13 ms·
What We’ll Do in Space by 2116
- adwn 11y ago> With lower budgets and less aversion to risk, private companies are also more likely than public agencies to suffer disasters in space. I disagree very much. Throwing bureaucracy and money at problems does not decrease risk. NASA has killed several astronauts: Challenger (bad internal processes and "go-fever"), Columbia (bad technical concept and design), and Apollo 1. Then there are those near-misses with Apollo 13 and Gemini 8 [1], which could have easily resulted in the loss of the crew. Money and bureaucracy also don't protect from stupid mistakes, as seen in the Mars Climate Orbiter case (output data in wrong units) [2]. Private companies also have a strong incentive to minimize risk to human life, due to all the bad PR and losses in revenue that brings. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gemini_8#Emergency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gemini_8#Emergency [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Climate_Orbiter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Climate_Orbiter
- ekianjo 11y agoAnd we have another good example of private companies in commercial airspace avoiding crashes as much as possible. By all means, risk is not zero, but look how far we have come in 60 years.
- amalcon 11y agoA big part of that is attributable to the FAA and corresponding bodies in other countries -- though not all, by any means.
- hga 11y agoBut that's simply a part of how we tend to this sort of thing, private actors with a public watchdog. I'm under the very strong impression that works better than a public actor with a public watchdog, we've seen too many examples of common mode failure (politics), the most recent notorious one being Flint's water system. (And as noted by others, private actors have marketplace feedback.)
- JshWright 11y agoRisk aversion and actual reductions in risk are not necessarily related.
- hga 11y agoBureaucracies also change, and seldom for the better absent extreme pressures like fighting a war. If the same NASA with the "Can't Do" attitude demonstrated between the Columbia's launch and death were running the Apollo program, they would have also killed the Apollo 13 crew.
- jellicle 11y agoEverything in your comment is belied by the evidence. Yes, NASA's attention to detail certainly does reduce the risk involved, and there have been numerous HN articles about its software processes, such as: https://gigaom.com/2012/08/20/nasa-scrubbed-mars-rover-code-clean-over-and-over/ https://gigaom.com/2012/08/20/nasa-scrubbed-mars-rover-code-... http://www.verticalsysadmin.com/making_robust_software/ http://www.verticalsysadmin.com/making_robust_software/ > Private companies also have a strong incentive to minimize risk to human life There's no evidence of that whatsoever. OSHA, for example, has vastly reduced workplace fatalities and injuries. https://www.osha.gov/dep/fatcat/dep_fatcat.html https://www.osha.gov/dep/fatcat/dep_fatcat.html
- adwn 11y ago> NASA's attention to detail certainly does reduce the risk involved Bureaucracy and several layers of subcontractors is not the same as "attention to detail". You can easily have the latter while avoiding the former; I'd even argue that bureaucracy is dangerous in this context, since it maximizes ass-covering and minimizes personal responsibility. Personal responsibility is still the best way to ensure attention to detail. > There's no evidence of that whatsoever. OSHA, for example, has vastly reduced workplace fatalities and injuries. My statement was in the context of human space flight. When an astronaut dies during a mission, that will have a massive impact on the company's reputation, unlike some construction site accident. OSHA does not apply to space flight missions. Compare commercial airplanes: Whenever a plane crashes, you'll be sure to hear about it and which airline it belonged to.
- lukeschlather 11y ago> Compare commercial airplanes: Whenever a plane crashes, you'll be sure to hear about it and which airline it belonged to. Plane crashes are rare events thanks to the massive bureaucracy known as the FAA.
- singham 11y agoWe couldn't even detect a planet larger than neptune inspite of having hubble telescope. I am vary of such articles which just collect positive instances and blow the trumpet.
- pilom 11y agoNASA has sent over 600 people into space not to mention orbit or the moon and killed around 17 along the way. Private companies have sent about 10 people into space and killed 2(?). Given the choice, I'd rather go to space with NASA.
- nsxwolf 11y agoThat's just not enough data for either side. And the 2 you refer to were test pilots flying an experimental aircraft -- a dangerous profession in the non-space aviation world as well. 17 out of ~600 isn't really something to brag about.
