4 ms·
Before shredding this mess, let us first give credit where it is due. They did get the age of the universe about right. General consensus right now places it at
by stcredzero 11y ago
Before shredding this mess, let us first give credit where it is due. They did get the age of the universe about right. General consensus right now places it at 13.8 billion years, and that is when all matter in the universe was created. However, not all atoms were “born” then, as they indicate, as most have been generated through fusion in stars and supernova.
To be pedantic at the level the madartlab.com folks seem to be going after, the video doesn't state that all atoms were born 13.8 billion years ago. It says "the atom" was born 13.8 billion years ago. This is correct.
http://patrickgrant.com/BBTL.htm http://patrickgrant.com/BBTL.htm
It took 300,000 years for conditions to get the point where neutral atoms could form. That's still about 13.8 billion years ago to a reasonable margin of error. It's entirely correct to say that "the atom" was born then. This is the point in time from which the cosmic microwave background dates from, so it's arguably our view of the Big Bang.
We'll see about the rest of the video now.