6 ms·
This is another example of perverse, unintended consequences of "pro-worker" initiatives biting their intended beneficiaries in the hindquarters. Take a look a
by patio11 17y ago
This is another example of perverse, unintended consequences of "pro-worker" initiatives biting their intended beneficiaries in the hindquarters. Take a look at France for the endgame to that: between generous benefits and legally guaranteed protection from firing that makes Japanese salaryman positions look unstable, the economy is structurally incapable of employing a huge percentage of the work force. The young and immigrants, who are the worst affected by this (not surprising: the lowest skilled/lowest educated/poorest always catch the worst of every systemic economic issue), have little to do but sit on the dole or riot, and few prospects for ever doing anything else.
My impression is that similar issues cause the massive underemployment of the non-salaryman strata of Japanese twenty-somethings. Many of the freeters (people who bounce from part-time job to part-time job) are cut out for entry level work, but hiring someone is a lot like marrying them, so if you don't have the appropriate credential and a resume which looks like exactly what the company wants, they generally pass.
- Imprecate 17y agoIt also has negative effects for experienced workers: http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601109&sid=a3Esvz92Fko4 http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601109&sid=a3Es... Instead of being fired or laid off, employees are put into "Milton" type roles where they are made to feel useless, or intimidated into quitting/committing suicide. There's a line between workers' rights & social safety nets and making the employment market extremely inefficient. I think it's fair to use public funds to retrain employees who have spent years contributing to society, or even to provide them a temporary income so they don't have to worry for their family's future. Still, people generally want to do useful work, and keeping unproductive workers employed hurts them, other candidates, and the nation as a whole.
- eru 17y agoShouldn't you be able to buy unemployment insurance privately? (Okay, I know that may be a market for lemons because of the information asymmetries.. And you can't let people starve who haven't bought their insurance.)
- hga 17y agoI've read that was made illegal in the US.
- eru 17y agoInteresting. You mean private unemployment insurance? On what grounds?
- hga 17y agoYes, private unemployment insurance. I don't know what the excuse was (this happened a long time ago), but the effect is obvious (governments are the only ones that offer it). You can buy private disability insurance while the government offers the same thing through the Social Security Administration, but not private unemployment insurance in any form....
- eru 17y agoInteresting. What level of government banned the private unemployment insurance? I guess it was a federal law?
- ajross 17y agoYour solution is what? Abolish unemployment benefits? Fund them from general revenue instead of a targetted tax? I'm honestly curious. Your use of scare quotes in the first sentence tells me you're a typical political troll, but the rest of your post seems thoughtful. What's the fix here, or are you just trying to score a quick point?
- lukifer 17y agoIMHO, the solution is a full employment economy, with government(s) acting as the employer of last resort: http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/articles/2009/09/13/why_capitalism_fails/ http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/articles/2009/09/13/... While it smacks of communism to some, intuitively it makes more sense to pay the unemployed to do something, particularly if it builds infrastructure or trains workers in new skills.
- hga 17y agoWorking against that is the I gather widely held opinion that a lot of people don't get totally serious about getting a job until the unemployment benefits run out. Of course, when you have a secular horrible employment market like today's you've got a different problem. You've got to be careful here, set up the incentives wrong and you get an unsustainable European welfare state (particularly for us, given that we provide so much of the world's security). One other issue WRT a situation like today's: you've got to be careful that governments don't go bankrupt when revenues crater and social payments skyrocket due to a very nasty recession/depression.
- sethg 17y agoThe last (and, thank God, only) time I was laid off, I was serious about getting a job even before my severance pay ran out. Damn good thing, too, because the search took me ten months.
- brc 17y agointuitively yes I agree with you, however, the problem is that the building of infrastructure or worker training is done in the abscence of market signals. Hence the likelihood of a bridge to nowhere or an army of trained workers in a useless field is high. Certainly projects like the Hoover dam or interstate system have many positive externalities that last a long time - but it's not always easy to come up with these projects, and the labour involved is only a small percentage. When you divert productive capacity of the economy to unproductive use (such as building an unnecessary bridge) then society as a whole pays because of the diversion of resources (including labour and capital). The problem becomes more acute, because the 'shovel ready' projects are generally uneconomic ones - in many cases, if there was a positive return to be made from undertaking a certain activity, then the private sector will already have undertaken it. I think the best use for the paid-unemployed is in things that are labour intensive and help with society. Helping clean houses for new mothers with small children and old people would be one thing, because these activities are economically unviable and you wouldn't be putting anyone else out of work.
