4 ms·
Venezula is a really interesting example in my mind. Here is a country which has all of the fundamental things it needs to be a vibrant, robust, and generally g
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Venezula is a really interesting example in my mind. Here is a country which has all of the fundamental things it needs to be a vibrant, robust, and generally great country and yet it isn't one.
It has natural resources which are in demand, and for which the tools and techniques to convert them into exchangable goods is well understood. It has few serious military threats from its neighbors and so militarily its primarily responsible for civil and criminal activities, and it has nominally "easy" access to nearby markets for trade goods (importing things it doesn't have domestically).
But it also has people in "charge" to have no idea how running a country even works much less the forces that act on it. And as many anti-libertarians will point out, the lack of a competent government does not result in a paradise emerging from the work of motivated individual actors within.
And understanding that, go back to the founding of the US and its fits and starts trying to go from being a colony to being a country, and most importantly the constraints on their own actions that everyone had to agree to in order to get the Constitution done. Try to understand why that worked is an interesting (and perhaps vital) exercise. Was it the people? Their values? Their education? Their understanding? Was it coincidence or luck?
I find myself desperate to know why one institution works and another fails. Both large like nation-states, and small like companies. How is it "no big deal" for some companies to get a new CEO and catastrophic for others?
- solipsism 11y agoHow is it "no big deal" for some companies to get a new CEO and catastrophic for others? It probably doesn't satisfy, but isn't one answer to this question: "Because there are countless convoluted variables"? This would depend on the outgoing CEO, the incoming CEO, every key employee, the state of the company, the company's sector, the state of the economy, etc. I guess you're looking for consistent rules of thumb, but is it possible that there are too many factors for their to be any good rules of thumb?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoHaving joined IBM which has a process for everything (including evolving management, and making changes at the top) which was very very different than Sun which was evolution by attrition (for example once Ed Zander figured out that Scott McNealy wasn't going to give him a shot at being CEO he went to Motorola) which was different than NetApp where some positional changes (CEO) seemed managed while others (CTO and VP Eng) did not. And then there are processes like military command or the US Constitution which have their own components. For example you can't run for the office "Speaker of the house" in the US Congress you have to be voted into it by a set of peers who are all nominally eligible for the job. Similarly with Pope, anyone in the College of Cardinals can be elected as I understand it. Not so much for Dali Lama though. Organizations are only as strong as the people who make them up, but creating tools to manage that set of people for the greater good of the organization, that is an interesting question. How do you quell damaging voices while amplifying the voice of people making forward progress? Countries are the same way, monarchies can fail suddenly with the coronation of a bad monarch, but democracies tend to survive such games. Rome had been around for centuries but as more and more power congealed into a single individual it became more and more unstable. It is like you have to walk into a room where anyone else can get you removed, and still get stuff done.
- solipsism 11y agoHow to design robust organizations at scale. And how to quantify the stability and robustness of a given organization. I agree, it's an interesting topic. At the nation-state scale, it could be that we don't have enough data points. And to take the question to its extreme, it's hard to answer what kind of life-forms/civilizations might be likely to become space faring (or even intelligent) with N=1.
- qrendel 11y ago> And as many anti-libertarians will point out, the lack of a competent government does not result in a paradise emerging from the work of motivated individual actors within. There's a big difference between an incompetent government and a libertarian free-market paradise. The two aren't even comparable. A corrupt government bureaucracy with central economic planning based on nepotism and cronyism (presumably, Venezuela) is pretty much the polar opposite of what any sane libertarian or anarcho-capitalist would be advocating for.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI agree they would not advocate it but I'm wondering how they would prevent it. It is easy for people who don't understand the consequences of their actions to over power those who do, because they are willing to take action that favors short term gain over long term survival. So your 'sane libertarian' or 'anarcho-capitalist' who was not also willing to destroy the economy to further consolidate their influence, would be swept aside by thugs who were willing to do that.
- Theodores 11y ago> It has few serious military threats from its neighbors The U.S. military is 'full spectrum dominance', including coup attempts, as in the 2002 coup attempt. Team Bush has not been gone long in the bigger scheme of things, and Team Bush 2 (Obama) seems to have sanctions on Venezuela. Sanctions is tantamount to a blockade or a siege, seen by some as an act of war even if no guns get fired. Venezuela's problem is that it wants to be a proper country rather than some Goldman Sachs managed vassal state.