3 ms·
Maybe people with low sperm concentrations tend to sit around using their cell phone while it is plugged in? The abstract doesn't really propose a mechanism, i
by maxerickson 11y ago
Maybe people with low sperm concentrations tend to sit around using their cell phone while it is plugged in?
The abstract doesn't really propose a mechanism, it just notes the correlation.
Pushing people with certain usage patterns to get screening for low t (or whatever) can still be a useful outcome of the further research.
Not that I think they really need to get funding to pursue it, but you are imputing the proposal of a causative radiation mechanism.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoRight - I'm charitably assuming that their study supported causality with p=0.02. In reality it doesn't.
- maxerickson 11y agoMy statement above but you are imputing the proposal of a causative radiation mechanism. is poorly phrased. A better way to put what I was getting at is that they are not claiming that radiation effects are the only possible causative mechanism. They found some observation in some data and published it, probably in the service of a future grant proposal. Saying they didn't prove anything for this publication is like saying water is wet. Should hn spend much time discussing the result (or really, observation)? Absolutely not. Should they get grant funding for this? I dunno, I hope there are better proposals out there, but really have no idea.