5 ms·
Tumblr Has Lost Almost a Quarter of Its Value Under Yahoo’s Ownership
- Grue3 11y agoYeah, and how much value has Twitter lost since the IPO? Or Snapchat since not selling to Facebook for $6B. Surely nobody believes these valuations were reasonable in the first place.
- tptacek 11y agoThis is a misleading, bait-y title. Yahoo took a write-down on Tumblr, but that doesn't mean it "lost value" post-acquisition. A far more likely reason for the write-down is that Tumblr was overvalued at acquisition. Paying too much for something is not the same thing as reducing its value. The title leaves the impression that the way Yahoo has managed Tumblr has harmed the site. It may have, but the article presents no evidence to back that argument up.
- Marneus68 11y agoWhat did you expect from a fair, balanced and accurate source like Buzzfeed?
- tptacek 11y agoNothing, but this warrants a better title. My suggestion: "Yahoo writes down 230 million dollars on Tumblr".
- paride5745 11y agoA buzzfeed article with a bait-y link? I don't believe you!
- pavel_lishin 11y agoIsn't the price someone pays to acquire something its value? What's the difference between losing value now, and being overvalued in the past?
- prostoalex 11y ago> Yahoo took a write-down on Tumblr, but that doesn't mean it "lost value" post-acquisition Can you explain the mechanics? A write-down will be reflected on YHOO's accounting statements and will lower their tax base. If IRS allows a company to record (and carry forward) such a loss without corresponding intrinsic value loss, that seems like a pretty large loophole.
- xiaoma 11y ago> This is a misleading, bait-y title. This is buzzfeed.
- tacos 11y agoPrepping for a sale or spinoff. Yahoo's hoping that by writing Tumblr down by $230 million they can slip the new valuation past auditors.
- ikeboy 11y ago>Yahoo, which bought Tumblr in 2013, said it had reduced its valuation of the blogging service by $230 million, or about 23%. The move was basically an acknowledgment that Yahoo overpaid in the $1.1 billion deal. Either it lost value, or Yahoo overpaid. Both can't be true at the same time. Make up your mind, buzzfeed. Was Tumblr worth $1.1 billion and has now declined, or did Yahoo overpay?
- elthran 11y agoIf the "correct" valuation was halfway between the 2 valuations, then they could have overpaid at valuation, and still have declined in value. Of course, value is relative and only based on what anyone will pay for it.
- ikeboy 11y agoThe title implies the entire decrease was after the purchase. That's inconsistent with the actual article.
- p4wnc6 11y agoWhen companies lose value (or are overvalued) why don't we ever highlight it when they use Agile / Scrum? Since those techniques are expressly marketed as value- and productivity-enhancing techniques, I think it's very fair to call out attention to cases when they aren't working. Of course there are confounding factors. Maybe Agile/Scrum are working well in Tumblr but other things are keeping them from achieving their higher value. Or, maybe Agile/Scrum bleed away productivity and fail to extract value from engineers. Or maybe it's a mixture. In either case it seems useful to point it out, ask questions about it, and so on. We shouldn't let Agile-adhering failures go un-called-out, whatever the post-mortem analyses might bring.
- bluejekyll 11y agoWhat methodology do you subscribe to? Agile, when implemented and executed correctly, really just shortens delivery cycles and allow for small corrective changes along the development path. What it's best at is delivering a product that more closely aligns with needs, than something like Waterfall. In many cases the overall delivery time might be longer with agile, but the correctness of the project is better. Which means less QA at the end of the cycle, and more throughout the entire process.
- p4wnc6 11y agoI've only experienced Agile lengthening delivery cycles, but more critically Agile also greatly reduced quality, because the lack of global context and long term planning caused the products to suffer. All of the micro-planning to make tinier-scale adjustments merely sounds like it should incrementally improve quality. But when your short term sprints aren't informed by long-term planning, what happens is more like a random walk. Some sprints randomly add quality; some randomly reduce quality, and overall quality grows slowly, like sqrt(n) due to this random walk effect. I also see a lot of this No True Scotsman fallacy of saying "when implemented correctly" that Agile, seemingly by definition, cannot fail. The teams I've seen be most effective at delivering quality products quickly always just created their own methodologies, and they would scrap them and change them often particularly based on changing needs of the project, new personnel, and so forth. Instead of the Agile approach of trying to say there is a one-size-fits-all / cookie-cutter solution (e.g. just use this timeframe for every sprint, just use this way of dividing up work for every project, just use this way of measuring progress for every team, ...), productive teams seem to negotiate this stuff organically, and with common sense. Even teams that nominally used Agile but still managed to be productive did so precisely by only adhering to Agile as a ritual to appease managers, and outside of what managers wanted to see, the teams just eschewed Agile and found ways to be productive in spite of it. That may not be true everywhere, but it informs my experience in three different Agile organizations of varying sizes and ages.
- CPLX 11y agoThis is a write down, they could change the value on the books to basically any number they want assuming they can get an accountant to say it's not crazy. This has everything to do with Yahoo messing with its balance sheet and manufacturing an earnings number and very little to do with the value of an independent Tumblr.
- jliptzin 11y agoOnce again journalists writing about things they know nothing about and coming to conclusions they shouldn't be, such as standard wall st shenanigans/accounting games (not expecting much from buzzfeed). Another example: Every tech IPO that pops on day one is spun as a company in huge demand and doing so well when in reality it's just that the whole IPO was orchestrated in the first place for a huge first day pop so bankers could hand hefty returns to their most valuable clients.