6 ms·
I think getting the news out about this research could be very important as many people could seek more heavy handed treatment for tiredness, depression and anx
by visarga 11y ago
I think getting the news out about this research could be very important as many people could seek more heavy handed treatment for tiredness, depression and anxiety, not knowing the cause was a simple mineral deficiency.
I used to feel tired all the time, with permanent pain in the neck and the retinas, even though I slept 7 hours a night. After I started taking magnesium, I felt 15 years younger. I could finally get a good night's sleep and my energy recovered. There were also other effects: my sex drive increased, dandruff almost disappeared and my bowel movements have improved.
Another useful mineral for me was Calcium. I got rid of a nagging back pain that affected me for the last 10 years. Other treatments such as massage and exercise had no effect.
It feels like doctors had no idea to check for these two minerals in my case. Even though I visited various specialists and went to a sleep lab to test my brain waves, they had no useful recommendations. Could it be true that doctors have no idea about magnesium and calcium?
- 6stringmerc 11y agoRegarding your question at the end - I firmly believe that doctors and day-to-day medical professionals traditionally despise discussions regarding supplementation. This his extremely anecdotal of course, but there seems to be some kind of 'wall' - probably on purpose - where medical professionals believe that only the knowledge on the inside of the wall has merit. This can be seen in the marketing/'re-evaluation' of opiates like Oxycontin, where once the establishment type leadership said it was okay, a lot of doctors started writing up scripts with this encouragement, and now the US is in the grips of a horrible addiction crisis. It's not that medical professionals don't appreciate healthy living - it's that I frankly don't believe they're trained to promote healthy living. Rather, they treat symptoms. Some things are easier to figure out than others, and anything outside of the 'wall' is more often than not viewed in a negative light.
- carbocation 11y agoIt's really just that most nutritional supplements have either low-quality supporting data or contradictory data. The hype surrounding the field of nutrition is not matched by its benefits. This is not to say that there is no future for it. Rather, it is to say that there is a huge future for it, because at present the field has little to offer backed by strong evidence.
- petra 11y agoEven if there's not enough data, the risk of supplements is very low , especially compared to the risk of pharmaceuticals.So why not try ? And the reason they don't have as much high-quality proof as pharmaceutical(clinical trials), is just because of monetary incentives, nothing more.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoPart of me agrees with the monetary aspect, but history and current events have shown that the medical community still doesn't even have solid footing for a lot of 'simple' type issues. Nutrition seems to be a relatively new area of study, as evidenced by the seemingly routine changes in 'official' dietary recommendations. I do think the medical profession is working to incorporate nutrition into their concepts of treatment, but it's going to take a lot of time.
- carbocation 11y agoWhen we talk about pharmaceuticals, we talk about financial toxicity. Americans spend over $10 billion on nutritional supplements annually [1], most of which have very poor supporting evidence. Should people be able to spend their money how they see fit? Sure. Are they getting utility from it? Not the utility they're hoping for. 1 = https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/02/04/americans-are-ignoring-the-science-and-spending-billions-on-dietary-supplements/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/02/04/ameri...
- 6stringmerc 11y agoI'm not denying there's a lot of unsubstantiated or over-inflated advertising within the supplement market, not at all. It takes hours and lots of digging into personal reviews and other sources to begin to find things that are both 1) effective and 2) legal. It's not a quick fix, which is what most advertising claims to provide. If we're talking about wasting money and health though, then I think it's equally important to point out that homeopathy is apparently a multi-billion dollar industry as well in the US ($6B in 2012 [1]) and if we're going to rank things on effectiveness, I'm pretty sure homeopathy is just about on par with drinking water from a clean toilet. [1] http://www.nutraceuticalsworld.com/issues/2013-07/view_industry-news/us-sales-of-homeopathic-herbal-remedies-reach-64-billion http://www.nutraceuticalsworld.com/issues/2013-07/view_indus...
- DanBC 11y ago> This can be seen in the marketing/'re-evaluation' of opiates like Oxycontin, where once the establishment type leadership said it was okay, a lot of doctors started writing up scripts with this encouragement, and now the US is in the grips of a horrible addiction crisis. To be fair with doctors when someone goes along and says "I have crippling back pain" and gets told "You need to lose weight and exercise" they bad mouth that doctor online and then they go to a different doctor.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoWell, sure, but the patient doesn't write the script so they're not the one with the power, and if it was 'medically approved' to tell patients how to change their diet, what types of exercise would help, then the patient would simply waste their time going from doctor to doctor getting the same response. Thus the medical community is complicit in taking 'the easy way' in this instance. I'm not a fan of for-profit medicine, which could be somewhat responsible for the patient entitlement complex fueled by commercials which say 'Ask your doctor' but probably mean more along the lines of 'tell your doctor to give it to you' in practical terms.
