2 ms·
It could be that carbon consumption is fairly widespread between rich and poor: in other words, Bill Gates does not consume 100000 times the carbon that Joe Sch
by davidw 11y ago
It could be that carbon consumption is fairly widespread between rich and poor: in other words, Bill Gates does not consume 100000 times the carbon that Joe Schmoe does, but maybe only 10 times as much, or perhaps even less. This means that to actually make a dent in usage, you have to make the tax hit everyone.
Of course, you could also try and compensate by lowering income taxes, or increasing the EITC or something, so that the tax is offset for the poorest, but still give them an incentive to use less carbon.
That's what this conservative commentator suggests: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/06/upshot/the-key-role-of-conservatives-in-taxing-carbon.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/06/upshot/the-key-role-of-con...
But... politics. Flagged.
- sumedh 11y ago> Bill Gates does not consume 100000 times the carbon that Joe Schmoe does People lile Gates and Buffett travel in their private plane, they do consume more carbon compared to the average joe.
- davidw 11y agoIt's likely, but do you see the point? They earn orders of magnitude more and have a zillion times more in the bank. But in terms of carbon - or food, to pick something else - they may not consume that much more than the average person. Put another way, 10000 Joe Schmoes are going to consume way more carbon or food than 1 Bill Gates. So to actually curb carbon usage, you're going to have to take that into account. One way to make it 'fair' would be to offset those costs in other ways: if you continue to drive as before, it'll be neutral, but if you curb your driving, you'll actually come out ahead financially. That's the theory, at least.
- rubberstamp 11y agowhat about carbon foot print of Gates' businesses -building and running costs
- zardo 11y agoThere are many ways to set up a revenue neutral carbon tax, but if all the revenue is distributed back to citizens equally, Microsoft pays the tax, but does not get a refund. Businesses that are large carbon emitters have to raise their prices, and the market cares about CO2 a little bit more.
- cbhl 11y ago> It could be that carbon consumption is fairly widespread between rich and poor It's less clear that oil consumption is equal for the rich and the poor. The rich person can afford a Tesla and have zero gas usage. The poor person is driving a '93 Ford Taurus that barely passes environmental air quality standards, let alone having any sort of fuel economy.