3 ms·
Here here. As it is a snow day, I can't get the other articles as well or do a good search (Fallout4 for me, oh shucks). That said, just because there are onl
by Balgair 11y ago
Here here.
As it is a snow day, I can't get the other articles as well or do a good search (Fallout4 for me, oh shucks).
That said, just because there are only 4 people in a study does not mean that it is a bad article. I agree that the guy is maybe a quack, but that can be said of a lot of scientists too. Truth has a different metric than the opinions of people. That there is only 4 subjects is not all that off in biology, especially in humans. For instance, in the hearing pathway, there is a single layer of neurons that helps mediate the location of low frequency noises in mammals. The Nature Letter that revealed this was done on 4 cells total. The difficulty of the experiment was extreme. Sectioning brains at essentially random, probing neurons perfectly from the input and output neurons to those special neurons, all at body temperature, and in mature animals, it took that team 10 years for 4 neurons. ALL of them now are bakers in Germany; they quit science.
So, though the guy may be a quack, and though this experiment may not be as hard, it does not mean he is necessarily wrong.
- bkmartin 11y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Any depression study with only 4 people is not extraordinary considering the pervasiveness of the issue in society.