- cpfohl 11y agoI don't think it's half as bad as you seem to think. My wife's an NP, so I have an inside view of Syracuse, NY's medical situation. There's two issues at hand: 1. The quality of evidence for most supplements ranges somewhere between Bigfoot and Flat-Earth society. That's not to say it's all bad, but it's generally unstudied and unproven. That being said: it's standard practice to strongly recommend vitamin D supplements for us northerners. That's reasonably new, high quality supplement data and it's not ignored. There's no bias for these types of medical practitioners, the data's just not there. 2. A lot of older docs are untrained when it comes to new studies about various things: pain meds (don't use them), alternative pain management (can be useful), H. Pylori (a proven explanation for stomach ulcers). These docs don't keep up to date. They're otherwise excellent doctors. Most of them care deeply about their patients and are fiercely defensive of them and their care (exceptions abound, but giving people the benefit of the doubt is a good way to live life a lot happier). There's tons that's wrong with our medical system, try not to generalize it too far. Also tell your doctor about ALL supplements you take. Some can react terribly with other medications and supplements.
- 6stringmerc 11y ago1. Elsewhere I definitely agree that advertising and claims in the supplement world are a real bothersome issue. However the exact same criticism can be levied at the official medical community which has a habit of prescribing lots of different drugs for things such as "restless leg syndrome" or in the case of Lyrica, advertising it for all sorts of different applications until one finally gets market traction. Selling quick fixes is a long, glamorous and shady business. Also, in my experience, a good deal of the actual, effective supplements that have been on the market are now illegal for suspect reasons. As in, because it actually works we're going to ban it. 2. A lot of older docs are pretty much what I was getting at, re: the 'wall' of knowledge. They've got long, strong careers in medicine doing things the way they've always done them, occasionally updating their knowledge but not really putting in a lot of effort. That breeds 'know it all syndrome' which, again anecdotally, tends to be a little bit more prevalent in that professional field.
- bkmartin 11y ago
- losteric 11y agoBig pharma push doctors to use their regulated or protected pills. Who pushes vitamins and minerals?
- SeanDav 11y agoFrom the abstract: > "Dietary deficiencies of magnesium, coupled with excess calcium and stress may..." Looks like Calcium may be part of the problem, not the solution. Although it is perfectly possible that in your case you had a Calcium deficiency and benefited from extra Calcium. If nothing else, this highlights the fact that people are different!
- visarga 11y agoCalcium and magnesium work together, calcium is necessary for the activity of the nervous system and magnesium for regulating the calcium. I felt no ill effects when taking both, their positive effects seem to add up. Perhaps I had a deficit for both of them. You can test if you have deficit by taking a supplement for a week and if yo feel better, then it means you had a deficiency, but otherwise if you run a blood test it could come out inconclusive (I am not a doctor).
- mamon 11y agoCalcium and magnesium may work together, but they also compete for being absorbed in our bowels, so it's better not to take them at the same time. I'm sure that many people don't know this, but they know that "calcium is good" and "magnesium is good", so they eat a lot of both, not experiencing the positive effects they hope for. Btw. the same is true for zinc and calcium.
- Flow 11y agoHow many mg magnesium do you take and when do you take it?
- visarga 11y agoI take the daily recommended dosage which is marked on the container of the meds, which comes about 400mg/day. It is important to select the right type of magnesium, as they come in many forms (oxide, citrate, taurate, malate etc). I used magnesium citrate. Magnesium oxide is very common but has less efficiency. If you take too much it could cause diarrhea.
- logfromblammo 11y agoYou can make your own magnesium bicarbonate solution by adding 90 mL milk of magnesia (Mg(OH)2 aq. susp.) to 2 L carbonated water. This has a taste to it. Some people find it unpleasant, but I think it is tolerable. I have also used magnesium diascorbate. The anion does affect the absorption of the magnesium, so 1g of Mg in MgO is not going to have the same effectiveness as 1g of Mg in magnesium citrate. Also, zinc supplementation interferes with magnesium absorption. Generally speaking, the aqueous solubility of the compound predicts absorption rate by the body. MgO and MgSO4 (epsom salt) are cheap, but poorly absorbed. They will have a laxative effect. Your entire body has about 25 g of Mg in it, and your kidneys drop about 120 mg of it per day into your urine if you are not deficient. Low magnesium cannot be detected by a blood test unless you are abysmally deficient; the best way is probably a urinary clearance test.
- nikolay 11y agoAfter doing some research, I found that magnesium lactate is the cheapest, most bioavailable, and the supplement with fewer side effects. For example, orotate, taurate, malate, glycinate, and others can give you extra amino acids and you can overdose or break the balance.