- sandworm101 11y agoPrivate and public enterprises don't use the same definition of risk. For a public body, risk is measured in political capital. how their failures and successes may influence how they are treated by governments. A private enterprise measures risk according to the likelihood of turning a profit on a venture. While there is certainly an overlap, such as SpaceX having PR/lobbiests or NASA launching commercial sats, they are two fundamentally different approaches to risk. A dangerous situations occur when either uses the wrong model. When governments try to turn profits, they may cut something that the perhaps shouldn't (Flint). And when private enterprise spends like a government, ignores the bottom line, they are ripped apart by irate shareholders. It's apples and oranges.
- cmurf 11y agoWell arguably in every NASA case, there were private contractors proposing astronomical (pun intended) chances of catastrophic errors, whereas internal NASA estimates were always expecting far, far greater chance of such error. So there was always this go, go, go mentality. So you can ding NASA for bad choices, which is fair, but there's a private business component in all of that too. It's a public-private venture, space.
- yyyuuu 11y agohow far is our current tech from cryo sleep? Most science fiction assumes that humans will survive long duration space travel through chemical induced sleep, waking up only when they are about to reach the destination. Is it just science fiction or do we have someone working aggressively on this.
- adrianN 11y agoIt's pretty far out. Currently we can't even freeze and thaw organs. As that would be quite useful for transplantation, there are people working on it. Depending on how you define "aggressive", this might not be aggressive though.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThere's the field of cryonics, aimed at preserving people who can't be helped by contemporary medicine, in hopes that the future technology will be able to save their lives. While the goal is slightly different, it seems to be pretty much the same research that's needed for space travel cryopreservation.
- amalcon 11y agoThere's at least one very big difference: the equipment for reactivating the frozen tissue, which modern cryonics does not even attempt to create, needs to be put on the spaceship at launch. Otherwise, even if perfectly preserved tissue arrives at its destination in a few centuries, it will just remain in that state until power runs down or something breaks.
- zimpenfish 11y ago6 months seems to be the outer extremes of medically induced comas (http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-is-a-medically-induced-coma/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-is-a-medicall...) and that's nowhere near long enough to get anywhere useful. Although I guess you could wake people up every 3 months for some muscle replenishment exercise and mission updates.
- 11y ago
- fit2rule 11y agoHere's what I wish we'd do in space in the next 100 years: - Make industrial-scale self-reproducing robots, and send them to an asteroid. - Build more robots out of that asteroid, send robots to next nearest asteroid. - Build a ringworld out of asteroid and robot parts. The great thing about space being so enormously big, is that .. once you get off Earth .. you've got so much of it to play with. Send some of these robots to the rings of Saturn, get as much water together as possible, take your fish-tank and get on with it .. We have the technology to do this. We truly do. We just don't have the will.
- mino 11y agoAre you referring to Von Neumann probes? Also see Carl Sagan's response [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-replicating_spacecraft#Von_Neumann_probes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-replicating_spacecraft#Vo...
- nxzero 11y agoPlease provide an explanation of what form "self-reproducing robots" would take based on the "tech we've got" in a way that applies to the context you've provided.
- fit2rule 11y agoPut 250 million bucks into this idea: http://www.markuskayser.com/work/solarsinter/ http://www.markuskayser.com/work/solarsinter/ Locate richest mineral resource in near-Earth neighborhood. Apply rockets. Build new rockets. I know, it is 'just a fantasy', but .. y'know .. it was once 'just a fantasy' that we'd all have Internet terminals glued to our heads, and look how fast we got that one, once the will-power was there ..
- kabdib 11y ago> We have the technology to do this We're not even close to being able to make self-reproducing robots. Even a simple robot requires a huge supply chain. Take, say, the photoresists used in chip manufacture -- that's an entire chemical industry that you need to box up. That little industry has a bunch of needs on its own. Okay, box those up, too. Repeat. Now let's do insulation for wires . . . or batteries. It takes a lot more than a village to make a robot, it pretty much takes a country. Probably several, given how suitable raw materials are so inconveniently spread around (and often, hard to find, so I guess we need to add some kind of prospecting facility now). Short of general-purpose nano-assemblers, which are likely to remain science fiction for quite some time, you'll not put a self-reproducing robot into a probe-sized package any time soon.
