4 ms·
I want to know how bankers would handle negative salaries. Edit: Sorry if that sounded snarky, it was my attempt at a witty way of saying, "it doesn't make sen
by SilasX 11y ago
I want to know how bankers would handle negative salaries.
Edit: Sorry if that sounded snarky, it was my attempt at a witty way of saying, "it doesn't make sense for there to be a negative price for provision of a scarce good, imagine if we did that to labor, like yours".
- dragontamer 11y agoSour Crude in some areas of the US hit negative values a few weeks ago. It means that supply has grossly outstripped demand, and that storage of the good has become the primary cost. In the case of banking, it means that liquid cash has become so worthless (ie: too many people are saving money) such that the Banks are now charging you for the privilege of keeping the money safe.
- SilasX 11y agoEven so, something is fundamentally wrong if markets are signaling, "no, we'd rather you not lend us money to work with", even if the fix lies somewhere else. We should never be at a state where "forgoing the use of money so that others can invest it" is a non-scarce good. (A charge merely for having physical banknotes on demand can make sense, of course.) In contrast, there are sane worldstates that correspond to "sour crude provides economic value less than its upkeep cost".
- dragontamer 11y agoYes. Which is why this is a stress test. Will the banks survive a financial crisis if the entire world switched over to negative rates? Well, the Fed wants to know, which is why they're running this doomsday test scenario. The Fed currently expects to raise rates about 2 or 3 more times this year btw... so the scenario probably won't happen, but that doesn't change the fact that lead bankers are preparing for the worst. In other words, the article is simply stating the following fact: big banks in America are thinking about various financial doomsday scenarios. I don't think that's a bad thing at all.
- SilasX 11y agoFair enough, I assumed the angle was less "hey let's kick the tires" and more "the Fed wants to make interest rates negative", since a lot of economists have been recommending the latter.
- valakon 11y agoIn the scenario described, money is no longer a scarce good. At 0%, they couldn't give it away (to banks). When it is negative, the fed is paying banks to take it.
- SilasX 11y agoEven then, negative doesn't make sense as a market price. Give me X dollars, and I only have to return Y such that Y is less than X? "I'll have infinity, thanks!"