2 ms·
I wasn't trying to imply that unemployment is an overall drain, I was simply pointing out a countervailing factor. Overall, I really don't know how these variou
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
I wasn't trying to imply that unemployment is an overall drain, I was simply pointing out a countervailing factor. Overall, I really don't know how these various factors add up. I imagine the result varies widely from place to place, and it's a very difficult empirical question to answer.
In fact, ultimately I suspect that the variation from place to place is the exact opposite of what would be optimal.
As you say, Detroit auto workers are on the wrong side of every variable. I expect that they also vote for generous benefits. In contrast, a place with a hard working "get off your ass and get a damn job" culture will probably vote for stingy unemployment benefits even though generous benefits would not be (locally) harmful.
It's a bit of a flaw with a democratic system.
However, a proposed solution which addresses both aggregate demand and disincentives would be to make unemployment benefits as unpleasant as possible while still providing monetary benefits. For instance, we could create a social stigma around receiving unemployment benefits. Or we might require unemployed people to submit to weekly adversarial interviews about their job search at 3AM in a cold/hot building with no chairs.