5 ms·
Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they don’t have to
- SwellJoe 11y agoI enjoy watching established players in industries that have exhibited decades of abusive behavior toward independent artists and consumers get stomped on by the new Internet economy. It's not that I necessarily think that in the end Amazon and Netflix will treat creators or consumers any better than Hollywood, though they might, it's hard to know yet. But, I think seeing the movie industry and the music industry (in particular, the music industry) kicked in the damned teeth until they cry for mercy is downright hilarious. Hollywood thinks they have money and power...until an Apple, or Google, or Amazon comes along and shows them what real economic clout looks like. Again, it may not end up better for creative folks or consumers, but it sure is funny while it's shaking out.
- vinceguidry 11y ago> Hollywood thinks they have money and power...until an Apple, or Google, or Amazon comes along and shows them what real economic clout looks like. Something I read once stuck with me. I don't remember the exact wording, but basically the movie industry's entire market, soup to nuts, is an order of magnitude less than just one of Disney's physical goods departments. An entire industry's market doesn't even hold a candle to one company's department. Hollywood is stranger than you could ever know. It makes a pitiful amount of money in relation to global capitalism, always has, always will. But it wields outsized influence on American policymaking regardless. Another quote comes to mind. When Apple released the Watch, someone asked one of the top watch companies if they were worried about Apple butting into their market. He just smiled and said something to the effect of, "Call me when they can figure out how to get men to wear diamonds on anything other than a watch." Established industries have spent long, long periods of time getting to know their customer. More often than not, they can take any upstart's best efforts and treat it as outsourced R&D. Netflix and Apple can succeed to their hearts content and still not have a prayer of unseating Hollywood.
- SwellJoe 11y agoI don't think luxury goods are at all a useful comparison to the various entertainment industries. I would argue entertainment is far closer to what Google/Amazon/Netflix/Apple are doing than it is to what jewelry makers are doing. And, I think it's too early to tell what'll happen to luxury watch makers. I think that cockiness is not well-founded. I'd be willing to bet that in a few more years, those traditional watches will be as common as cuff links. They'll still exist, but they won't be considered a standard part of people's every day wear, even people who buy and wear luxury goods. I do agree with you, however, that Hollywood and the entertainment industry wield way more political power than the size of their industry would indicate. They're good at lobbying, and they have a few friends in very high places (like Disney) to fight their battles for them, such as copyright terms, for example.
- vinceguidry 11y ago> I'd be willing to bet that in a few more years, those traditional watches will be as common as cuff links. I'm not sure where you're getting this from. Traditional watches have seen way more potential challengers than just the Apple Watch, and managed to survive nonetheless. You can think "yeah, but this time it's different," but try to think of it from the point of view of somebody whose been making and selling watches to people his whole life in an industry that's been making and selling watches for hundreds of years, as part of a company that's probably been around for at least a hundred years itself. These guys know a thing or two about why people buy watches.
- SwellJoe 11y agoBut, try to think of it from the point of view of somebody who's been making and selling wagon wheels to people his whole life in an industry that's been making and selling wagon wheels for hundreds of years, as part of a company that's probably been around for at least a hundred years itself. These guys know a thing or two about why people buy wagon wheels. Sometimes, things change.
- 11y ago
- Arnt 11y agoPerhaps you meant to say "it may not end up better for the creative films, the consumers, the indie cinemas or streaming sites, but it sure is funny while it's shaking out". That said, I've no idea whether Netflix is buying/wants to buy the rights to so much that it actually might bother sites like Mubi (where I work, FWIW) or Fandor. Somehow I doubt it.
- mwsherman 11y agoCommoditize complements until you run out of complements (for which one shouldn’t hold one’s breath).
- Steko 11y agoNetflix and Amazon are doing what Murdoch did in the 90's when he massively outbid CBS (by over $100 million/year) to get the NFL on FOX: he wasn't just buying football games, he was buying a ticket to the big time network business and simultaneously shutting doors for other fledgling channels from Warners and Paramount that were following FOX's path.
- JackFr 11y agoOverpaying for the NFL was also a message to the affiliates, that we have deep pockets and are in this for real.