3 ms·
Sure, but the magnitude of that cost matters a lot. You were saying a dollar or two in raw materials to protect against 100W, now you're saying three or four ce
by mikeash 11y ago
Sure, but the magnitude of that cost matters a lot. You were saying a dollar or two in raw materials to protect against 100W, now you're saying three or four cents. A few cents to protect hundreds of dollars in equipment from electrical faults seems worthwhile to me.
- teraflop 11y agoThat makes sense from the consumer's point of view. But imagine you're a manufacturer, producing USB device controller chips by the million. Would you really be willing to spend tens of thousands of dollars to protect against a failure mode that can only happen due to some other company's extreme negligence?
- mikeash 11y agoYes, but of course it doesn't matter what I think. It's not abnormal to add protection that isn't needed when everything works properly. As noted elsewhere, the USB spec already requires resettable overcurrent protection, for example.
- knughit 11y agoTens of thousands of dollars total is far less than it costs a company just to moot the question.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- krapht 11y agoSorry I was not clear in my comments. The dollar solution is for some type of crowbar circuit. This is the most robust solution. The 3-4 cents is for specifically, reverse polarity protection when somehow, a -5V differential is applied to device power inputs. This cheaper solution only narrowly addresses this particular power fault, and no others.
- mikeash 11y agoI see! A dollar per port for robust protection against a wide variety of faults sounds pretty good to me, but I know that sort of stuff doesn't sell well when people compare primarily on price. Do I assume correctly that a fuse for overcurrent protection wont act quickly enough to save the hardware in the event of reverse polarity?