4 ms·
I like that idea but I do worry about it causing rear-end collisions. In an ideal world drivers wouldn't speed and they also wouldn't tailgate, but in the worl
by Someone1234 11y ago
I like that idea but I do worry about it causing rear-end collisions.
In an ideal world drivers wouldn't speed and they also wouldn't tailgate, but in the world we currently occupy both are extremely common (even amongst law enforcement).
So while this would act to reduce speeding, the unpredictability may increase accidents and it is definitely going to reduce traffic flow.
- phn 11y agoRear-end collisions are the responsibility of the person behind. If they're keeping the correct distance, there's plenty of time to stop without collisions. Usually the lights are also a good distance after the radar so you have plenty of time to go from speeding to a halt :)
- jld89 11y agoWell I imagined that it would turn red but at the same time give enough time to the driver to break. So the detector would be at least 300m or 400m from the light.
- kraftman 11y agoHow would it be any different from a normal red light?
- mikeash 11y agoRear end collisions like this tend to be pretty benign. For example, one of the arguments against red light cameras is that they actually increase the number of accidents. However, they also increase safety. How? Because while they increase the number of rear end collisions, they decrease the number of side impact collisions, which are much more deadly. Net result: more bent metal, less bent flesh. I'd also be surprised if speed-sensing lights really increased collisions much. They still go through a full yellow before turning red. They are only more unpredictable if you know the light's cycle time, watched it turn green, and are carefully timing it so you could otherwise predict it.
- ape4 11y agoYes, I thought that about this issue too. Perhaps more distinct signage and early warning lights might get cars to slow before the red.
- mikeash 11y agoThat's how I've seen them installed. For example: https://www.google.com/maps/@38.8393523,-77.0661647,3a,75y,332.5h,91.34t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sUyF8MMUp2_K4oCZnH3eOkg!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@38.8393523,-77.0661647,3a,75y,3... Of course, if I've seen them without any signs then I wouldn't even know it....
- NetStrikeForce 11y agoThese are usually on blinking orange while you approach, warning that they might go red at any time. Most drivers unconsciously slow down and I haven't seen a rear-ending on these lights for more than 30 years.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>I like that idea but I do worry about it causing rear-end collisions. Chicago had a pretty significant red light camera deployment about six or seven years ago. Drivers used to be okay with blowing through a red that was a yellow a moment before in the past. Now everyone slams on their brakes when they see a yellow. According to time.com, "a 22% increase in injuries from rear-end accidents." So yes, you can expect more rear end collisions and injuries when traffic light enforcement automation breaks up traditional driving habits. Arguably, its okay to speed. Say doing 50 in a 40 when there's no traffic, like late at night. Why do we need a system to enforce this? I wish there was more fuzzy logic applied to traffic systems. Say a peak hours vs non-peak hours speed limit. Longer yellows during rush hour when everyone is stressed and potentially distracted. Instead we get hard and fast rules for all conditions, which doesn't make much sense. http://time.com/3643077/red-light-cams-rear-end-collisions-chicago/ http://time.com/3643077/red-light-cams-rear-end-collisions-c...
- bryanlarsen 11y agoYou omitted the fact that it reduced injuries by 15% from side-swipe collisions. The Time omitted the fact that side-swipe collisions tend to have more serious injuries than rear-end collisions. They also failed to mention that red light cameras reduce the number of pedestrian and bicycle collisions.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoThe article certainly mentions the holistic view here: "Taken together, the study shows a statistically insignificant increase of injuries by 5%." Time's source is the Tribune: http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/watchdog/redlight/ct-red-light-camera-safety-met-20141219-story.html#page=1 http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/watchdog/redlight/ct-red-... Emanuel has credited the cameras for a 47 percent reduction in dangerous right-angle, or "T-bone," crashes. But the Tribune study, which accounted for declining accident rates in recent years as well as other confounding factors, found cameras reduced right-angle crashes that caused injuries by just 15 percent. At the same time, the study calculated a corresponding 22 percent increase in rear-end crashes that caused injuries, illustrating a trade-off between the cameras' costs and benefits. The researchers also determined there is no safety benefit from cameras installed at intersections where there have been few crashes with injuries. Such accidents actually increased at those intersections after cameras went in, the study found, though the small number of crashes makes it difficult to determine whether the cameras were to blame. >They also failed to mention that red light cameras reduce the number of pedestrian and bicycle collisions. From what I can tell, no one has done a study on that and it sounds questionable to me to see any results there. In fact, Chicago has a big problem with cyclists hitting pedestrians since it added so many bike lanes. But that's a discussion for another time I suppose and a problem that'll probably take care of itself as cyclists and pedestrians get used to each other.