12 ms·
Nuclear fusion device's first test with hydrogen declared a success
- weinzierl 11y ago> German Chancellor Angela Merkel [..] who holds > a doctorate in physics, personally pressed the button > at Wednesday's launch of an experiment they hope > will advance the quest for nuclear fusion, considered > a clean and safe form of nuclear power.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoDo I understand correctly that they haven't actually fused anything yet, just verified that the stellarator can power up without immediately exploding? What's special about the Wendelstein 7-X? I know stellarators as a concept aren't new. Is this a significant result, or is it just a handy opportunity for a media event?
- pastullo 11y agoThe article says that the 7X won't ever produce energy. Over the course of the following years they will try to leave it on for longer and longer period of time. SO yes, they kept it on for less then a second, nothing exploded and future looks quite brigth i would say
- dest 11y ago7X may produce energy, but it is not planned (AFAIK) to produce electricity from it. 7X is a scientifical machine, not an industrial one.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 11y agoNope, it won't, it's too small for that, it will always need more energy input to keep the reaction going than the reaction itself produces.
- dest 11y agoBy producing energy, I meant hosting some fusion reactions, even if few of them compared to the external heating power. Sorry for the confusion. By the way, do you know what is the estimated gain factor of W7X, even if < 1 ? I could not find that info on the web.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 11y agoNo clue, unfortunately ... I might have known at some point, but I unfortunately don't remember the source anymore either ...
- dest 11y agoW7X is special as it is more performant than previous stellarators. For fusion devices, you hope to produce more energy than the energy you have to inject to heat the plasma for fusion to happen. Yesterday's event was not much about science, but rather about engineering. Building that machine was a gigantic work.
- creshal 11y ago> For fusion devices, you hope to produce more energy than the energy you have to inject to heat the plasma for fusion to happen. Which Wendelstein can't do – for that, you'll need much more radioactive reactions (involving tritium), and Wendelstein isn't (and can't be) sufficiently shielded for those. Wendelstein is a research reactor: It's covered in sensors in and out, and it can be easily disassembled or opened up for repairs and modifications, which you generally don't want to do if everything's covered in radiation activated materials. If Wendelstein holds up to its plans, derivative designs can be used to build net-positive reactors involving tritium (and lots of shielding). > Yesterday's event was not much about science, but rather about engineering. Building that machine was a gigantic work. Indeed. Most of its design was finalized in the 80s and the project took 25 years to just get the funding, build the (first of a kind) components and build a working reactor out of them.
- petra 11y ago>> Most of its design was finalized in the 80s and the project took 25 years So in light of that, how long we we have ,assuming all goes well, before a working reactor ?
- creshal 11y agoI'm not sure we can extrapolate here: Right now it's expensive government-driven research, Manhattan project style. Once it's proven that you can make money with fusion (and Wendelstein is our best bet), all hell will break loose.
- Ygg2 11y agoIn programmer speak, you're essentially asking for how long will it take to implement some new feature (let's say collaborative text editor) in language unknown to you :P Could be months, years, or even decades.
- legulere 11y agoThat happened a few weeks ago with Helium, not they did it with Hydrogen
- onion2k 11y agoThey've been doing test fires with helium to clean the inside of the stellarator for the past few months. This news is because yesterday, with hydrogen, they ran a plasma at 80million degrees for 0.25 seconds. Still a few years away from the goal of 100 million degrees for 30 minutes, but it's a huge achievement. When that's working they'll start putting deuterium in and the fusion fun will begin, but not at a level that actually has a net energy output. That will only happen with tritium, but that won't ever be done in this particular stellerator (at least there aren't any plans to do it).
- cygx 11y agoWhat's special about the Wendelstein 7-X? The number of functional stellarators is rather limited, so getting it built is a success in itself. W7-X will be the largest of the bunch and is supposed to sustain plasma for up to 30min (for comparison, the record for tokamaks is 6.5min, and ITER will only add a minute or two to that).
- kriro 11y agoCliffnote version is: stellarators are hard/expensive to build. The test run shows this one seems to be built correctly. Simplifying a ton one could compare the two competing designs as follows: stellerator: harder to build, easier to run (and more efficient) tokamak: easier to build, harder to run (and less efficient) Due to the first property, there are more tokamaks around and showing basic functionality for any stellerator is a good/important step. Edit (relevant quote from the article): """Although there are about a dozen stellarator experiments around the world, including in the U.S., Japan, Australia and Europe, scientists say the Greifswald device is the first to match the performance of tokamaks."""
- Zardoz84 11y ago> stellerator: harder to build, easier to run (and more efficient) > tokamak: easier to build, harder to run (and less efficient) Too simplistic view... Read more about how works each design (wikipedia).