- irq11 17y agoOn the other hand, the Danes have a system where the workforce is extremely mobile, precisely because every worker is guaranteed up to four years of unemployment benefits. Employers are under no obligation to retain employees, because there's a great safety net. If we're going to talk about unintended consequences, we need to consider all sides: what is the unintended consequence of a system that provides no assurances to workers during economic downturns? I suspect the downside is quite harsh.
- patio11 17y agoYou have a curious definition of "all sides" in which the solution space appears to be "Impose European-style levels of benefits" XOR "Unemployed people starve in the snow." I am missing anybody here seriously proposing the second option. I suspect the downside to having employment-at-will, very modest unemployment benefits, and a liquid labor market exists. I also suspect that it can be measured in terms of objectively verifiable criteria, and compared with the alternatives. For example, I suspect that I can look in a US newspaper for a count of the number of cars burned last night by immigrants rioting over lack of economic opportunity. It will take me a whole lot of searching, because few newspapers publish articles titled "BREAKING! No riot today, either!" Then I could look at the same number in a French newspaper. (100 a day on quiet days, spiking to over a thousand on New Years or during periods of mass unrest. You might think I'm exaggerating. http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1869392,00.html http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1869392,00.htm... ) Alternatively, if counting riots seems a little messy, I could look at unemployment statistics for those under twenty five. In the United States, for youths at large, it is about 11~12% right now. In France, it is over 20 -- down a bit from a few years ago when it hit 25%. For socially disadvantaged groups in America, for example black males without a high school degree, it is about 48%. For similarly situated folks in France (for example, uneducated immigrants), unemployment is close to total.] I can go on if you want me to.
- irq11 17y agoI don't assume that the options are mutually exclusive. That said, I'm pragmatic enough to know that someone has to pay for a system like the Danes'. It comes at the expense of high taxes for all. But if we're talking about curious, all-or-nothing thinking, I have to wonder why you're so obsessively focused on the French? A quick Google search tells me that the unemployment rate in Denmark (horrible social welfare state and all), is only around 5%. Perhaps the problems in France are specific to France?
- shin_lao 17y agoThe problem in France is that you CANNOT fire people without an excellent reason. It's just illegal. You may be forced to hire back the person or give a totally ridiculous amount of money. There is however up to six months of probation during which you may let the person go for no real reason. It can unfortunately be a bit more complex than that and it's better to argument well when you fire even during the probation... As for employment compensation, it's around 7% of what you pay to your employees. When fired people have one year of compensation from the public unemployment insurance. I however think it's good that people don't end up with "nothing" when they lose their job, whatever the reason. Our real problem however is not here I think, the real problem is that when I want my engineer to receive 78 €, I have to pay 178 € including all taxes. On these 78 €, the engineer will pay around 20% - 30 % of income tax (up to 50% if he really makes a lot of money) and we have a 20% VAT on just about everything. fyi: I run my own company in France
- ovi256 17y agoI am pretty sure you are mistaken about firings being illegal, having witnessed firings. Yes, in France. Employment is certainly not "at will", but employers can fire for the usual reasons: economic causes, performance problems, incidents, the last one causing the employee to lose the safety net. I have witnessed mass engineer layoffs at a startup for economic reasons, and the employer was not on the hook for much. I have witnessed firing "for personal reasons" which can include differences about work tools or methodology. The ridiculous amount of money you cite is not huge at all, 20% of monthly salary for each year of work at the company (5 year with the company = one month of compensation). The employee can contest the firing at the French equivalent of the work board, but it's usually cut and dried. If that is what you are actually complaining about, about employment not being "at will", I do not have a good answer, other than it being a cultural difference that turns irrelevant in practice. I am wondering what is going on around here, relative to France. Both in HN and Times comments I have witnessed only ignorance (not a single knowledgeable comment) on French employment, laws, and worse, attitudes. It's not a worker's paradise, and nobody feels unnaturally entitled to their job. About the overhead, yeah, the patronal taxes suck badly.
- 17y ago
- ytinas 17y agoPersonally I find it more of an example of how screwed up the US government is at this point. They seem to ruin everything they try to do. A lot of other first world countries have reasonable protections for workers without killing the "little guy". I also don't buy your analysis of France. Large amounts of immigration always create a lot of unrest (just look at the otherwise pretty progressive Swedish).