3 ms·
In the full knowledge that this opinion will be unpopular: the crime here is not selling coverage. The crime here is selling coverage obviously while being an
by patio11 17y ago
In the full knowledge that this opinion will be unpopular: the crime here is not selling coverage. The crime here is selling coverage obviously while being an intern. The media, including Techcrunch, sells coverage as a matter of routine.
Sure, we'd be happy to cover your new gadget, but we'll need an exclusive on that. The exclusive will be worth, at the margin, 50,000 uniques we won't lose to Endgadget (and the attendant link equity we'll get for being first, and possibly mainstream media attention). The CPM for this blog is $10. But $500 in an envelope on the table, that is totally different. That makes us feel like we're selling coverage.
- staunch 17y ago1) How much is "exclusivity" worth? Could you sell the story of your product launch to anyone? 2) Are you really providing much of anything to TC with your exclusive in terms of traffic? They drive traffic to you, not the other way around.
- patio11 17y agoExclusivity is apparently worth an embargo. http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/09/23/the-last-has-fallen-the-embargo-is-dead/ http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/09/23/the-last-has-fallen-the... As the old saying goes, after that we're just dickering about the price.
- staunch 17y agoYou're claiming it's worth in the neighborhood of $500. If it's actually only worth $5 that's a big difference. No reasonable person believes TC can be bought for $5. My guess is that exclusivity is more of an ego thing than anything else. Competitive people like to win, and in journalism that means scooping the competition. TC might make just as much money, with or without an exclusive (give or take a few dollars). If true, all you're doing by giving an exclusive is feeding their ego. That's hardly the same as handing over a $2k laptop.
- jacquesm 17y agoOver time the cumulative effect is worth well in excess of $500. TC lives by the 'scoop', remember the time when they posted twitters internal documents only because they said they were afraid someone else might beat them to it ? Ethics and TechCrunch have very little to do with each other.
- drusenko 17y agoexclusivity is definitely also a readership thing. the blog that breaks the news picks up more daily readers, which in turn makes them a bigger blog.
- staunch 17y agoI'm sure that's the case on things like an iPad launch, but when it comes to MyLittleStartup.com I think it's more about ego/reputation than money. Arrington knows he's #1 and he doesn't want to eat Pete Cashmore's leftovers -- he wants Cashmore to eat his.
- jeff18 17y agoDoes TechCrunch really do this?
- pg 17y agoThe difference is that an exclusive actually does have more news value. By definition, it's news.
- patio11 17y agoIf Bob Smith creates a tablet computer which runs Flash and cures cancer tomorrow, that has some news value N1 and some pageview value P1. If a particular media outlet gets an exclusive on that announcement, then it has news value N2 and pageview value P2. delta(N1, N2) is zero -- it is still news tomorrow no matter how many people report it. (See: iPad, which was apparently a story of staggering importance despite having everybody and their dog say the same things about it.) delta(P1, P2) is nonzero. Hilariously nonzero. If Steve Jobs had a fit of stupid and had given somebody the exclusive for the iPad, that would probably have been worth hundreds of millions of page views. Page views are, of course, exchangable for money. We build entire industries on that fact. News media outlets are willing to trade things of value for exclusives. For example, PR flacks value embargoes. TechCrunch will give you one if, and only if, you give them an exclusive, despite their professed hatred for them in all other contexts. That should imply to you that TechCrunch is getting something from the exclusive -- and it isn't delta(N).
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pg 17y agoThe difference between being paid to cover something and covering something in return for an exclusive is that in the latter case your readers benefit as well. Even if your only criterion in deciding what to print was how newsworthy it was, you'd still be more likely to print a story if you'd been given an exclusive.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- chairface 17y agoHow does a reader benefit from news that is available from fewer sources? Also, if you're more likely to print a story when given an exclusive, then newsworthiness is not your only criterion in deciding what to print.
- rythie 17y agoPlus not telling the TechCrunch management and giving the gift to them, plus disclosing it in the post.
- evansolomon 17y agoClaiming an embargo is the same or even similar to cash-for-coverage is silly and immature. Is providing a press kit the same as paying for coverage? It makes the coverage cheaper for the reporter to provide, which has a monetary result. Hating TechCrunch is certainly a popular opinion at times, and there are some reasonable stances to base that opinion on, but this is not one.
- suhail 17y agoIt's more to do with the fact that the intern is selling coverage for his own personal gain--Techcrunch the entity gets nothing. I see nothing wrong with exclusives. This happens regularly in business not just in news. For Techcrunch, it's simply an optimization and they are likely to not sell their news space for otherwise non-newsworthy items anyway.