4 ms·
I imagine these laws eventually will be overturned by the Supreme Court as contrary to the First Amendment. It involves punishment of core political speech, so
by otterley 11y ago
I imagine these laws eventually will be overturned by the Supreme Court as contrary to the First Amendment. It involves punishment of core political speech, so it should be a relatively open-and-shut case.
The strongest argument in favor of the Constitutionality of these laws is that they are outlawing speech that could not have been made but for the violation of another law (i.e. common trespass and/or contract breach), but I'd be very surprised if the laws survived on those grounds. Newsgathering is often performed by trespassing, even newsgathering that's been previously upheld by the Court (e.g. Pentagon Papers, in which the author had unlawful access to classified materials).
- rileymat2 11y ago>violation of another law (i.e. common trespass and/or contract breach) I thought breaching a contract was not a violation of the law. There will be civil consequences of course.
- tamana 11y agoCivil law is law.
- pc86 11y agoBreaching a contract does not make you a criminal.
- dragonwriter 11y agoThat doesn't mean it is not a violation of law, it means that it is not a crime. Crimes are subset of violations of law (specifically, they are violations of criminal law.) Violations of contract law, or tort law, etc., are still violations of law, but not crimes. "X doesn't make you a criminal" is not equivalent to, nor does it imply, "X is not a violation of law."
- cyphar 11y agoIt is technically correct to say "breach of contract is not a crime". But it isn't correct to say that "breach of contract is not illegal".
- vinceguidry 11y agoYes, but a contract isn't.
- dragonwriter 11y agoBut contract law, which sets the rules for what is a contract, the conditions under which one is required to adhere to them (and the conditions in which one is not), and established remedies for when one does not adhere to them when legally required to do, is (as the name suggests) law.
- cyphar 11y agoContracts are part of contract law, which the name suggests is a law. Of course contracts are legally binding documents, and a breach of contract is a violation of contract law (which is a civil, not criminal, offense).
- otterley 11y agoWhether a law was violated is a different question than what the remedies or penalties are from its violation. You have to establish the first before the second can even be contemplated by the court.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I thought breaching a contract was not a violation of the law. Breaching a contract is a violation of law (specifically, the subset known as contract law.) > There will be civil consequences of course. "Civil consequences" require a violation of the law. Obviously, they don't require a violation of criminal law, but criminal law isn't the whole of the law.
- Someone1234 11y agoI definitely agree that this law violates the First Amendment and therefore suspect if a case came to the SCOTUS they would rule against it (assuming it even needed to get that high). But my question is this: From my understanding, the First Amendment establishes limits on what government can and cannot do, it doesn't establish what a private entity can and cannot do. In this case the law allows a private business to sue a private individual, and while the law itself is established by government, the use of that law is not. So maybe someone with more legal expertise than myself can answer: Is it possible to bring this issue before SCOTUS if it is only used by non-government? Have they effectively found a loophole by keeping government out of the actual lawsuits? Can you sue a law itself (would you have standing)?
- matthewmcg 11y agoThe First Amendment is still implicated even in private disputes when one party requests that a court take some action that restricts the speech of the other party. The court can't take the requested action (e.g. an injunction stopping publication) if it violates the first amendment. This is a bit of a simplification but the name in legal circles for the concept you are talking about is the "state action" requirement.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cmurf 11y agoIt's the worst example of government where businesses have more of a voice than people, and use their political influence to compel the government to basically act like a gang or the mafia to shut up dissenters. It's really a tiny handful of jerks who say, "yes, it's a good thing that we bash little baby pigs heads in, by grabbing them by the hind legs, and throwing them head first into the ground, when we determine they are non-viable. But we desperately don't want the public to know that's how we get rid of non-viable pigs, because we know the public actually has something of a moral conscience, unlike us, and would stop eating our pigs if they knew this is how it worked. And that's just the beginning." So the question is whether it's the private business that's abridging speech, or if it's the government. If this an extension of defamation law, then it's the former. If it's asking the government to do their own dirty work, then it's the latter. And I think it's the latter.
- WildUtah 11y agoThe Supreme Court is no fan of the First Amendment. Notice that Citizens United was a 5-4 decision in the clearest core political speech case since the First World War[0]. And at least two of the Citizens United justices will probably be replaced by the next president and no likely presidential candidate is a big fan of the First Amendment. [0] When villain Oliver Wendell Holmes wrote a majority opinion that arguing in public that military conscription was bad policy should be a criminal offense and the First Amendment didn't apply. There's no reason the Supremes can't just abolish the First Amendment for political convenience again.
- solipsism 11y agoclearest core political speech case It might be a clear case to you, but there's a huge amount of controversy among legal scholars regarding Citizens United. Pretending this controversy doesn't exist and that the decision should be clear-cut doesn't help your point.
- mmanfrin 11y agoNotice that Citizens United was a 5-4 decision in the clearest core political speech case since the First World War I'm sorry, what?
- jsprogrammer 11y agoDo you know of another?
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoAll the obscenity cases they ruled on. Each and every ruling had reasoning and precedent that would be directly impactful to any political ruling.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>The strongest argument in favor of the Constitutionality of these laws is that they are outlawing speech that could not have been made but for the violation of another law What is the precedent of this argument? I'm guessing it can be found in the justification behind certain laws which make certain speech illegal.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I imagine these laws eventually will be overturned by the Supreme Court as contrary to the First Amendment. Probably, and a case that may do that is already in the system; Idaho's ag-gag law has already been struck down by a Federal District Court, and a notice of appeal has been filed by the state with the Ninth Circuit. [0] [0] http://www.foodsafetynews.com/2015/12/idaho-appeals-federal-court-decision-overturning-statess-ag-gag-law/#.VrKGcVIUUeE http://www.foodsafetynews.com/2015/12/idaho-appeals-federal-...