3 ms·
> I do think the Tufte essay is excellent except for one detail. I don't think that one detail is the only serious flaw in the essay. As far as I can tell, Boi
by pdonis 11y ago
> I do think the Tufte essay is excellent except for one detail.
I don't think that one detail is the only serious flaw in the essay. As far as I can tell, Boisjoly's criticisms--that Tufte misunderstood the actual issue (it was blow-by, not erosion), and that he misunderstood what information the engineers did and did not have (for example, they didn't have reliable temperature data for many flights)--are valid.