7 ms·
She's also the head of the "Christian Democratic Union" party...
by k__ 11y ago
She's also the head of the "Christian Democratic Union" party...
- sdoering 11y agoAnd what does this information tell anyone? Not liking her in any way, but that information is not adding anything to this. She was there as Head of State, starting an important experiment funded by the state and lending importance to this scientific endeavor in this way. Or at least hoping to garner some positiv press for herself, that she is in dire need of. But being Head of a (by the way just so called) christian party does not tell anything in a very secularized country like German.
- k__ 11y agoThe same could been said to my parent comment. That's why I wrote this ;)
- 50CNT 11y agoThe name came out the the desire to unite catholic and protestant groups after WWII in a centre party. They've been open to non-christians since inception, and they decided to keep the "Christian" in the name to emphasize their concern over the Christian image of man, from which they derive their view that human dignity is worthy of protection as it is given by God. They do seem conservative by comparison to their main opponent party, the SPD, which has Marxist roots, but compared to say US politics, they would be considered moderates. In that sense, it's disingenuous to take them out of the German political spectrum (which is much more moderate than the US), and judge them by name alone. She's certainly not a bible thumping Christian denying global warming. [0] [0][http://www.environmental-watch.com/profiles/angela-merkel/ http://www.environmental-watch.com/profiles/angela-merkel/]
- kuschku 11y agoWell, her opinion on gay marriage (not compatible with her opinions about the traditional definition of marriage) shows that she is definitely quite conservative.
- k__ 11y ago> they derive their view that human dignity is worthy of protection as it is given by God q.e.d. > compared to say US politics, they would be considered moderates compared to the US politics, probably all german parties are considered moderates Till the AfD showed up, CDU/CSU were the most conservative parties (besides some really small ones that never got over 5% of the votes) in Germany. > She's certainly not a bible thumping Christian denying global warming That's true, but there don't seem to be much countries in the world, besides the US, where you could get voters which such comments... My point was just, that the parent poster quoted this text, that made the impression Germany is so advanced that we even have a physicist as Chancellor, while Merkel in fact is a member of a christian party.
- germanier 11y agoI don't know how having a chancellor who is member of a party bearing the word christianity in it's name makes a country more or less "advanced".
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 11y agoI don't know how having a chancellor who is member of a party bearing the word astrology in its name makes a country more or less "advanced".
- 50CNT 11y agoShe is a physicist though, which reminds me of one "controversial" statement she made in an interview. Essentially, the interviewer asked her what she liked most about her job as Chancellor, to which she replied "I like that there's interesting new problems every day", which her critics jumped on almost immediately. Now the thing is, she almost certainly meant that in the way a scientist talks about "problems", but it wasn't interpreted that way by political commentators. I'm honestly not too concerned about there being a CDU instead of there being just a DU, as long as they're not pushing the Christian angle too strongly. As long as their policy is sound, they could be the Pastafari Democratic Union for all I care. Maybe the Pirate Party will step up to that role, becoming the PPP, which would net them my vote.
- 11y ago
- cbd1984 11y ago> human dignity is worthy of protection as it is given by God. Except if those humans are gay, or Turkish, or Muslim...
- ricardobeat 11y agoChristians outside of the US are rarely that conservative or judgemental of others' choices. On the contrary, being able to accept those differences is one of the core beliefs.
- oldmanjay 11y agoDo you have actual experience with Christians all over the world? I've certainly met a few that put the lie to your assertion, from a variety of places, and I suspect you're making the classic mistake of calling the place you live "the rest of the world" in comparison to the US.
- aidenn0 11y agoAfter we got engaged, my wife was told by Swiss missionaries living in France that it would be wrong marry me because I'm Roman Catholic. Furthermore they assumed that she would have to become a practicing Catholic as, after all, the husband is the head of the household and it would be immoral for the wife to persist in different beliefs and practices. Granted, the percentage of people in the US that would agree with all of the above is much higher than in Europe, but it's not like conservative Protestantism (or Roman Catholicism for that matter) doesn't exist there.
- kbenson 11y agoNot that I feel a distinct need to defend stereotyping statements towards large disparate groups of people, but I think the original statement was meant to imply the general Christian populations of other countries. People that visit other countries specifically to spread their religion may have somewhat more extreme views than people of the same the general population of their originating countries.
