3 ms·
You'd still need a strong enough structure to hold up to the launch, telemetry system to track it and a vacuum stage with enough precision to place it in a phas
by rtkwe 11y ago
You'd still need a strong enough structure to hold up to the launch, telemetry system to track it and a vacuum stage with enough precision to place it in a phased orbit with the shuttle so Columbia would have a chance to come get it. But at that point you're eating into the fuel the Columbia needs to maintain orbit. It's been a while since I read the article (Ars has done a piece on this before) and I haven't read the report but I don't think there's a number for how long the orbit could be maintained.
- mikeash 11y agoI don't think Columbia needed any significant amount of fuel to maintain orbit. At these altitudes, orbital decay is a matter of months or years. The report says that it "would have been placed in a tail-down gravity gradient attitude that would require very little propellant." According to the accident report, the time in orbit was limited by breathing consumables, specifically the lithium hydroxide used to remove CO2, and the onboard oxygen. Both were probably good for about 30 days.
- rtkwe 11y agoYeah I knew the other human consumables were the main issue that's right there in the article. I didn't know and didn't want to assume how long the orbit would last though since it didn't seem to be covered with a specific time. Also even if it was a small amount how much would be eaten up rendezvousing with a hypothetical dumb supply bag?
- mikeash 11y agoI think the major propellant need is for deorbiting, which would dwarf all other needs. Attitude control is probably close enough to zero to be ignorable. The big question is how much would be required to rendezvous, and I don't have even the slightest idea there. They clearly thought there was enough to rendezvous with Atlantis, but it's a whole different game when the other craft is under active control and can also maneuver. The report says Columbia had 448fps of propellant available. The deorbit burn was at least 200fps, so that leaves at most 248fps for other uses. The rendezvous burn plans listed in the report for the hypothetical Atlantis rescue list propellant use of over 300fps which is clearly too much if rendezvousing with the dumb supply bag is even comparable, let alone worse. The report does mention this briefly, discussing an Ariane 4 that was almost ready to go at the time. It says, "The challenge with developing a supply kit, building an appropriate housing and separation system, and reprogramming the Ariane seems very difficult in three weeks..." but doesn't mention the feasibility of rendezvousing with that housing. Whether that's because it can be done or because it's not even worth looking at that sort of detail I don't know, but I'd bet on the latter.