- aerique 11y ago> In a mere 60 years, we of Earth have gone from launching our first spacecraft, to exploring every planet and major moon in our solar system, to establishing an international, long-lived fleet of robotic spacecraft at the Moon and Mars. Put like that it's pretty impressive. A lot of people, including me, tend to focus on humans in space and on other planetary bodies so think look a bit grim from that perspective. We're doing pretty well exploring our solar system. I wonder how the jump to other solar systems is going to be once we're 'done' here.
- Already__Taken 11y agoFor the foreseeable future that's is going to look like a permanently sustainable space colony that just happens to be travelling towards another system. Given the timescales involved.
- hga 11y agoThe Generation Ship: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_ship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_ship
- ansible 11y agoThe issue is that it takes a ridiculous amount of energy to transport even 1kg of matter from one solar system to another in a reasonable amount of time. We're more likely to upload our minds and run them on a small and energy efficient computing substrate. After seeding a new solar system with appropriate infrastructure, we can then just transmit ourselves from place to place.
- IndianAstronaut 11y ago>We're doing pretty well exploring our solar system. I wonder how the jump to other solar systems is going to be once we're 'done' here. We can reallydo a lot more in our current exploration. Ideally we would have a permanent human presence on the moon and Mars if budgets kept up. Also a good exploration of Europa, Titan and other moons. As of now we do not have the ability to travel to another solar system in a human lifetime and the technology to do so doesn't even seem possible. No hints at near light speed travel, let alone faster than light.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nxzero 11y agoUsing species known to survive outside Earth’s atmosphere like the Tardigrades, especially given their size, for space based efforts might be worth considering.
- samstave 11y agoUsing them to do what exactly?
- nxzero 11y agoOff the cuff, using water bears as biobots and space-seeds might be of use, but just doing any research relate to using them in space to me is worth looking into; NASA has already done some research. Generally speaking, right now their our best bet to transfer life out of the solar system.
- dsr_ 11y agoPrivate companies have a long record of killing their employees and causing huge amounts of environmental damage, as long as they think it will be profitable and that they won't suffer awful repercussions. http://www.msha.gov/stats/centurystats/mnmstats.asp http://www.msha.gov/stats/centurystats/mnmstats.asp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_Labor_Wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_Labor_Wars "all the bad PR and losses in revenue that brings" is insufficient.
- logicchains 11y agoThe first link doesn't provide separate numbers for comparing public and private mines, so doesn't really prove anything; mining could just be inherently dangerous. The second link doesn't mention any instances of private employers killing their employees.
- beobab 11y agoI humbly suggest that sitting atop large quantities of explosive and riding the blast wave up into space is inherently dangerous, too.
- philh 11y agoThe question adwn was talking about is not how many people will die? but will private companies kill more people than public companies? logicchains is suggesting that "private mining companies kill lots of people" says more about dangerous versus safe industries, than it does about private versus public companies.
- dsr_ 11y agoAs to your first point: the USA does not have government-owned mines. Some public lands are leased for mining by private corporations. As to your second point: apparently you neither read the fine Wikipedia article nor followed up on any of the references provided. Here, read just the two first paragraphs of this article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludlow_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludlow_Massacre and you may become satisfied that, without restraint, some private employers will kill their employees.
- mihaifm 11y agoThere's no mention of exploring Europa or Enceladus. I think sending probes there will have far more important consequences than sending orbiters to Uranus.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- godber 11y agoPerhaps Emily was thinking more about things in the distant future. There is already a Europa mission under development: http://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-s-europa-mission-begins-with-selection-of-science-instruments http://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-s-europa-mission-begi... We should be there within the next 10 to 15 years.
- gregwtmtno 11y agoWhen she says "In the 2020s, we’ll launch our next robotic missions to Jupiter; they’ll arrive and do science in the 2030s, and will hopefully persist for a decade or so.", she's referring to the upcoming Europa mission.