- 11y ago
- lagadu 11y agoBeing religious or part of a party with religious affiliation is entirely different in pretty much anywhere in Europe than it is in the US. Non-secular views on any major subject are effectively unheard of here; there's nothing conflicting about being religious and secular here.
- jagermo 11y agoThis right here. Religion is more like a hobby (if you are not a politican with a clear agenda and in need of propaganda material and no solid evidence to back it up) not something you need to tout everytime you go on camera.
- baldfat 11y ago> Religion is more like a hobby As a religious person I would say you are seeing these values as extrinsic, but MOST religious people see religion as intrinsic (AKA essential to who they are). If you reject religion of people you devalue who they are and not some "Hobby." I would warn you that that statement was more hurtful then you meant it to be.
- douche 11y agoThat comment might be in the context of Germany, where people generally don't seem to get wrapped up in religious identity to the extent that they do in the US. From what I saw living there, many Germans don't set foot in a church outside of Christmas and Easter. I sure would like to have federal holidays for all those Catholic saint's days like they do in Bavaria, though...
- usrusr 11y agoPeople don't need to be religious for religion to be part of their identity. Many german atheists still identify with one of the two main churches even when they don't have the smallest trace of belief in them. After centuries of highly formalized coexistence, the lutheran and catholic churches have become subtle but deeply rooted parts of regional identities.
- return0 11y agoThe british have a "Queen" and a "Kingdom" as well, what's your point.
- noir_lord 11y agoNot to mention our Queen is also the head of an entire religion and on paper has powers to suspend parliament, her assent is required on legislation passed (a power that hasn't been used for 300 years btw), she can remove Ministers (of the crown) and just for kicks she can declare war and is beyond prosecution. Of course the second she used these powers they'd be removed but yeah, it's an interesting framework. Edit: oops, forgot - she is also the Command in Chief of all armed forces and in theory has complete control of the disposition of forces.
- lucozade 11y agoAs it's pedantic Wednesday I'd does like to point out that the Queen uses these powers regularly.In fact we can't pass legislation in the UK without her assent, she suspends Parliament all the time, she removes Ministers etc. What hasn't happened in a long time is for her to act contrary to Ministers' advice. It's probably fair to say that there is close to negligible chance that that state of affairs (or Affairs of State if you prefer) will change in the present Queen's lifetime. Charles, however, may make things a little more constitutionally interesting as he has far more activist tendencies.
- deskamess 11y agoDon't forget that she lords over Canada (Queen, Head of State) and laws require her royal assent. Not a fan, and do not like that in the Canadian oath you have to pledge to her (a human) instead of something non-human that symbolizes Canada (like the Canadian flag). It is unfortunate that in the oath you have to be subservient to another person - so much for all people created equally.
- kwhitefoot 11y agoNo one in the UK pledges allegiance to anyone or anything, certainly not on a regular basis. What is this Canadian oath? I don't think a Brit would have to be a republican to find pledging allegiance to the monarch a rather odd thing to do. And as for pledging allegiance to the flag, well which one? Union flag, the Saltire, the Red Dragon? I might give a little respect to Saint Piran's banner but I'm not about to swear allegiance to it even though half my ancestors are Cornish. Or should I choose the Wessex Wyvern because that is the region where I was born and lived for the first 25 years of my life? Sorry for drifting off topic, got carried away. :-)
- dang 11y agoThis throwaway bit of arson (or at minimum, criminal negligence) set off a ridiculous religious flamewar. That means you did serious damage to this site. Please never do that again. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11032716 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11032716 and marked it off-topic.
- k__ 11y agoCalling this arson or criminal negligence is a bit of a stretch, don't you think? I just stated a fact here. :\ "She's physicist" ... "She is head of the CDU" ... the end. Yes I saw what it brought here and after a few posts, I was like "Oh wait, this is an Internet Argument... better don't look at it anymore" but it was already too late. Well, I'm sorry.
- dang 11y ago> Calling this arson or criminal negligence is a bit of a stretch, don't you think? Oh yes. I didn't mean it literally. It's just that starting a flamewar on purpose is one thing, and accidentally setting one off is another, but both are bad. I'm sorry I came down on you that hard. Such flamewars are awful but they're also very much a community creation, which is why they're hard to prevent.
- k__ 11y agoWell, my thought was the HN crowd would simply ignore this, acknowledge it or vote me down and be done with it. Seems like religion is a heated topic, even here. Next time I know better :)