2 ms·
> It's mostly not about banning encryption though. The debate mostly centers on regulating the products and services companies can provide to facilitate such co
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
> It's mostly not about banning encryption though. The debate mostly centers on regulating the products and services companies can provide to facilitate such communications.
Banning effective encryption, or banning commercial encryption, is still effectively banning encryption, or forcing it underground and casting suspicion on it.
> It's not the "government" versus "the people." It's a small group of people who strongly support surveillance, a small group who strongly oppose it, and a mushy middle that tends to lean towards whatever makes them feel safe. People in each group are represented within government, though for obvious reason people in the first group tend to gravitate toward positions involving national security or defense.
The people within government who oppose backdoors have yet to be very vocal, or effective. I'd certainly love to see a large outpouring of support from government, to counter the level of support for the pro-backdoor position.
- rayiner 11y agoThe former NSA head opposes encryption backdoors: http://www.networkworld.com/article/2990294/security/former-nsa-chief-undercuts-fbi-s-desire-for-encryption-backdoors.html http://www.networkworld.com/article/2990294/security/former-.... So has the current NSA director: http://www.digitaltrends.com/computing/nsa-director-actually-says-encryption-backdoors-are-a-bad-idea http://www.digitaltrends.com/computing/nsa-director-actually.... The White House Office of Science and Technology also opposed the FBI's proposal, which led to the White House tabling the idea: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/11/us/politics/obama-wont-seek-access-to-encrypted-user-data.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/11/us/politics/obama-wont-see.... Many people in the tech community don't want to get behind those in government who oppose back doors because they are not absolutist in their rhetoric about privacy. They want to assert there there is not even a debate to be had between security and privacy and that privacy should always win. But when the vast majority of the actual voting public is concerned just as much about safety as about privacy, if not more, that's not a tenable position for elected and appointed officials to take.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoFraming the issue as security/safety versus privacy would accept the rhetoric that keeping encryption legal and non-broken would reduce security/safety. (Which aligns with the similar rhetoric about pervasive surveillance.) The comments by the NSA director didn't seem to have any significant effect on the general government message. As for the White House position (which I had not seen the announcement of, so thank you for the link), they said they won't seek legislation, but they hardly need to at this point; those in Congress seem more than happy to keep proposing such legislation, and I've seen no suggestions that the White House would veto it if passed.