- gtirloni 11y agoI'm a complete newbie about space travel so when the article says it takes decades to reach planets like Mercury, I went searching for the fastest way we can/could travel today. From the Wikipedia article about the Solar Probe+, it seems the spacecraft should achieve 200km/s as it passes by the Sun. At that speed, a trip to Mercury (57.91 million km) would take 80 hours? Could someone with more knowledge about space travel weight in on the difficulties of achieving this and/or any glaring mistakes I have made in my assumptions and calculations? To clarify, I'm interested in how fast we should ship super advanced robots to these planets. So things like human survival while it passes by the Sun aren't important in this case (I think? Is melting a huge problem for shipping robots that way?).
- airza 11y agoThe speed as it is passing by the sun is the highest that it will reach in its route (the closest part of its elliptical orbit around the sun) You couldn't change that momentum to be going in the right direction (Towards mercury's gravitational influence, which is small compared to the sun) or slow it down enough to orbit mercury after it gets there without expending a crazy amount of fuel. So you could do it for a flyby, but trying to land something on the surface wouldn't work. The other problem is since 200km/s is the fastest speed, you have to get to that point at the normal one.
- S4M 11y agoYes, the moment Earth and Mercury are the closest is when the Sun, Mercury and Earth are aligned, so going from Earth to Mercury at this moment is heading towards the Sun, but then gravity from the Sun will be too strong to be able to stop at Mercury.
- ceejayoz 11y ago> From the Wikipedia article about the Solar Probe+, it seems the spacecraft should achieve 200km/s as it passes by the Sun. At that speed, a trip to Mercury (57.91 million km) would take 80 hours? If you read the Wikipedia article more closely (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_Probe_Plus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_Probe_Plus) you'll note that it takes seven flybys of Venus over the course of six years to get into that orbit, and the resulting orbit has an 88 day period. Plus, if you want to do anything more than whiz past Mercury, you need to bleed off that 200km/s speed to orbital velocity, which takes an enormous amount of fuel.
- ifdefdebug 11y ago> Still, we could see humans on Mars in 20 years, give or take. After a whole paragraph describing how difficult it is, this seems rather optimistic. Give or Take? Give another 100, I'd guess.
- kjs3 11y agoCompletely agree. We probably need more than 20 years to build and test the infrastructure and logistics to send someone to Mars (little things like the actual vehicle to get there is barely more than a pile of concept drawings). And that's assuming we don't continue our history of changing NASA priorities completely every couple of years. Maybe in 100 years.
- zardo 11y agoNASA says 20, SpaceX says 9, I'll call it 15.
- ifdefdebug 11y ago> Which means it’s likely that the first humans on Mars will not have been sent there by NASA or ESA. Yes I agree that's likely but for very different reasons from what is said in the article: "Since the retirement of the US Space Shuttle in 2011, only Russia and China have maintained human spaceflight capability with the Soyuz program and Shenzhou program."[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_spaceflight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_spaceflight
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- superkuh 11y agoThis needs more electrostatic solar sails and fission fragment rockets.
- peteretep 11y agoAll I got from this articles was an excessive desire to post childish Uranus jokes. Predictions of the future are supposed to inspire and bewilder
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoIf we're talking 100 years, my money's still on some kind of field propulsion. Here's why: Take any 100-year period of time over the last few centuries. It's not just that folks in one period of time would not understand the activities of the next period, they wouldn't even understand the concepts involved So horseback folks really didn't grok riverboat steam power at all. Same goes for railroads. Or aviation. That leads me to believe that what's up next is something we currently think impossible or silly. "Field propulsion" is a nice moniker for that, whatever in reality it turns out to be.
- simonh 11y agoIm a bit of a contrarian in this area. I know Ray Kurtzweil thinks we advanced as much in tge last 14 years as the previous 100, but thats tosh. What amazing new technologies have we developed even since the 70s? Silicon chips? Genetic enginering? Rocketry? Solar power? Nuclear power? All those are baby boomer technologies. What advances from the last 30 years even come close to those? I think the truth is we discovered most of the exploitable physics in the mid 20th century and from now on it will be mainly iterative improvement.
