3 ms·
£35K is not unreasonable. However if you ask me it should be £35K outside of London and £38.5K within. It far too easy to find a London job that pays £35K, even
by Someone1234 11y ago
£35K is not unreasonable. However if you ask me it should be £35K outside of London and £38.5K within. It far too easy to find a London job that pays £35K, even a lot of entry positions are in the high 20s (27-28K).
That being said, while it is fine for workers, what the UK government have tried to do to people on family visas is very immoral. And has caused a lot of families to be separated.
- To sponsor a spouse you must make: £18,600
- To sponsor a spouse and one child you must make: £22,400 (+£2,400 for each additional child).
For reference the medium salary in the UK is around £22,044, the average is around £26,500 but neither tell the whole story, the UK has a wide salary disparity (in particular London Vs. elsewhere), and some charities project that the above rules preclude over a third of the population from bringing in their family.
Can you imagine being separated from your spouse and child because you don't make enough? Even if that spouse is perfectly able to work? And the worst part is that a lot of people get caught in a poverty trap, where they don't make enough to pay for the skills that they would need to escape it.
The problem is these types of rules come from London where wages are much higher and from very affluent individuals who came from money. They typically impact the poorest parts of the UK, but as they say "out of sight out of mind." Who cares if someone in north England cannot see their family for years... Certainly not Westminister.
- edandersen 11y agoTo elaborate on the spousal visa issue: this only applies to non-EU spouses. As a British citizen, if you decide to marry a non-EU person, be prepared for hell when you try to get them in. However, Germans living in Britain can get their non-EU spouse in under the German rules. These policies are a result of the governments impossible, damaging pledge to get immigration "in the tens of thousands". What happens is that they look at a categorized list of immigration categories, realize they cannot do anything at all about EU immigration so double down on non-EU migration. Except the rules only apply to British citizens, because they are the only people they can apply these rules consistently to. Therefore we are left with the bizarre situation where it is easier for a French person in Britain to get their spouse in than a British person in Britain. There are British people effectively exiled because they went abroad when young, got married and had a kid and cannot return with their family because they don't have a guaranteed job lined up in the UK paying 18k+. The spouses income is deemed irrelevant under the rules, so even if your non-EU spouse can earn well above that, it doesn't matter. Ridiculous, borderline sick fiddling from the government that has severely damaged the family lives of tens of thousands of Britons.
- pascalmemories 11y agoThe work round is to spend 3 months in the EU and then return under EU rules and not UK. The case was Surinder Singh but there are subsequent rulings - https://www.freemovement.org.uk/surinder-singh-immigration-route/ https://www.freemovement.org.uk/surinder-singh-immigration-r... You'll still be rejected out of hand and forced to resort to legal action however. You're right that the UK has targeted non-EU spouses and is intentionally obstructive, arbitrary and perverse in their dealings, all for the political ends you describe.
- bruceb 11y agoWhy is immoral to make sure people earn enough to support a spouse and a child that they will bring with them or have come over? Is England obligated to take care of non citizens? US has same rules.
- edandersen 11y agoBecause it discriminates based the nationality of who you marry. If you marry someone from the EU the rules do not apply.
- thawkins 11y agoOf course its discrimatory, it discriminates in the favor of british and eu citizens, is that wrong? Are we saying that non citizens have the same rights of entry as citizens? I live in the far east, in order to qualify for a residency visa, i have to show assets of at least $50,000. In fact i have to bind that in an accredited savings account. So minimum asset determinatiins for residency qualification is common and not a vile abnormality as sugested.
- Someone1234 11y ago> Of course its discrimatory, it discriminates in the favor of british and eu citizens, is that wrong? You have that backwards. British citizens are the ones it harms, they're the ones who cannot see their spouse or child. > Are we saying that non citizens have the same rights of entry as citizens? Dependants of British nationals should have the same rights, yes. > So minimum asset determinatiins for residency qualification is common and not a vile abnormality as sugested. We are talking about visas to bring a spouse or child into the country, you're talking about something else entirely. I don't see the connection. I also have no idea what country or visa type you're even referring to.
- Someone1234 11y ago> Why is immoral to make sure people earn enough to support a spouse and a child that they will bring with them or have come over? Because separating families is immoral. If you don't think causing a parent and child to be separated is immoral then your list of immoral actions must be slim. > Is England obligated to take care of non citizens? You call them non-citizens, I call them dependants of UK citizens. Also the rules entirely ignore the spouse's earning potential which is stupid. > US has same rules. No it doesn't. The US does have a minimum income level but firstly it is much lower, and additionally you can get numerous additional sponsors to combine incomes. So someone in the US could get their parents as co-sponsors, and thus allowing even someone working at Walmart to bring in a foreign spouse and child.
- robk 11y agoBut how do you reconcile that with those that marry through arranged, sometimes forced marriages, to those in some poor countries? This law is intended to reduce that scenario which is a wide backdoor to normal immigration.
- Someone1234 11y ago> But how do you reconcile that with those that marry through arranged, sometimes forced marriages, to those in some poor countries? Forced marriages are already illegal under UK law, and additionally a foreign spouse cannot enter without support by a UK-national sponsor. You cannot use extremely rare incidents to justify a policy of mass discrimination (against non-EU citizens, and UK nationals that are impacted). > This law is intended to reduce that scenario which is a wide backdoor to normal immigration. There's no backdoor. UK nationals are meant to be able to bring in spouses and children. The fact they cannot in some cases because they make the national median in salary is just disturbing. Essentially poor people have one set of rules and affluent people have another.
- oldmanjay 11y agoOh there are so many more than two sets of rules, and the predicates that determine which sets apply to any given individual are legion as well.
- clort 11y agoYou state that it is a 'wide backdoor' and while it seems that you could describe this as a backdoor, to assert that it is a wide one seems .. dubious to me. Also, the fact that forced marriage exists is not enough, because it is not necessarily used to foster immigration. Both of the people I have known who had spouses arranged for them had this done because of 'cultural history' and actually went to live abroad with their new husbands (one later managed to leave him and return by herself, I don't know of the other) I think that the situation you describe (forced marriage) could be illegal already and while it would be good to detect and punish the perpertrators of this kind of offence, to penalise a whole bunch of other people in their name seems somewhat excessive.