4 ms·
I definitely agree that this law violates the First Amendment and therefore suspect if a case came to the SCOTUS they would rule against it (assuming it even ne
by Someone1234 11y ago
I definitely agree that this law violates the First Amendment and therefore suspect if a case came to the SCOTUS they would rule against it (assuming it even needed to get that high).
But my question is this: From my understanding, the First Amendment establishes limits on what government can and cannot do, it doesn't establish what a private entity can and cannot do. In this case the law allows a private business to sue a private individual, and while the law itself is established by government, the use of that law is not.
So maybe someone with more legal expertise than myself can answer: Is it possible to bring this issue before SCOTUS if it is only used by non-government? Have they effectively found a loophole by keeping government out of the actual lawsuits? Can you sue a law itself (would you have standing)?
- matthewmcg 11y agoThe First Amendment is still implicated even in private disputes when one party requests that a court take some action that restricts the speech of the other party. The court can't take the requested action (e.g. an injunction stopping publication) if it violates the first amendment. This is a bit of a simplification but the name in legal circles for the concept you are talking about is the "state action" requirement.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cmurf 11y agoIt's the worst example of government where businesses have more of a voice than people, and use their political influence to compel the government to basically act like a gang or the mafia to shut up dissenters. It's really a tiny handful of jerks who say, "yes, it's a good thing that we bash little baby pigs heads in, by grabbing them by the hind legs, and throwing them head first into the ground, when we determine they are non-viable. But we desperately don't want the public to know that's how we get rid of non-viable pigs, because we know the public actually has something of a moral conscience, unlike us, and would stop eating our pigs if they knew this is how it worked. And that's just the beginning." So the question is whether it's the private business that's abridging speech, or if it's the government. If this an extension of defamation law, then it's the former. If it's asking the government to do their own dirty work, then it's the latter. And I think it's the latter.
- delazeur 11y agoHere's a recent example case: A judge recently dismissed a defamation suit against Bill Cosby on the grounds that he has a First Amendment right to deny accusations against him. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/arts-and-entertainment/wp/2016/01/22/a-win-for-bill-cosby-judge-tosses-out-defamation-suit/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/arts-and-entertainment/w...
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoA lawsuit is meaningless unless the government enforces the end result.
- Gibbon1 11y agoI'm not a lawyer but can point to 1960's court rulings invalidating real estate covenants that banned homeowners from selling to Blacks, Jews, and Mexicans. The supreme court invalidated the convents by flatly refusing to enforce them. In short the court said 'not your personal army.' Meaning the courts weren't going to accept lawsuits attempting to enforce racially based covenants. tl;dr: Courts don't actually overturn laws or contracts instead they refuse to enforce them.
- ubernostrum 11y agoThe racial-covenant case (Shelley v. Kraemer) is actually interesting for the departure from normal constitutional questions -- typically a court either upholds the constitutionality of a statute, or rules the statute unconstitutional and thus unenforceable. In Shelley, effectively the court ruled that racial covenants, which were private contracts, were perfectly legal, perfectly constitutional and perfectly valid, but that the state government (which would normally enforce this type of contract) could not enforce racial covenants because doing so would require actions outside the powers of the state government. Which comes back to whether either a state government or the federal government could enforce certain types of gag-order provisions in contracts, since the required action might similarly be outside the powers of the government.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> But my question is this: From my understanding, the First Amendment establishes limits on what government can and cannot do, it doesn't establish what a private entity can and cannot do. In this case the law allows a private business to sue a private individual, and while the law itself is established by government, the use of that law is not. The first amendment prohibits government (Congress, actually, but the 14th Amendment's due process clause has been read to apply, among other things, a virtually identical restriction to the states under the doctrine of incorporation) from making any law abridging the freedom of speech. Whether such a freedom-abridging law creates a cause of private action or public action is immaterial, it is the creation of the law itself that is prohibited. (That said, most ag-gag laws involve both criminal penalties and private causes of action, and so do not actually meet the description of the government role being merely the creation of a law under which private parties act.) >So maybe someone with more legal expertise than myself can answer: Is it possible to bring this issue before SCOTUS if it is only used by non-government? Have they effectively found a loophole by keeping government out of the actual lawsuits? Can you sue a law itself (would you have standing)? You don't sue the law, you raise the unconstitutionality of the law as a defense against any attempt by any party (public or private) to use the law, e.g., by suing you or filing criminal charges against you.