- liamconnell 11y agoBased on economic incentives, I would guess that the mining industry would conquer the new frontier way before any commercial space travel for humans--one way or two way. Unfortunately the mining industry today is the scummiest on earth. I honestly hope that Elon Musk and SpaceX get into space mining before say Rio Tinto, just because he deserves the billions more and would probably reinvest it for more socially good projects as well. My vision of how it could be in [N=no_fucking_clue] decades: Completely unmanned from the beginning (just like mining on earth nearly already is), with a large-scale base on the moon. It starts with mining on the moon that is processed on the moon and shipped to the earth and the infrastructure is set up so that [M] decades later it would be the hub for inerplanetary mining operations as well. Get building Mr. Musk!
- adwn 11y agoYou might be interested in Planetary Resources [1]. They're planning to mine resources from asteroids though – no gravity well (like the moon) makes for easier transport from the source to the consumer. It's very unlikely that SpaceX will be entering the space mining business. Musk doesn't seem to be a big fan of it, except in the context of mining resources on Mars for consumption on Mars. [1] http://planetaryresources.com/ http://planetaryresources.com/
- zardo 11y agoSpaceX will certainly be interested in putting someone else's mining equipment in space though. If there is an asteroid gold rush, they're selling the tickets.
- infectoid 11y agoThis is probably a better point. Established mining companies would be better off investing in research on how to extract raw materials once they are at the location. Let another company (e.g. SpaceX) deal with the transportation. The level of specialisation at every steps is huge.
- ldehaan 11y ago
- swatkat 11y agoISRO has few exciting space exploration projects lined up in the coming years: a) Chandrayaan-2[1] in 2017. Second lunar mission; this time with a soft lander and rover. b) Second Mars mission[2] in 2018. More science payloads than the first mission. May have a lander as well. c) Venus orbiter mission[3] in 2018-2020. d) Aditya L1[4] solar observatory mission in 2020. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandrayaan-2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandrayaan-2 [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mangalyaan_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mangalyaan_2 [3]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venus_orbiter_mission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venus_orbiter_mission [4]http://www.isro.gov.in/aditya-l1-first-indian-mission-to-study-sun http://www.isro.gov.in/aditya-l1-first-indian-mission-to-stu...
- davesque 11y agoTo be totally honest, it's hard to feel any enthusiasm for future space travel/exploration when it seems like a real question as to whether or not civilization will still be around in one hundred years. Climate change is such a huge problem that it dwarfs other scientific concerns. That being said, I suppose there's a chance that space exploration could drive technological innovations that could help on that front.
- arnold_palmur 11y ago> That being said, I suppose there's a chance that space exploration could drive technological innovations that could help on that front. I'd say there is more than a chance, the amount of technology that was produced during the "space-race" is incredible - I personally think that an emphasis on space exploration would continue that advancement.
- maxxxxx 11y agoI hope that there will be a major breakthrough in propulsion in the next 100 years. With current technology there are pretty hard limits to what can be done in space.
- hughes 11y agoThe biggest breakthrough might not be in technology, but in policy. Nuclear propulsion has offered high-Isp and high-thrust together in the same engine since the 60s[1], but for various reasons it hasn't flown. With the right safety precautions, public perception, legal changes, and luck, this could be the "breakthrough" you're looking for. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA
- shmerl 11y ago> it’d take 100 years to get there, give or take, unless there is some revolution in spacecraft propulsion. What about ion thrusters? They are known and it's not a revolution but rather evolution of technology that's needed to make them more useful.
- XorNot 11y agoNo it'd be a revolution. An ion thruster with comparable performance to chemical rockets would be revolutionary and is by no means a logical extension of any technology.
- shmerl 11y agoIon thrusters aren't comparable to common chemical engines and they don't need to be. They can't offer same high acceleration (to enable escaping the planet gravitation for instance). What they can offer however is very long operation and constant acceleration (even if not high). What it means that when in outer space you can accelerate the spacecraft to huge speeds over long time, which you can't do with regular fuel, simply because you quickly run out of it. It's not a revolutionary idea by any means (at least not anymore) - it is pretty well known.