5 ms·
Prior to the Internet, cipher schemes existed that could delay or foil the best government analysts, and that took significant government efforts to even attemp
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
Prior to the Internet, cipher schemes existed that could delay or foil the best government analysts, and that took significant government efforts to even attempt to crack. It was never illegal to use such a code and transmit the result on a letter, postcard, or phone. And a government warrant would not compel the decipherment of such a scheme, unless someone had possession of a physical key usable for decipherment.
The two differences now: we've made that technology available to non-experts, and we hope that no amount of government effort can crack the scheme (as opposed to obtaining the key).
I agree with your comment that it's not a "fake crisis", though. It's one with only one right answer, but it's a "crisis" in the sense that no possible path forward will make both parties happy, so we fundamentally need the government to either realize they're wrong or to lose. Government positions don't change easily, and governments do not like to lose.
While it bothers me to see terms like "common ground" used, as they imply that both positions have grounds worth considering, I do think one of the few paths that has a hope of success is to convince the government that there exists a position they can adopt that doesn't look like it goes back on their current stance.
- rayiner 11y agoIt's mostly not about banning encryption though. The debate mostly centers on regulating the products and services companies can provide to facilitate such communications. If there was a precursor to companies promising to make it easy for regular joe criminal to encrypt his postal mail, it's conceivable that the government would have fracked down on those companies. > It's one with only one right answer, but it's a "crisis" in the sense that no possible path forward will make both parties happy, so we fundamentally need the government to either realize they're wrong or to lose. Government positions don't change easily, and governments do not like to lose. It's not the "government" versus "the people." It's a small group of people who strongly support surveillance, a small group who strongly oppose it, and a mushy middle that tends to lean towards whatever makes them feel safe. People in each group are represented within government, though for obvious reason people in the first group tend to gravitate toward positions involving national security or defense.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> The debate mostly centers on regulating the products and services companies can provide to facilitate such communications. You're calling them products but the relevant thing they want to regulate is still more speech. If you want to communicate with your friends in code then you first have to communicate the code itself. In this context the code is code, but code is speech.
- rayiner 11y agoCode is not speech any more than electronic circuits are speech. That is to say that in unique contexts when the code is itself a means of expression code may be speech,[1] but not when it is used to build something that enables communication. [1] Bricks can also be expression in unique contexts. That doesn't mean that bricks are speech.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoA brick or electronic circuit is speech when being used as a medium of expression. Code is speech all the time because it can't be anything else. It's pure information. You can't email someone a brick. It happens we have machines that will turn that information into action, but the code isn't the machine or the action. It's just a type of speech that machines can understand too. People are always wanting to regulate speech by combining it with a machine, but the machine and the speech are separate. They don't have any specific relationship. Apple makes a) a general purpose computer and b) computer software. But (modulo DRM/copyright) you could run that software on any general purpose computer and use that general purpose computer to run any software. It's like trying to regulate what information you can print in a newspaper by claiming you're regulating the printing press.
- harryh 11y agoA piece of encryption software is clearly both. It is speech. If you wanted to you could even go find the source code and translate it into english in such a way that a relatively competent programmer could turn it back into code ("If the first bit in the byte is 1 then do .... other wise do ...."). But it's clearly also a tool. I've never read the source code to the software I use to encrypt my hard drive. It's unlikely that I ever will. I just care that it does the job I want it to. Trying to say that it's either one or the other is silly. It's both. But just because it's speech doesn't mean that the government might not have an interest in regulating it. The first amendment is not absolute. I can imagine a great many prima facie arguments supporting the idea of regulating encryption software. The fact that code is speech is not, in and of itself, a defense against any of them. As with most cases of constitutional law, it comes down to weighing competing interests. Failing to acknowledge these varying interests fails to acknowledge the actual question at hand.
- Qantourisc 11y ago"possible path forward will make both parties happy" -> We only have to make 1 party happy: the 'people', as the government (should) serve them.