28 ms·
Bingo. A lot of the 'leftist' things enacted were not things that have been successful elsewhere. Look at Norway for instance - they've stashed a lot of their
by davidw 11y ago
Bingo. A lot of the 'leftist' things enacted were not things that have been successful elsewhere.
Look at Norway for instance - they've stashed a lot of their oil money in a fund for the future, rather than piss it away.
Venezuela was a terribly run place, whatever sort of economic theories the leadership espoused. Lots of stuff went on that would not have been acceptable in a country with a stronger democracy and a high regard for the rule of law.
- s_q_b 11y agoI wrote a paper on the resource curse once, examining Norway as the example of how to escape it. The funny thing is that Norway's system was designed by an Iraqi immigrant engineer.
- sremani 11y agoNorway and Singapore are excellent examples until you realize both their population is about 5 million.
- davidw 11y agoCountries can be small and poorly run kleptocracies too.
- dragonwriter 11y agoIf population ratios are the standard to go by, they are better examples (by that standard) of what outcomes Venezuela could expect than Venezuela is for the US, so offering them as counterexamples in a thread where Venezuela is being held out as a cautionary tale for the US is not inappropriate.
- csomar 11y agoQatar and UAE are a good example too (overall) at managing resources. Libya is not. All of them have small populations. And they belong to the same Arabic world. It's about management not money or resources.
- sremani 11y agoCheap labor from South and South East Asia have a lot more to do with Qatar and UAE. Also lot of India-Pakistan trade (because of hostilities) happens via. UAE and Qatar(to a lesser extent). So, there are elements, like demographics, stability and geographical and geo-political issues casting bigger shadow than we think. Dubai is 70% non-citizens, and majority from India.
- m0skit0 11y agoCan you provide examples on why Venezuela is a "weak" democracy or has poor rule of law, and specially compared to which other countries for example? Thanks.
- davidw 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supreme_Tribunal_of_Justice_(Venezuela)#Criticisms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supreme_Tribunal_of_Justice_(V... Look at how Chavez took over the oil company, and generally treated businesses. Sweden, for instance, may have high taxation, but it is applied fairly, and businesses are not considered 'the enemy'. Property rights exist and are taken seriously. I'm actually a somewhat left-leaning person, but never found Venezuela to be a very compelling example, to be honest.
- Shorel 11y agoThe elections are rigged. They are also rigged in my country, but it is a bit more obvious there.
- crdoconnor 11y agoIt wasn't any particularly leftist policies that killed them, it was just trying to artificially boost the value of their currency. That policy has been tried across he political spectrum and it's pretty much always ended in tears. >Look at Norway for instance Norway wasn't suffering from a massive level of poverty. When Chavez took over, Venezuela was and he cut it significantly. That's what he "pissed" the money away on.
- davidw 11y agoThey have some terrible policies, like massive gasoline subsidies. http://reason.com/blog/2015/01/20/venezuelan-fuel-subsidies-mean-cheap-gas http://reason.com/blog/2015/01/20/venezuelan-fuel-subsidies-... (first link I found, but you can find other less ideological sources as well. I'm not in the reason.com camp, myself). I'm sure they've done a few good things too, but I think the bad has mostly outweighed the good.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>They have some terrible policies, like massive gasoline subsidies. Cheap gasoline is the least of their problems. That is one thing they do have enough of to go around. >I'm sure they've done a few good things too, but I think the bad has mostly outweighed the good. Yeah like cutting the poverty rate in half. Something that apparently stops being laudable once the middle classes have to queue for toilet paper.
- tptacek 11y agoEverybody has to queue for toilet paper! The economy has ground to a halt! Unless you use the (entirely unregulated, utterly laissez-faire) black market, nobody can buy anything. Not toilet paper, not food.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoI'm on your side of this one, but I think crdoconnor has a bit of a point. I saw somewhere (the original article or a comment, I forget which) that people are limited to buying one chicken a week. That's not good... unless you couldn't buy any before, in which case it's a massive step up. Would getting that much protein in your diet (that you never could get before) be worth being unable to get toilet paper (that you also probably couldn't afford before)? But I'm on your side of this one, because it turned out that chauvismo didn't deliver enough gain to enough people. It promised utopia, but delivered much less, even to the poor, at the price of destroying the economy. But don't minimize the value of what it delivered to the poorest of the poor.