2 ms·
Sorry, but I'm not going to get into any specifics about the CAD systems. I have seen first-hand (though fortunately as a third party) what happened when someon
by Silhouette 11y ago
Sorry, but I'm not going to get into any specifics about the CAD systems. I have seen first-hand (though fortunately as a third party) what happened when someone upset the wrong big name in that industry, and I have no interest in either spending the next part of my life defending a frivolous lawsuit supposedly necessary to protect their reputation nor in having licences tied to me revoked under blatantly abusive EULA terms. I will say that your assumption was wrong, though; it was not AutoCAD that I was referring to.
As for the Adobe issue, as I see it the point is that the original product was known to be faulty, and a means of correcting the defect was already made. Given the cost and expected useful lifetime of the original software, and given the relatively small and presumably diminishing-over-time cost of maintaining an update server relative to that, I have no problem in this sort of case with literally requiring perpetual availability of the existing updates for as long as the developer is around and it is commercially viable to do so. I don't think this is a universally appropriate solution, but for the kind of software we're talking about that makes many millions or billions in revenues, it doesn't seem at all unreasonable to me. If the software developer doesn't like it, they are free not to incorporate artificially limited technology in their product in the first place, for example by distributing updates in a freely downloadable form instead of via a proprietary system with limited availability.
Incidentally, if a software product really has no remaining value after just 6 years, the developers are welcome to relinquish the relevant copyright as well since clearly it also has no remaining value at that point, and then anyone else who is willing and able to solve any future problems with that software can lawfully do so. Perhaps the law should no longer give the developers a choice, by including a specific exemption to copyright for actions reasonably necessary to allow the continued effective operation of the software according to the original deal. In this case, that might extend up to and including installing a cracked pirate version instead, provided that the use would otherwise have been lawful.
As you say, I suspect in the near future a lot of these big software developers are going to try to bypass these issues entirely by moving everyone onto subscription models anyway. I don't expect that strategy to remain a viable exclusive proposition in the longer term, though, because it's too hostile to users. In most cases, it will naturally create opportunities for less hostile alternatives in the market, as we're already seeing with the increasing competition faced by Adobe Creative Cloud from smaller, cheaper, but still professional-quality and well-regarded alternatives in various niches.