15 ms·
This fake crisis of "Going Dark" as if we haven't been that way for all of time before the Internet is dangerous. The "scary" notion that the police won't be a
by CapitalistCartr 11y ago
This fake crisis of "Going Dark" as if we haven't been that way for all of time before the Internet is dangerous. The "scary" notion that the police won't be able to read everything about everyone is being recast by the Feds as if it really is national crisis. Benjamin Wittes suggests on Lawfare we make Common Carrier Immunity conditional on the company being able to make all data available in the clear to the government. This is dangerous ground.
https://www.lawfareblog.com/out-box-approach-going-dark-problem https://www.lawfareblog.com/out-box-approach-going-dark-prob...
- hellbanner 11y agoI think (most) of us on HN are on the same page here. But we are a minority... many people truly don't care and are not incentivized to care.
- danharaj 11y agoi think people are incentivized not to care, which is subtly different but far more pernicious.
- izacus 11y agoFor pretty much any political issue the people caring are a minority (on each side) with middle being populated with people who don't care or don't know what's going on. Those people on the sides that do care then shape the debate and ultimately the outcome of pretty much any democratic decision (as little as those are still left).
- laotzu 11y ago"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has." -Margaret Mead
- bobby_9x 11y agoEven look at public wifi. Most non-tech savvy people I know really have no problem using piblic wifi to conduct business and login into important accounts. They want the path of least resistance, which isn‘t good for security or privacy.
- obrero 11y agoThe facts which Wittes gives are way off. He links to "civil suits against the companies who provide service to ISIS and other bad guys". The civil suit is regarding a Jordanian police officer who shot and killed an American military contractor. Other than this lawsuit, almost nothing is linking the officer to ISIS. If you read the lawsuit, they really have nothing linking this officer to ISIS either, other than a vague statement from a supposedly official ISIS source. So the link to this military contractor's death to ISIS is very tenuous. This has to be established first, and there is almost nothing to establish it on - he was a Jordanian police officer, not an ISIS militant. Then you have to say Twitter is engaged in running afoul of material support of terrorism laws. These laws generally would mean something along the lines of that in some back office of Twitter, Jack Dorsey was storing up Kalashnikov rifles which he was going to ship to the Taliban in order to assault American bases there. In 1929, the Republican (!) Secretary of State rolled up all the old World War I spying operations saying "Gentlemen do not read each other's mail". How far the US has fallen in freedom from the day Stimson uttered those words a century ago.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mirimir 11y agoRepublicans in 1929 were more or less what we today call libertarians. Or maybe Victorians. Honor, and all that.
- munin 11y ago> In 1929, the Republican (!) Secretary of State rolled up all the old World War I spying operations saying "Gentlemen do not read each other's mail". How far the US has fallen in freedom from the day Stimson uttered those words a century ago. He also turned it all back on, to 11, as the secretary of war, once stuff heated up in Europe.
- rayiner 11y agoWhile I oppose things like encryption backdoors, I think it's disingenuous to say this is a "fake crisis." The 4th amendment has always required balancing security and privacy--that's why the distinction between "unreasonable searches" and reasonable ones appears right there in the text. And society has always balanced those two interests with a simple mechanism: the police can only search with a warrant, but once they have a warrant their power to search is nearly limitless. Thus, the government has always had a way to search the long-distance communications mechanisms of its day. Wiretapping telegraph or telephone lines was not deemed a violation of the 4th amendment until 1967. Even after that, a wiretap was authorized with a warrant. Now, you have a pervasive mechanism of long-distance communications, and it's increasingly opaque to the government, even with a warrant. That's an unprecedented state of affairs.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoPrior to the Internet, cipher schemes existed that could delay or foil the best government analysts, and that took significant government efforts to even attempt to crack. It was never illegal to use such a code and transmit the result on a letter, postcard, or phone. And a government warrant would not compel the decipherment of such a scheme, unless someone had possession of a physical key usable for decipherment. The two differences now: we've made that technology available to non-experts, and we hope that no amount of government effort can crack the scheme (as opposed to obtaining the key). I agree with your comment that it's not a "fake crisis", though. It's one with only one right answer, but it's a "crisis" in the sense that no possible path forward will make both parties happy, so we fundamentally need the government to either realize they're wrong or to lose. Government positions don't change easily, and governments do not like to lose. While it bothers me to see terms like "common ground" used, as they imply that both positions have grounds worth considering, I do think one of the few paths that has a hope of success is to convince the government that there exists a position they can adopt that doesn't look like it goes back on their current stance.
- rayiner 11y agoIt's mostly not about banning encryption though. The debate mostly centers on regulating the products and services companies can provide to facilitate such communications. If there was a precursor to companies promising to make it easy for regular joe criminal to encrypt his postal mail, it's conceivable that the government would have fracked down on those companies. > It's one with only one right answer, but it's a "crisis" in the sense that no possible path forward will make both parties happy, so we fundamentally need the government to either realize they're wrong or to lose. Government positions don't change easily, and governments do not like to lose. It's not the "government" versus "the people." It's a small group of people who strongly support surveillance, a small group who strongly oppose it, and a mushy middle that tends to lean towards whatever makes them feel safe. People in each group are represented within government, though for obvious reason people in the first group tend to gravitate toward positions involving national security or defense.