3 ms·
Because such a ban would obviously prevent illegal transactions from taking place; people might be committing other crimes, but they would never think of breaki
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
Because such a ban would obviously prevent illegal transactions from taking place; people might be committing other crimes, but they would never think of breaking this one.
- Someone1234 11y agoSo your point is, what? Because something is imperfect that the status quo where nothing is done is inherently superior? Plus a lot of people involved in money laundering have no idea they're involved in anything illegal: auctioneers, realtors, sometimes accountants, sometimes lawyers, etc. Or if they do know it is shady they can play ignorant. Laws like this make it harder to involve law abiding parties in illegal activity. PS - I actually feel like 5K is too low, 10K seems like a more reasonable lower limit.
- adrusi 11y agoThe point is that money laundering is already illegal, everyone who's doing it is already breaking the law. The only purpose this serves is to create a new law that is easier to prove violation of. A law that makes it easier to indict criminals at the expense of making legitimate acts illegal is fundamentally at odds with the physical underpinnings that give us the "innocent until proven guilty" doctrine.
- Someone1234 11y ago> The point is that money laundering is already illegal, everyone who's doing it is already breaking the law. No. Knowingly laundering money is illegal, being used to launder money unknowingly is not. For example if a money launderer buys your property with cash (car, house, painting) and then goes ahead and resells that property later to clean money, by your logic the seller would also be laundering, which is obviously absurd. With this law the seller has the responsibility not to accept cash over a certain amount, which makes the launderer's life more difficult. Most people who take part in money laundering do so unknowingly. The law provides a better paper trail to detect laundering. > A law that makes it easier to indict criminals at the expense of making legitimate acts illegal is fundamentally at odds with the physical underpinnings that give us the "innocent until proven guilty" doctrine. That's circular logic. You claim something is a "legitimate act" but all illegal things were at one time legitimate acts: drinking & driving, guns on aircraft, drug usage, all computing crime, all financial crime, etc. You can use that exact sentence and the logic held within to argue that all new laws of any nature violate "innocent until proven guilty" because inherently before the law was passed these were "legitimate acts."
- 27182818284 11y agoI can't speak about the transaction aspect, but the banning of the €500 note is an old idea. Most regular folks do not use that note period. So much so that occasionally you hear the nickname "binladens" for the €500 note.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoIs it the kind of note that if you used it in a shop, they'd think it was counterfeit?
- 27182818284 11y agoGiven its nickname, I think they wouldn't guess it counterfeit as much as dirty like money from drugs, etc
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoOh, yeah, it could also be counterfeit. I shouldn't have edited that out of my comment.
- natosaichek 11y agoIt just gives police another reason to arrest / detail people who they suspect of wrongdoing - you got more than 5k in cash? You better be able to account for the multiple transactions you're going to be performing.
- xanderstrike 11y agoFTFA: > Germany has been one of the Mafia’s favorite places to invest its money Banning large transactions in cash obviously isn't going to stop the guy buying 100k in drugs and guns, but it will make it extremely difficult for the seller to legitimize that 100k.