying to close it? And you think he could just disappear an extremely visible personality and no one would be suspicious? The fact is they have him dead to rights on breaking the law and any court would easily convict him and give him at least a few if not many years in jail. He'd probably plea bargain to something face saving and be done with it.
- Karunamon 11y agoYou've got a lot more faith that extralegal shenanigans won't happen than I do, for sure. Snowden's leaks have shown us that the US government will do anything if it thinks it can get away with it, the law be damned. Besides. What happened with Bradley/Chelsea Manning is all "legal", and that amounts to straight-up torture.
- beedogs 11y ago> desperately trying Haven't heard a peep out of him about Gitmo this decade. If this is what counts as "desperately trying", I've got to wonder what term you use for actual effort.
- tootie 11y agoHe's been slowly but steadily releasing people. http://www.gtmoclock.com http://www.gtmoclock.com
- barney54 11y agoSnowden would not have been sent to Guantanmo because he is an American citizen. The point of Guantanmo is that the US wanted a place to keep people who weren't US citizens and wasn't on US soil.
- tootie 11y agoNot just that. They had all these detainees that they thought were probably terrorists, but they knew they didn't have enough evidence (or at least admissible evidence) to convict them. So, between sending them court knowing a lot of them would be acquitted or letting them go back to do whatever bad stuff they were worried would happen, they just decided to hold them in limbo. They have plenty of evidence to convict Snowden in a civilian court.
- jellicle 11y agoCorrect. He would be placed in permanent solitary confinement at ADX Florence in Colorado, not Guantanamo Bay. (Guantanamo Bay, in case you weren't aware, has entered the vernacular as a metaphor, and that's how the previous commenter was using it.)
- tomp 11y agoSo... wouldn't this be a rendition from Denmark to USA (where he would be - no doubt - interrogated harshly)?
- tootie 11y agoInterrogated over what? He's publicly confessed repeatedly to what he's done. AQ subjects were tortured because the administration believed at the time they could find out about upcoming plots. Snowden has already done his business, boasted about it and fled the nation. If he ever set foot in the US he'd be very easily convicted by due process without needing to answer a single question.
- arethuza 11y agoPerhaps pour encourager les autres.
- feintruled 11y agoI'm sure he will get some ridiculous 2,000 year prison sentence, no need to torture him to make the point.
- RobertoG 11y agoManning has been tortured. As a member of the army I suppose there are some differences but it's not so difficult to think that the same could happen.
- pekk 11y agoManning was convicted of espionage, imprisoned, and put into solitary confinement under the legal authority of UCMJ. Unfortunately, this is all legal, backed by the popular view that sentencing should be punitive and serve as a deterrent. Think of all the people in solitary confinement who, unlike Manning, were never in the public eye.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoRendition just means giving something e.g. giving someone up for extradition. "Extraordinary rendition" is some weird orwellian way of saying "we kidnapped people and took them to countries that will torture them for us"
- tptacek 11y agoThat's not true. Rendition is the act a host country takes in yielding a subject to the country requesting extradition. What you're referring to is the Orwellian term "extraordinary rendition" (the correct term is "kidnapping"), in which subjects are detained extrajudicially and shipped to a third party jurisdiction to be tortured. "Torture" is important to the definition of "extraordinary rendition", as getting subjects to countries where they can be tortured is the reason "extraordinary" measures have to be taken in the first place.
- pc86 11y agoSerious question: is it kidnapping if US Marshals go into Mexico and grab a fugitive to bring him back to the US? Maybe it is, maybe we (generally, as a country) are okay with it under certain circumstances or for certain offenses.
- RobertoG 11y agoDoes it happen frequently? (Serious question, I don't know).
- pc86 11y agoI have no idea, I just know it has happened in the past both with and without approval/consent of Mexican officials. I don't think they'd be super public about it either way. Either it happens very rarely and that's a safe way to evade capture, or it happens every day and people will stop running to Mexico.
- langarto 11y agoIf it happens as you describe, then it is definitely kidnapping.
- tptacek 11y agoI don't believe it is the case that US law enforcement agents can go into Mexico and arrest people. Can anyone clarify this?
- 11y ago
- luso_brazilian 11y agoExtradition is a well defined process subject to a defined judicial review by the countries involved. According to the Wikipedia article on (extraordinary) rendition "in the United States, the first well-known rendition case was that of an airline hijacker abducted in Italy and brought to the U.S. for trial, authorized by President Ronald Reagan". It seems like the Snowden case would fit the same definition.
- vageli 11y agoThe US would extradite him, but the Danes would render him.