5 ms·
This "Google Safe Browsing" initiative seriously worries me. It's effectively some unknown, mysterious, un-contactable set of AI algorithms/people/who knows wha
by dheera 11y ago
This "Google Safe Browsing" initiative seriously worries me. It's effectively some unknown, mysterious, un-contactable set of AI algorithms/people/who knows what controlling the internet because Google owns everyone's browser.
One of my websites got tagged as "Dangerous" and having "harmful programs" despite having nothing of the sort. My guess is a silly hiccup of their neural network algorithms. And I have absolutely nobody I can contact about the issue to get an explanation. They just effectively killed the site in one fell swoop.
- ryanlol 11y agoAs with most things in this world, you could sue them.
- dheera 11y agoIt wasn't a major or revenue-generating site, so I don't want to spend on legal fees. If it had been though, I would.
- ryanlol 11y agoYeah, I've experienced the same and it's really a pain in the ass. Apparently there's tons of orgs that can automatically add sites to that blacklist, I got abuse from some company saying there was a phishing page on my IP because it featured a login page and the text "Amazon" and suddenly chrome started showing alerts when I visited the IP. As with most of similar systems (spamhaus etc) the people running them are just as bad as the people they're trying to stop.
- mtgx 11y agoHow many of the sites that were illegitimately blocked can afford to sue Google? How many can afford to win against Google's top notch legal team?
- ryanlol 11y agoThe real question is "Is it worth it for google to send their legal team to some small claims court hearing instead of just unblocking the site?" And contrary to the popular belief, suing people really isn't that expensive if you've got the time to do it.
- sharkweek 11y agoHas any site that has been incorrectly de-indexed from Google sued and won? I have no idea, but this would be super fascinating.
- jfoster 11y agoDe-indexed in search is a bit different from effectively blocked in the browser. If Chrome says your site is dangerous and actually your site is harmless, are they defaming your website? If Google choose not to include you in their search engine, that could still be an issue, but it's probably a lot more nuanced.
- crdoconnor 11y agoThey'd invoke the first amendment. It would be pretty open and shut.
- nerfhammer 11y agoIf the claim that your site is dangerous is demonstrably false and there are demonstrable damages you can indeed be liable for damages or face injunction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_statements_of_fact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_statements_of_fact
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ryanlol 11y agoI'm not sure if you know what the "first amendment" is. I'll tell you what it isn't, it's not a magical trump card that lets you say whatever you want.
- crdoconnor 11y agohttp://searchengineland.com/another-court-affirms-googles-first-amendment-control-search-results-209034 http://searchengineland.com/another-court-affirms-googles-fi... That seems to be how Google is (successfully) using it.
- maehwasu 11y agoThat's a VERY different situation. Google is claiming there that (essentially) they have the right to put sites in whatever order they want, and US courts are extremely sympathetic to that argument. Here the issue is that Google is making direct, verbal claims about other sites. That's not to say Google couldn't come up with a strategy to win in court, but the strategy would have to differ markedly.
- killface 11y agogoogle is not a government agency. you can't claim first amendment when dealing with private parties. that's like me suing the NFL for not letting me post racist rants on their homepage because of the first amendment. edit: i dun read gud. leaving comment as an homage to lack of literacy
- enzanki_ars 11y agoAccording to the FAQ[0] of the safe browsing program, they attempt to contact you first, but there is a way to contact them. What if you can’t get in touch with the webmaster because they’re not registered with Google Webmaster Tools? Every time we add an unsafe site to the list, we make a reasonable effort attempt to inform the webmaster by sending a notification to a standard set of email addresses (e.g., webmaster@[sitename].com; info@[sitename].com; admin@[sitename].com). If my website has been compromised and is now unsafe, what can I do? We offer advice for webmasters whose sites have been hacked here. It’s best to register your site at Google Webmaster Tools in advance of any problems so that we can notify you promptly and provide more information about the problems we find. If you don’t want to use Google Webmaster Tools, you can file appeals with StopBadware.org once you have removed the infection from your site. StopBadware.org also offers great resources for webmasters who want to learn more about what they can do to make their sites safer. [0]: https://www.google.com/transparencyreport/safebrowsing/faq/?hl=en https://www.google.com/transparencyreport/safebrowsing/faq/?...
- dheera 11y agoA while ago I submitted my site for review and provided a contact. I got no response. I also got no such e-mail. In addition it seems they only send you a "notification", i.e. an automatic "We've blocked you" and not a human attempt to resolve the issue. If a human had been viewing my site it would have been 100% clear that there is no malware issue. However, since I do make use of certain HTML5 features after prompting the user, I could see why it causes a trigger if they have some half-baked neural network algorithm trying to identify potential malware based on JavaScript source. If anyone is wondering, the site is a location-based file sharing app. It makes use of geolocation and file uploading capabilities. Largely a quick experiment, throwing an idea out there just to see if there's any need for such an app. It was running fine for a few months before Google decided to block it. https://quack.space/ https://quack.space/ (which gives a malware error now on Chrome) https://www.producthunt.com/tech/quack-space https://www.producthunt.com/tech/quack-space (ProductHunt page)
- kuschku 11y ago> Google owns everyone's browser It doesn’t have to be like that.
- vlunkr 11y agoIt doesn't have to, but that's the way it's trending.
- tedmiston 11y agoWhat website?
- dingdingdang 11y agoYes, there's good reason why I'm posting this from https://www.palemoon.org/ https://www.palemoon.org/ which is Firefox without the politics - Chrome is too intrusive and non-transparent about its intrusion to boot.
- jusob 11y agoFirefox uses Google Safe Browsing, like Opera and Safari.
- sleepychu 11y agoHow do they fund their security patches?
- dingdingdang 11y agofund as in finance?
- sleepychu 11y agoYup, to be on top of the security stuff is a really expensive thing to do.
- dingdingdang 11y agoSaw this late: I believe they have a running policy of porting all security stuff from main rep FF and adding additional hardening on top (by disabling semi baked features and removing legacy stuff, like XP support, at a much quicker rate than regular FF releases). But how this is managed in terms of man-hours/pay/etc. - haven't got the faintest: organisational transparency is expensive but would be ever so great to get right for software vendors on the whole!
- sleepychu 11y agoYup, to be on top of the security stuff is a really expensive thing to do.
- Tyr42 11y agoI always thought it was something like visiting the site with a somewhat unprotected (but virtualized) computer and seeing if anything bad (registry keys changed) happened.