- InclinedPlane 11y agoI don't think they generated any fusion reactions, I believe they used just natural Hydrogen rather than Deuterium and Tritium (which would normally be used for fusion fuel). Also, magnetic confinement fusion reactors don't explode, they are like pencils balanced on their points, when something goes wrong or they "lose containment" the pencil falls over, the fusion conditions dissipate and reactions stop. This test was just one step along the way of verifying the plasma dynamics and heating capabilities of the system, it'll be a while before they do fusion reactions, and it will never produce energy from fusion. But be aware that making fusion reactions happen is easy, it's the matter of creating a self-sustaining fusion reaction that's hard. In magnetic confinement fusion there is a big problem of confinement stability. You are trying to confine a plasma, which is electrically charged and thus an electrical conductor. Electric current generates a magnetic field. This is actually made use of in tokamak designs, which are the most straightforward magnetic confinement systems. However, tokamaks suffer from a fundamental flaw, that plasma current produces a feedback instability loop making it very challenging to attain plasma confinement longer than a few seconds or minutes. That's problematic because the shorter lived the fusion plasma is the more the initial (externally produced) heat as a proportion of the total cumulative heat of the plasma over its lifetime adds up. Short lived plasmas don't spend very long producing fusion heat to "pay back" the energy used to heat up the plasma to fusion conditions to start with. A stellarator is basically a way to twist the magnetic fields around the fusion plasma tube in such a way so that the trajectories of ions in the plasma will stay inside the confinement volume, without requiring any current in the plasma. This makes the system potentially much more stable but at the cost of a very much more complex arrangement of magnets. The longer the plasma can be confined the longer fusion reactions can be sustained, making it easier to generate more power than was put in to raise the plasma to fusion suitable conditions (high density, high temperature).
- Zardoz84 11y ago> This is actually made use of in tokamak designs, which are the most straightforward magnetic confinement systems. Wrong! The most straightforward magnetic confinement systems are : - Simple toroid design -> Have some flaws that make useless and Stellerator is a evolution of the idea, fixing it with twisted magnetic fields. - Magnetic mirrors -> Two simple coils separated, so the combination of the shape and the more dense magnetic field on the center of the coils, works like a mirror for charged particles. Also, at nearly the same time (around 1955) that the Russinas was begin to experiment with the Tokamak design, the British was experimenting wit the "ZETA", where the contaiment magnetic field comes ONLY from a current on the plasma.
- Xylakant 11y ago> What's special about the Wendelstein 7-X? I know stellarators as a concept aren't new. Is this a significant result, or is it just a handy opportunity for a media event? The concept is not new, they're just hideously complicated to build. It's a relatively new development that it's possible to model the shape of the magnetic fields and magnets required to keep the plasma. So it's a significant achievement to build one and prove that you can run it while containing the plasma. Yesterdays event is one step on that path.
- yongjik 11y agoDon't let movie physics fool you. Fusion reactors don't have a tendency to explode. (Well, at least not any more than any other industrial device connected to megawatts of power...) The problem with fusion is that they are notoriously hard to achieve, so basically they are always in the brink of fizzling out.
- k__ 11y agoShe's also the head of the "Christian Democratic Union" party...
- sdoering 11y agoAnd what does this information tell anyone? Not liking her in any way, but that information is not adding anything to this. She was there as Head of State, starting an important experiment funded by the state and lending importance to this scientific endeavor in this way. Or at least hoping to garner some positiv press for herself, that she is in dire need of. But being Head of a (by the way just so called) christian party does not tell anything in a very secularized country like German.
- k__ 11y agoThe same could been said to my parent comment. That's why I wrote this ;)
- 50CNT 11y agoThe name came out the the desire to unite catholic and protestant groups after WWII in a centre party. They've been open to non-christians since inception, and they decided to keep the "Christian" in the name to emphasize their concern over the Christian image of man, from which they derive their view that human dignity is worthy of protection as it is given by God. They do seem conservative by comparison to their main opponent party, the SPD, which has Marxist roots, but compared to say US politics, they would be considered moderates. In that sense, it's disingenuous to take them out of the German political spectrum (which is much more moderate than the US), and judge them by name alone. She's certainly not a bible thumping Christian denying global warming. [0] [0][http://www.environmental-watch.com/profiles/angela-merkel/ http://www.environmental-watch.com/profiles/angela-merkel/]
- kuschku 11y agoWell, her opinion on gay marriage (not compatible with her opinions about the traditional definition of marriage) shows that she is definitely quite conservative.
- overcast 11y agoI just love the name of the device. The Stellerator.
- ucho 11y agoMaybe it is a dumb question but does fusion really matter that much? I mean that nuclear reactors are ridiculously expensive to build and maintain and fusion only removes the cost of fuel acquiring and disposal. It might be 20%, 30% or even 40% cheaper but still not a revolution, no "Free energy for everyone". Are people over-hyped?
- oldmanjay 11y agoInstead of answering your question, I'm going to ask one; does your lack of vision more reasonably conclude with "people are overhyped" or something less opinionated? Consider that your opinion is admittedly based in ignorance rather than information.
- elorant 11y agoEver heard of Fukushima?
- rasz_pl 11y agoThat place where ONE worker died? of heart attack?
- 21 11y agoQuote: "The precise value of the abandoned cities, towns, agricultural lands, businesses, homes and property located within the roughly 310 sq miles (800 sq km) of the exclusion zones has not been established. Estimates of the total economic loss range from $250-$500 billion US."
- duaneb 11y agoFusion removes disposal. Right there is worth it—much of the fearmongering surrounding this hugely efficient energy source would be ameliorated.
- vortico 11y agoThe fuel is also much more environmentally friendly to extract. Tritium is hard to purify, but you don't need much of it, so it is probably more difficult to extract the steel for the reactor's structure than the fuel during its lifetime.