3 ms·
The statistic might be stupid, but it does a marvellous job of illustrating immense inequality in wealth distribution, something which is both factual and impor
by crishoj 11y ago
The statistic might be stupid, but it does a marvellous job of illustrating immense inequality in wealth distribution, something which is both factual and important. Would you not agree?
- mattlutze 11y agoIf the statistic is inaccurate then it does a bad job at illustrating the inequality, because it's falsity discredits the conversation. In fact, it would be detrimental to the goal of telling the inequality story.
- richmarr 11y agoHow would you sum up the message to be both 'accurate' and consumable?
- Ntrails 11y agoGenerally the reason statistics are so dangerous when used to support an argument is that the argument quickly becomes about the validity of the number rather than the underlying issue. At a very basic level comparing wealth between economies requires all sorts of subjective normalisation which is pretty open to challenge, and accounting for things like student debt is obviously going to be contentious. Frankly I consider it surprising that you can even find the calculation methodology for something like that.
- dawnbreez 11y agoThe trouble is that a burger flipper will not make as much money as an inventor, programmer, or doctor, no matter how much time you spend demanding minimum wage increases. The former's job is far less effort-intensive than the others; even if you created a fascist state and ordered that all burger-flippers be paid as CEOs, you would immediately lose your CEOs as they all quit to become burger-flippers.
- vsl 11y agoWhen tou have to cook statistics to have this "immense inequality", no, I would not.